Papa, Don’t Preach

(All names have been changed.)
It was the first week of September, and I was in the car with my father riding back from one of those bothersome orthodontist appointments. While speeding down the street, he startled me with the question, “Do you have a boyfriend?”
I immediately went into defensive mode. “No, Papa,” I answered. I was lying.
“OK, because if you did, I’d kill you and take away all your privileges, including your cell phone,” he said. “And if he’s Black or Spanish, I will disown you.”
I turned my head towards the window so he wouldn’t see me roll my eyes. I wanted to blurt out, “Too bad-I have a boyfriend and he’s Dominican, and he’s 20 years old.”
But instead I just said, “Well, I’m 17, and I’ll be going to prom in June and I’m going to have a date.”
Withheld My Tears
“Well then, you better expect to stay at home that night,” he answered back. My father knew from the past that I’d only dated Black and Latino guys, and he added, “You can have all kinds of friends from different races, but I can never accept a Black or Spanish guy into the family. Never. They’re the reason why I quit my job. Those Spanish people look at us Filipinos like we’re nothing.”
I turned my head to the window again, this time to withhold the tears. I wanted to yell back, “So what? Don’t make me suffer because of your work experiences! I’m your daughter, but I will not inherit your ignorance!”
“Papa, my bosses are Black. Are you going to make me leave because of that?” I asked. The three top executives of the technology firm I worked for are African-American.
“That’s different,” he said.
“Yeah, whatever,” I muttered to myself. I was angry but remained quiet, just for the sake of not arguing.
A Strained Relationship
His views on how I should date have put a strain on our relationship. I love him because he’s my father, but I wish I could be more open with him when it comes to guys.
I’ve had boyfriends ever since I was in 5th grade, and not one has been Filipino. I’ve never told my parents about my boyfriends, but in 7th grade, they found out about one since my teacher caught us making out in the school bathroom. I convinced them that we were “just talking,” but they were furious since the boy, Greg, was Black.
My father was out of town the week I got in trouble, so my mother was left to deal with me. While discussing the situation, my mother said that my father was scammed by a Black co-worker.
She didn’t go into further detail, but that was her way of explaining why she didn’t like Black people and why the last thing they wanted was their daughter dating one.
Feel Distant From Parents
My parents also believe that all Blacks and Latinos are vulgar because of how they’re portrayed in rap music and news reports. I felt offended by my parents’ views, which didn’t help our relationship.
My parents and I have such different backgrounds. They were born and raised in the Philippines, surrounded by people of their own ethnicity. But my sisters and I grew up in Jamaica, Queens, where we were surrounded by many other cultures.
My childhood best friend was Guyanese and Trinidadian, and I often stayed at her house to enjoy her mother’s West Indian cooking. Another friend, who was Puerto Rican, had the best birthday parties because of the fast-paced Latin music and delicious foods. So I’ve always felt comfortable with people of other ethnicities.
Embraced by Black and Latino Guys
And there’s the issue of attraction; Black and Latino guys have always shown more interest in me. I think it’s because Black and Latino cultures find voluptuous women more acceptable: I have a plus-sized figure, and guys I’ve dated have told me that they like my hips and thick waist. Filipino guys I’ve met tend to go for thin Filipinas or Asian girls.
That makes me feel rejected by my own culture. But then again, there aren’t that many Filipino guys I’m attracted to. When I go to parties and clubs, my eyes go straight to Latino guys. There’s just something about curly hair, olive skin and finely contoured lips that drive me crazy.
So it felt natural for me to date Latino and Black guys. But the gap between my parents and I has widened since I’ve had to keep my romantic history a secret from them.
Dates on the Down Low
After the incident in the bathroom, Greg and I broke up. Then the summer after 8th grade, I went out with a Puerto Rican guy, and then pursued a year-long relationship with Richard, who’s Haitian. After we broke up, I continued to date Latino guys.
For the most part, I was able to pursue these relationships without my parents knowing. I had a pager, and then a cell phone, so my boyfriends never called the house.
If I went out to meet a guy, I often told my parents that I was going to the movies with a friend. I was caught once or twice on the phone with a guy, but I’d play it off like I was on the phone with a friend from school and we were studying.
Found Out
But last year, when I was 16, my cousin snitched on me and told my parents I wasn’t really going out with friends one night, but that I was meeting my boy-friend.
My parents said I was too young to date and had to break up with him immediately. During our talk, when I told them that he was Colombian, my father became even more furious.
I ended up breaking up with the guy anyway since he was so busy with work and hanging out with friends. But that was beside the point. It was frustrating that my parents and I had such different values when it came to how I should live my life.
Support From Boyfriend’s Parents
A year later, their opinion hasn’t changed. So I’ve continued to date on the down low. Right now I have a great boyfriend, Marc, whom I’ve been with for more than six months. I plan to be with him even if my parents find out.
In contrast to my folks, Marc’s parents love me to death. I went to a family party of his, and his older brothers and sister gladly welcomed me as well. I’d never been in a relationship where I met the guy’s family, and I felt at home with them.
He’s able to have an open relationship with his parents. He tells them everything about what’s going on in his life, including me, and they give him advice when he needs it.
If Marc can have an open relationship with his parents, why can’t I? I wish that I could invite him to family parties or to the house to hang out so I wouldn’t have to lie. Marc is not a bad person, and if my father and mother got to know him, they’d think he’s nice too.
Support From Grandma
It’s hard dealing with my parents’ rules and regulations, but I’m grateful to have the support of some of my friends and relatives. My grandmother and two older cousins live with me, and they like Marc.
They were very supportive when I told them about my relationship. Marc has met them, as well as my two sisters, and he gets along with them. I’ve never introduced a boyfriend to my family before.
My grandmother once said, “Why does your father object to you dating, especially Blacks and Spanish guys? What does he want, an Italian?” She understands my tastes; as long as Marc is good to me, my grandmother’s happy for me. Grandma even invited him over to the house when my parents were working so we could have dinner and spend time together.
But my parents’ disapproval is still frustrating. I had to vent through my poetry. I poured my heart out in a poem I entitled, “Letter to my Father.” I ask him to just, “Put your can’ts and won’ts aside and listen to me like your daughter.” I performed the piece at some open mics. Some girls in the audience totally related.
Not Being Close Hurts
Marc knows how my parents feel about me dating. It scared him when I told him how my father feels about Black and Latino people. That made him feel even more intimidated about meeting my father. His parents even joked that if Marc ever stepped into my house, my father’d probably pull out a shotgun.
It might be easy for some to brush off the fact that I can’t be open with my parents. But when I’m at my friends’ homes and see how well they vibe with their parents, or how I hear that their mother or father is their best friend, it really gets to me. I don’t remember ever being close with my parents.
Will I Stand Alone?
My parents are good people, and I love them a lot. I’m not trying to be a rebel, but I like dating. As long as I’m not getting pregnant or sleeping around with guys, I don’t think I’m doing anything wrong. I wish they’d have more faith in me.
I don’t think I should compromise my happiness in order to please my parents when it comes to my significant other. As long as my boyfriend treats me right, respects other people, and has a future ahead of him, they should be happy for me, even if he’s not Filipino.
I want to move out of my house when I go to college next year. As long as I’m still living at home, my parents will probably continue to forbid me to date. I need to be independent, so I can freely be with whomever I want.
Sometimes I wonder what will happen when I get married, and my husband isn’t Filipino. Years later, will my parents still adhere to their close-mindedness? On my wedding day, will my father walk me down the aisle, or will I stand alone, with no one to give me away?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.