If you were to come visit my school the first thing you’d notice is that most of the students are Black. I have been going to Erasmus Hall HS for three and a half years, and so far I haven’t had a class with a White student. In fact I don’t think I’ve ever seen a White student in my school. The only White people I see are the teachers.
Why are there so few Whites and Asians at Erasmus? Student Marlon Beckford, 18, said that “Since communities are still segregated, so are schools.”
Lisa Dudley, 17, also of Erasmus, agreed. “It’s because of the zoning process,” said Lisa. “When the zoning line gets to a White neighborhood it stops. We should be able to choose for a high school like we choose for college, because zoning segregates.”
In February, I got a chance to visit Roslyn HS, a suburban school on Long Island. It was the opposite of Erasmus. There were hardly any Black students in the school. The classes I visited were mostly White with a few Asians. I was the only Black in the classes I attended.
It’s Economics
I asked Ealiss Bell, 16, of Roslyn HS, why there were so few Blacks and Hispanics at her school. “Most of the people who live around here are Jewish,” she said. Josh Kaufman, 15, also of Roslyn HS, added that “It’s because of the economics in the community and few Black families move to the community.”
The races of the students weren’t the only things different about Erasmus and Roslyn. Physically Erasmus doesn’t look good. There are broken chairs, broken windows covered with a board of wood, broken desks, and so on. Imagine how your room would look like if you never cleaned it for 20 years, never got new furniture, wrote all over the place, stuck gum under your desk and on the floor. That’s exactly how Erasmus looks.
Roslyn HS is in much better condition. The desks and chairs were not broken in any way and there was nothing written on them. The school only has 800 students but it has three cafeterias, and five study centers where students can go after school and have a teacher help them with math, science, social studies, English, or foreign languages. The library has two floors, with a lot of books, a lot of librarians, and 17 computers. Most of the classes I visited there had between 15 and 22 students. Erasmus has more than 3,000 students and my classes have up to 35 students.
Black Students Get Neglected
Why is Roslyn in so much better shape than Erasmus? Lisa Dudley says that our school gets neglected because most of the students are Black. “Let me give you an example,” she said. “In the eleventh grade I was taking an RCT test, and it was so cold that we had to write with our gloves on because the windows were broken. But in a White school the repairs would have been done quickly.” There were no broken windows at Roslyn or anything else that needed to be repaired, as far as I could see.
I asked other students what they thought the differences are between schools that are almost all White and schools that are almost all Black. Marlon Beckford said, “It’s the funding…White schools get more money because White people have all the money. Go to a White school, and you’ll see that they have better computers, better books, and the school looks great.”
Marlon’s right. According to the Educational Priorities Panel, a group that studies state and city funding for public education, Roslyn spent an average of $12,822 on each student during the 1988-89 school year. New York City spent about $6,730 on each of its students that year.
What’s the Difference?
But the students at Roslyn seemed unaware of how much more is being spent on their education. When I asked them what they thought the difference was between a mostly Black and a mostly White school, they just mentioned the people. One student said the students at a Black school are more diverse. Another said that he would be scared to attend my school, because people like people of the same background, and since he’s Jewish he wouldn’t feel comfortable.
But their principal knew how much more they were getting. Mark Wayne has been the principal of Roslyn HS for seven years. Before that, he was principal of Thomas Jefferson HS in Brooklyn. He told me that when he was at Jefferson and asked the superintendent for something the school needed, the answer he got was “maybe.” But in Roslyn when he asks the superintendent for something the answer is almost always “yes.” And when the superintendent can’t get something that the school needs, the parents buy it for the school themselves, Mr. Wayne said.
Who’s responsible for New York City schools not getting as many resources as schools like Roslyn? Eon Parks, 18, of Erasmus, said that everyone should share the blame. “The Board of Ed. needs better methods of teaching to keep kids in school. The teachers should have more concern for the students. The parents need to get more involved in their children’s education. When these three combine it makes the student better.”
It’s Not Fair
Some people don’t believe that schools are segregated, but they cannot deny the fact that most New York City public schools have a majority of Black and Hispanic students, while public schools in a wealthy suburb like Roslyn have mostly White students. And schools with a majority of White students tend to look a whole lot better than schools like mine.
I’m always hearing about how “students are America’s future.” Does that include all of us or just the ones from wealthy communities like Roslyn? Roslyn HS looks great; why can’t Erasmus look like that? Aren’t the students at Erasmus part of America too? I don’t think it’s fair that schools with a majority of White students get treated better than schools with a majority of minority students.
SIDEBAR: Suburbia Is a Real Trip
I went to visit Roslyn HS on Long Island in February to find out how a White suburban school is different from a New York City school. When I got off the train to Roslyn, I was kind of nervous. I was saying to myself, “What if while I’m walking to the school, I run into some White boys who want to make me another Yusuf Hawkins?” What really made me nervous was the fact that I didn’t know the neighborhood, so if I had to run, I would have gotten lost. But as I walked to the school, I saw that the neighborhood was quiet so I began to feel safe. One of the most impressive things about the school is that it has separate fields for all the sports it’s involved in. There’s a football field, a track for running, tennis courts, etc. Inside, I saw a lot of trophies. All this made me think that the students must be real big. But as the day went by, I saw that I was bigger than most of the students, and that the big ones were about my size. I had to laugh to myself about having worried about the size of the students at Roslyn. And then I found out that most of the trophies were for academics, not athletics. I know that if Erasmus had the fields that Roslyn has, Erasmus would be the best athletic school in New York City.
They Don’t Dress Rich
Another thing I noticed was the way the students at Roslyn dressed. They didn’t wear expensive clothes like the students at Erasmus. They wore ordinary blue jeans with no design on them, and ordinary shirts or sweaters. They didn’t wear much jewelry neither. I didn’t see any of them with gold caps, or cables like the students at Erasmus. The ones that did wear jewelry only had about two little gold rings, and a real skinny gold chain. I had thought that most of the students at Roslyn had rich parents and that they’d be dressing much better than the students at my school. One thing they were doing better was eating. When Ealiss, one of the students I met, took me to the lunchroom with her, I knew just by looking around that the food was going to be better than the food at Erasmus. First Ealiss went to get an ice cream sundae, then we went to another part of the lunchroom so I could get a sandwich. When we got there, they asked me what I wanted. I said a turkey-roast beef sandwich and they made it for me. It cost $2.50 but, by the size of it, in Brooklyn it would go for $5.
