Our Parents’ Rules: Fair or Square?

Almost all teen girls have to deal with rules-rules about where they can go and when they have to come home, what they can wear, and who they can date (if they can date at all).
“First thing, don’t get pregnant.”
“Do not date ’til you’re 21 or until we’re dead.”
“No tight, tight clothes.”
“Get good grades.”
“Tell me where you’re going.”
“Get home by 9:30, 10 at the latest.”
These are just a few of the things that girls I interviewed mentioned when I asked what basic rules their parents expect them to follow.
A Dangerous City
Almost everyone I talked to agreed that while some of their parents’ demands are reasonable, “sometimes they make up rules that are kind of hard to follow,” as Johanna Peters, 16, of Clara Barton HS, put it.
Most parents make rules because they want to protect their daughters and keep them out of trouble, and their kids realize this.
“New York is a dangerous city, a lot of things can happen to young girls,” said Ruth Marantz, 15, of Beacon HS. “[My parents] just want to make sure I’m taking care of myself.”
Although she doesn’t have a curfew, Ruth said her parents “expect me to call them, to tell them where I was, always. They’re concerned about my safety. They’ll make me take cabs late at night.”
The Right to Make Mistakes
Others, like Faith Wallace, 16, of Choate-Rosemary Hall, think their parents are more concerned with controlling them than protecting them.
“[My mother] doesn’t want me to challenge her authority,” she said. This frustrates Faith. “I think I should have the right to be left alone and make mistakes and make my own decisions, too,” she said.
But even when girls think there are good reasons for their parents’ rules, they don’t always enjoy following them. Rachel Leung, 17, of Health Professions HS, said her parents’ rules include no dating until college, a 10 p.m. curfew, and the expectation that she’ll get good grades.
“I think they’re doing this for my own good and so I won’t mess up my life,” Rachel said. But she also thinks her parents are “too strict.”
‘I’m Not the Rebel Type’
Rachel wishes she could stay out later because she thinks she’s missing out on “all the fun and excitement.” And she doesn’t think she should have to wait until college to have a boyfriend.
“If I found a nice person, I would date them but my parents wouldn’t know,” she said. But, basically, Rachel goes along with what her parents want.
“I know I have no say in it,” she said. “And I’m not the rebel type.”
Johanna said her parents make rules “because they want me to have the best possible life I could have.” But that doesn’t mean she always follows them.
Like Rachel, her curfew is “10 at the latest.” She’s not supposed to date or go to bars or clubs. But, unlike Rachel, “I rebel,” Johanna said.
Getting Revenge on the ‘Rents
One time her parents “found out I was going out with some guy,” she said. “I still kept going out with him. I felt kind of good because I got back at them.”
Sometimes she does things just to spite her parents, Johanna said. “Like before, when they didn’t want guys calling, maybe I would give my number out more,” she said.
The biggest fight Johanna ever had with her parents was over a guy calling.
“They figured he was my boyfriend,” she said. “They screamed at him. He turned out to be in one of my dental classes from school. I was very embarrassed. I went into my room and said I would never speak to them again. Eventually they came and apologized.”
Guys: a Source of Tension
Guys are often a source of tension between girls and their parents-even when they are allowed to date. Faith said her mother has rules about the kind of guy she can go out with.
“He has to be in school, he has to be doing something, he can’t just be hanging with his boys on the street,” she said.
Mary Grace Colobong, 15, of John Bowne HS, has gotten a similar message from her parents. They’ve told her, “Don’t go out with lower status [guys] or gangsters,” she said.
Other girls said their folks just want to know who they’re dating. “My dad wanted to meet my boyfriend,” Ruth said. “Other than that [who I date] is basically not in their control.”
Even though girls may not like these rules, they do see why they make some sense. But then there are the rules girls think are totally unreasonable-like telling them what they can and can’t wear.
Many girls said their parents won’t let them wear things that are too tight, too revealing or too sloppy, and these are among the things they get most upset about.
“I don’t think it’s a parent’s place to tell you how to dress,” said Vanessa Ho, 17, who graduated from Hunter College HS in June.
Vanessa said her parents can “express their opinions” about her clothes but they “can’t tell me what I can and can’t wear.”
But many parents do think it is their right to tell their daughters how to dress.
‘You Can’t Wear That’
“My mom will say, ‘You can’t wear that’ and I say, ‘Why?’ and she says, ‘It’s too tight,’ ” said Faith.
Makeda Benjamin, 17, of Beacon HS, said, “My mother doesn’t let me show my stomach or wear tight, tight clothes, but my father doesn’t really mind.”
Makeda said that last summer when she wore something her mother didn’t like, her mom “didn’t make me take the clothes off but she would complain and get real mad.”
Makeda said that, in the end, “I would just change my mind and go with her way.”
But a lot of times, girls refuse to go with their parents’ way. If there’s something they really want to do, they’ll go ahead and do it, even if their parents have said, “No.”
“I think they’re unfair at times,” Vanessa said. “I kind of just ignore them and do it anyway.” Or, she said, “I talk to them and say, ‘Look, this is unfair’ and they let me do what I want to do.”
The Guilt Factor
One time Faith’s mother told her she couldn’t go to a party. “But I went to a friend’s house and went anyway…[My mom] found out from calling my friend’s house,” Faith said. “When I got home, I just went to my room, slept late and came out in the morning. She just said, ‘I’m very disappointed in you, if you ever do that again I’m going to come down there in my slippers and rollers in my hair.’ ”
Afterwards, Faith regretted what she had done. “I felt really bad, I felt guilty,” she said. “I was like, I can’t believe I did that.”
Even Ruth, who described her parents as “very easy going,” and said, “they trust me so I can deal with the rules,” has disobeyed on occasion.
“I’ve sneaked out of the house before,” she said. Afterwards, she felt “half happy with myself and half guilty.”
Voicing Our Protests
The girls I interviewed usually felt bad about breaking the rules. Most said they try to talk to their parents and convince them to change rules that they find too strict.
“I protest, I voice my opinion,” Ruth said. “It doesn’t hurt just to talk things out.”
Mary Grace agreed. “Like a suggestion I made about dating and what age-they took it pretty seriously.”
But most of the girls also felt that there were times when their parents are just being unreasonable. “The information they give me is [from] like 20 million years ago,” said Mary Grace. “This is the 20th century and things are different.”
Faith disagrees about parents being so out of touch. She thinks the real reason parents are sometimes hard on their kids is because they weren’t perfect angels when they were teenagers and they don’t want their children to repeat their mistakes.
“I think our parents know what they were doing at 16 and they don’t want us to do that,” Faith said.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.