Reaction from Teens: Youth Are Worried About Welfare Changes

Interviews by Ciuela Thomas and Lorraine Stephens
To find out what impact the welfare “reform” might have on foster youth, teen mothers, and the poor, we interviewed several teens in care. While some agreed with cuts for people who are able to work, almost everyone interviewed thought that the new law would cause a lot of suffering.
Leslie Roman, 17, of Inwood House, a maternity residence for teens in Manhattan, felt that the new restrictions would stop some people from “taking advantage.”
“I feel that some people do take advantage of welfare,” Leslie said. “There are some people who have a stable job and don’t need to be on welfare.”
Pam Smith, 20, of Little Flower, said, “Seventy percent do [need it], 30 percent don’t. I do believe a lot of people take advantage of welfare.” But, she added, “Most people go on welfare because they don’t have no money to support their child.”
Leroy Chase-Hill, 17, of St. Christopher-Ottilie in Brooklyn, feels that the five-year limit on benefits will do more harm than good.
“Yes, there are those who take advantage, but there are more who really need it, the ones who can’t support their families…I do think that most people need it.”
Keshia Miller, 15, also of St. Christopher-Ottilie, agreed that most people on welfare were families struggling just to survive-far from living the high life. “Who wants to be on welfare?” Keshia asked.
Need for Jobs
One of the big ideas behind welfare reform was to break the “cycle of dependency”-in other words, to get people trained for work instead of sitting home collecting checks. But many young people doubted whether the new plan would really get people to work.
Michelle Noble, 19, of St. Christopher-Ottilie, agreed with the welfare time limit, but also feels that the government needs to do more to provide good jobs with decent pay.
“I need a very good-paying job in order to maintain my home,” Michelle said. “I’ll be damned if I’m going to clean some street for $150 every two weeks.”
“Sweetness,” a 17-year-old with St. Joseph’s Children’s Services in Brooklyn, wasn’t sure the government would deliver its end of the deal.
“I think [welfare reform] is very unfair to the less fortunate,” she said. “Jobs are not always hiring.”
More Kids in Care?
“Sweetness” predicted serious trouble if welfare benefits to the truly needy were eliminated without more jobs being available: “More shooting and more crying and dying,” she said.
And, more kids in foster care: “If parents can’t care for their children, the state will most likely-definitely-take their kids.”
Many teens interviewed also worried about the impact of new restrictions on teen mothers, which require them to be in school or job training, and also to live at home or in foster care to collect welfare. They doubted that it would stop teens from having babies, one of the goals of politicians who supported welfare reform.
“I don’t think this will stop teens from having babies,” said Pam Smith, 20, who has one child. “I just feel that for a lot of teens who are having babies, including myself, it will be much harder to support our children in the future.”
“What if a teen parent at the moment can’t go to school because he or she lacks money for a babysitter and has to take care of her kids?” asked Queen Boyce, 17, of Brooklyn. Queen added that welfare reform “will have a terrible, devastating impact on the poor.”
Leslie Roman, 17, disagrees with the new rules “because there are teen mothers who don’t want to be in foster homes or any group home because they want to start out fresh. There’s some that can’t go to school because of the lack of child care during school hours. Also, there are some who don’t even have a home.”
Impact on Teen Mothers
Asked if the new rules would stop teens from having babies, Leslie added, “No, because teenagers don’t think about the responsibility. They feel that having children would give them love better than their lover, families, and friends.”
Michelle Noble, 19, the mother of a two-year-old, said she didn’t know how she could meet the new requirements.
“It depends if I can get help from [my daughter’s] father. I would be in school, but unfortunately, I don’t have that kind of help.”
Cherice Sands, 20, in foster care with St. Christopher-Ottilie in Brooklyn, strongly opposed the new welfare changes: “We are not asking for handouts…We need help instead of being on the street.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.