One Tough Mama

After reading the articles that FCYU staff were writing about rules in foster care, I interviewed Bernadetta Hayward, a senior child care worker for the Administration for Children’s Services, who works in a group home in Queens. Since she’s been working there for 13 years, I thought she might have a good perspective on when rules do and don’t work. She brought up some good issues. As an outsider peeking in, I think that the boys in her group home are lucky to have her in their lives. I also think some other group home staff could learn from her example.
Q: When residents complain about the rules in your house, when do you discuss their concerns, and when do you just say, “That’s tough but those are the rules?”
A: We have our rap sessions, or what I call our Indian teepees. We sit on the floor Indian style with food all around us. If we’re having an issue, I’ll ask them, “What do you think is fair?” and we’ll negotiate. I tell them, “If you want to make this like a family, you’ve got to help me make the rules. But if you do, and you break them, there are going to be consequences.” Usually the consequences are, they’ll lose part of their curfew or phone privileges. Or if they have a single room, they could lose that.
If I put a kid on restriction, he has to come to me to negotiate if he feels it’s unfair. But I don’t change my punishment too often because first they have to prove to me that they’ve changed their behavior. When I am too hard on a kid and I realize it, though, then I do apologize. Just like in all families, people make mistakes and you have to be able to apologize. It helps.
Q: When kids get in trouble, sometimes after-school activities are taken away. But being stuck in the house can make kids act even worse. Is this something you do?
A: I would never take away any after-school program. That’s teaching, and I would never interfere with teaching. But if there’s an agency trip they really want to go on and they do something drastic, maybe I would take that away.
Q: When do you use restraints and why?
A: We have not used restraints in a long time. Physical restraints holding a kid when he’s getting violent-is not meant to hurt a child but to calm a behavior down. Restraints should be done with the minimum force and the maximum love. But physical restraint should be the last thing you ever do. You should only use them if a child is physically harming himself or another person. And sometimes restraints can hype a child up and make things worse, so you really need to be careful.
Q: How do you think kids can be helped to succeed without making them feel like they’re slaves to your rules?
A: I think that the city needs a better structure to hold kids responsible. Now when a kid decides he’s not going to get up and go to school that day, or he’s not going for months, there’s very little we can do. But the city has an abundance of money, and they should develop programs to deal with what’s really going on with the kids. When kids aren’t doing anything it’s because they’re scared, and they’re not waking up to reality. They’re scared to go to school and they’re scared of the future.
One idea I have is for the city to build half-way houses for kids who aren’t going to school or will not work. They would put GED programs or work-training programs into these homes. This would make it easier for kids to get over their fears. Once they’re more on track, they could go back into the group home.
In the meantime, sometimes staff just have to stay on kids’ cases, even if the kids don’t like that. We had a kid who refused to go to school, to go to work or do anything. So we had a child welfare specialist talk to him and keep him motivated. And I’ve stayed on his case, too. Sometimes I’ll spend three or four hours talking to him about going to school. But sometimes I do get fed up and just say, “Enough is enough. You’re going.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.