Real Women Have Curves is about a Mexican-American teenager’s struggle with her family, her future and her body.
The film begins on Ana’s last day in high school. Ana, who lives in a Los Angeles ghetto, wants to attend college, but doesn’t stress the issue because she knows that her parents want her to stay home and work instead.
Keshia: I felt for Ana. She had to struggle with her parents so they’d allow her to go to college. Plus, her mother, Carmen, was always nagging her about her weight. Even though Carmen’s overweight herself, she tried to make Ana feel undeserving of love because she wasn’t skinny and didn’t act like a “lady.”
Jennifer: I was feeling Ana all the way. I know how it is to be teased about weight. It’s stressful.
K: I admired Ana for not letting her self-esteem drop, regardless of her mother’s constant insults. When her mother called her a slut because she lost her virginity, Ana said, “There’s more to me than what’s between my legs.”
J: That line had me laughing. She finally set her mother straight. I was anticipating that moment. In a way, I felt like Carmen deserved what was coming to her, but at the same time I felt sorry for her. She wanted the best for her daughter even though she didn’t show it.
K: Yeah, but Carmen needed to realize that what she thought was best for Ana might not necessarily be so.
J: I think Carmen was just jealous of Ana because Carmen had to work when she was young, so she wanted her children to grow up the same way. It reminded me of my friend’s mother who makes my friend clean the house and get a job because her mother had to work since she was 11.
K: If Ana was born in Mexico, like her parents, she probably would’ve just listened to them. Everyone around her would probably be working early in life and staying home to help the family. Living in America is different, though. Ana’s classmates went to college and her teacher persuaded her to go, too.
J: I thought it was terrible that Carmen gave Ana a guilt trip when they learned about Ana’s acceptance to Columbia University. She made it seem like Ana’s leaving meant she’d never come home again or speak to her family. I don’t think Ana wanted to abandon her family. She just wanted to go to college.
K: Carmen especially made her feel guilty about leaving her grandfather.
J: Right! How dare she! It’s true that her grandfather’s old and in need, but Ana has a future ahead of her.
K: Though he was quiet, her grandfather supported her more than anyone else in the family.
J: Like when Ana said that they were going to the movies together only to cover up a date she was going on with Jimmy. I thought it was real cute that her grandfather left with her and went to a bar instead so she could meet up with her guy.
K: Ana and Jimmy had a weird relationship, though. I don’t think Ana even had real feelings for him. She was just using him to pass the time. We didn’t learn much about Jimmy other than his name, that he went to school with Ana, and he’s going to college.
J: It wasn’t clear how serious the relationship was. They kissed a couple of times and went on a couple of dates. So I wouldn’t really say he was her boyfriend. But Jimmy saw her as a beautiful girl. She was more concerned about her weight than he was.
K: I’d say she was the guy in the relationship. She got what she wanted from him and left. How coldhearted. She just needed the attention to boost her self-esteem. She didn’t seem upset when he said that he was going all the way to the East Coast to college. She even turned him down when he suggested that they keep in touch. I lost respect for her when she broke it off with Jimmy.
J: I thought Ana loved him at one point. She was happy every time she was with him. It seemed like Ana was scared that her mother would disapprove of Jimmy, maybe because he’s not Mexican like they are. But I agree; if she loved him, she wouldn’t have left him like that.
K: If she really cared about him, why couldn’t she stick it out with him? Even if they weren’t romantically involved, being friends would’ve been cool. That scene just didn’t feel right.
J: But the scene when Ana came home with her sister, and her mother started telling Ana’s sister about the soap opera she’s watching, was completely realistic. It reminded me of my grandmother and her novelas. Sometimes when I visit her, she starts telling me about who got pregnant, who slept with whom, and who died.
K: But how realistic was the scene when Ana and her co-workers started taking their clothes off at work in the factory to show that they weren’t ashamed of their bodies? Who strips at work when there are large windows surrounding them?
J: And you know people would be looking through those windows. She was letting all her stuff hang out. She had no shame.
K: Or what about Ana being accepted to Columbia? She didn’t apply until the summer and was accepted on a full scholarship.
J: That is so true. I doubt she’d have gotten accepted so quickly. I wish I could be so lucky to get a full scholarship to the only college I wanted to go to in a matter of a month. What was that about?
K: And Columbia’s really hard to get into, too.
J: Still, the girl who played Ana-America Ferrera-she’s a good actress. She showed her emotions well and didn’t seem fake.
K: She made me believe that she was really struggling with pudginess problems and her mother. She had the spunk and attitude needed for the role. America was Ana.
Real Women Have Curves: Bold Daughter, Bitter Mom
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.