Police Crackdowns Have Cleaned Up Washington Heights, But At What Price?

It was a regular day in Washington Heights, and for Clobys Guerrero, 15, hanging out on the corner with a couple of friends was the logical thing to do.
He and his friends were just chilling and talking when suddenly they were confronted by police officers looking for kids who had just robbed a cab driver.
The police asked them questions about the robbery and then the officers began to ask them whether they were selling drugs. The police ordered them to put their hands on the wall and searched them.
‘I’m No Dealer’
The entire humiliating experience proved to be pointless. Clobys and his friends had not committed any robbery, and Clobys has never bought or sold drugs in his life.
You would think that Clobys would be really irritated. You would think he would feel that the cops were way out of line. But surprisingly, Clobys did not.
Clobys didn’t mind, he explained, because he thinks the cops have made his neighborhood safer. So instead of getting mad, he laughed and cooperated, and in the end, the cops thanked him for his help.
Witnessing Violence
Clobys lives in Washington Heights, a neighborhood that has long been notorious as a dangerous center for drug trafficking and gang violence.
In the mid-1980s and early 1990s, Washington Heights became a center of the crack trade; in 1993, there were 75 murders in Washington Heights alone, according to a recent report in The New York Times.
Clobys himself has witnessed violent crimes. “They killed a cop on my block by throwing a bucket of cement from the roof, hitting the cop on the head,” he said.
For years there has also been tension between the police and residents of Washington Heights, many of whom believe the cops don’t respect them or understand their community.
In recent years, however, crime has gone down and the number of police officers in the neighborhood has gone up. So far, in 1998, there have only been 6 murders in Washington Heights-still too many people dead for no good reason, but far better than how things used to be.
It isn’t just in Washington Heights that crime has dropped. Recent statistics show that crime across the nation has been decreasing over the past several years.
But the change in Washington Heights is particularly dramatic, and one reason for it is probably that Mayor Giuliani assigned more police to Washington Heights and made the area a focus in his fight against crime.
Today, an extra 1,100 new cops are patrolling the streets of New York City and the cops have issued 67,000 tickets so far this year, more than double the number at the same time last year.
In Clobys’ opinion, this is good news. “A lot of cops stop drug dealers and take them to jail. Before there were a lot of crackheads. You don’t see that many crackheads now,” he said.
Good Cop, Bad Cop
But not everyone feels so comfortable having the cops around or is so easy-going about being stopped when they’ve done nothing wrong.
Many residents say they feel that more police also mean “more harassment.”
Ydanis Rodriguez, the executive director of a Washington Heights group called Dominican Youth, has lived in Washington Heights since 1983, and said he knows about police brutality first hand.
In 1988, right after he started attending CUNY, he was handing out flyers on a street corner when a police officer came up to him and told him to stop, he said. When he began to ask the cop what was wrong with what he was doing, the police officer punched him and slapped him with a summons, he added.
That was a long time ago and Ydanis admits that a lot has changed. The police have helped decrease crime, he said, and they have also “started opening up to the neighborhood by taking tours and meeting the people.”
Still, he says, the distrust continues.
Spanish Spoken Here
Part of the problem is that about half of the people who live in Washington Heights are immigrants from the Dominican Republic, and about another 20% are Puerto Rican, while most of the cops are not.
On the hot, humid day when I visited the neighborhood, the streets were crowded and on every corner people were selling flavored ice. There were lots of signs written in Spanish, and I heard Spanish spoken on the streets and among the people chatting on their doorsteps.
The people I spoke to said they feel at home in their neighborhood, and that they feel more like a community than if they lived somewhere else in the city.
But with these advantages come difficulties.
Fitting-and Breaking -Stereotypes
Many Dominican immigrants have had a difficult time finding jobs. Even if they do find a job, the pay is often low. The income of Dominicans is the lowest of any ethnic group in New York City and 45 % of Dominicans in the city live under the poverty line.
Plus, the schools in Washington Heights are overcrowded and many kids leave school early to find work.
Because it’s hard to find a job, some have turned to selling drugs as a way to make a living. Most, of course, do not.
But sometimes it seems-even to Dominicans-that everyone is. Even Clobys said that people in his neighborhood make money either by selling drugs or by stealing.
Maybe that’s because it’s easier not to notice people like Clobys’ mom, for instance, who is a home attendant.
If you go to the subway in the morning, Ydanis said, “you will notice that there is a large number of Dominicans going to work every day and you can see [them again] when they go home.”
And Clobys plans to attend college. He hopes Syracuse will be his destination. He dreams of becoming a basketball player, but if that doesn’t happen, he’d like to be a computer analyst.
One Problem: Too Little Communication
But Ydanis says that lots of people, and sometimes cops, too, have stereotypes that all Dominicans are dealers and gang members.
“There is a lack of communication between the police and the community. A number of police see [all] Dominicans as the same types of drug dealers,” Ydanis said. “Many of the [police] don’t come from our community and don’t understand our values. Instead of feeling protected, we feel afraid.”
Even Clobys acknowledges that there are problems. A friend told him of another friend who was pulled over in his car on the suspicion that he was smoking weed.
When he refused to open the door, the police broke it down, grabbed him and slammed him to the ground, Clobys said his friend told him. Then, a police officer shoved his foot into the man’s neck and started to kick him.
Still, Clobys believes that when the cops beat people up, “it’s usually for a reason. It’s only when people start arguing, fighting back and cursing,” he said.
After being stopped himself, though, Clobys says that now when he sees cops, he sometimes worries that they’ll stop him again.
Drugs Gone Underground
Even though Washington Heights is much safer these days, that doesn’t mean that the problems in the neighborhood have gone away. Gangs and drug dealing still go on, there’s just less of it, and it’s more underground.
But crime is not the only problem in Washington Heights, nor can the police be the only solution.
It’s clear that larger issues, like jobs and education, have to be addressed to really turn things around in Washington Heights.
Angel Guillermo, 25, who lives in Washington Heights and works with teens there at an organization called Alianza Dominicana, said he tries to show the teens he works with that they have many options besides selling drugs.
“I want to open up my own youth group to try and help kids,” he said.
Discovering Better Options
When Angel walks the 13 blocks to get home from work, he knows which blocks are safe, and which he ought to avoid.
“The trick for me is that I’ve been here so long that I can detect the bad streets and avoid them,” he said.
Still, Angel said he feels safer than he did 10 years ago, and part of this, he acknowledges, has to do with increased police presence.
Angel believes that cops are part of the answer but cannot be the whole solution. He said more programs need to be set up for teens, like the one he works for.
And the schools in the neighborhood-like overcrowded George Washington HS-need to be improved.
“Young people usually join [gangs] because they want that sense of family, so these gangs promise them things that make them want to join. But young people are also not being [shown] other options. They think you’ve got to take this,” Angel said.
The truth is that, besides cops, the people in Washington Heights need better services and more opportunities.
As Ydanis put it: “I believe that drug dealers will never disappear from the community until we address the issue of more jobs and better education.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.