On Their Own

It Takes Luck and Determination to Make It After Care

I was sitting on the subway, reading On Their Own, a true book by Gary Stangler and Martha Shirk about how 10 young adults cope with aging out of foster care. I was reading so intensely that I didn’t even realize I was on the wrong train. By the time I noticed, I was almost in Queens! (I live in Manhattan.) I aged out of the system when I was 18 (I’m 25 now), so a lot of the pain and emotions I was reading about hit close to home.
A Family Like Mine
I grew up in the Bronx, New York, in the late ’80s. The projects were extremely rough back then, but growing up with drug addicted parents made it even tougher. My father died in 1990, when I was 10, and my grandmother followed three months later. As for my mother, she is MIA ’til this day.
My sisters and I were sent to live in foster care, but my two older sisters ran away and grew up in the streets. My other sister and I stayed in foster care and were split up. I managed to scrape my way through high school and graduate from a good college.
The first chapter of the book describes a family almost just like mine-Lamar, Jeffrey and Jermaine Williams, who entered the system in 1987 because their mother was neglectful.
Streets vs. College
Jeffrey and Jarmaine, who were older, decided to run back to the mean streets of Crown Heights, Brooklyn, rather than deal with the system. They found love and caring in the streets, until Jarmaine died in a car accident on his way home from a drug pick up, and Jeffery landed a long prison sentence.
The youngest brother, who I thought of as Jackpot Boy Lamar, had a good head on his shoulders. He saw the system as a place of opportunity and hope. Lamar’s attitude and size turned him into a high roller.
He got into football in high school, and was lucky to have people behind him who really cared. The coach and teachers instilled confidence in him, made sure he had the skills to succeed in college, and helped him get into a school where he could play ball and get a good degree. Lamar went on to complete college, start a successful business, get married and build a beautiful house.
No Hollywood Endings
This chapter really got my feathers ruffled. I said to myself, “This is bullshit! Life after the system isn’t Hollywood. I got a degree but I’ve had a hell of a time finding a job. And most kids I know really have a hard time making it.”
Not to discredit Lamar in any way, but most kids in the system never get as many people pushing for them as Lamar did. And even if they do make it through college, not too many are making seventy grand a few years after graduating.
But after reading about a few more kids, I realized that the book didn’t portray life after care the way Hollywood might. For better or worse, Lamar was the one shining star.
Nothing But Rejection
The kid who really grabbed me was Alfonso Torres. Alfonso grew up in south Florida and struggled for acceptance since birth. His mother did not want him, his father just wanted to beat on him, and eventually the system took him. But even in the system, Alfonso found mostly rejection and fear.
Alfonso developed the mentality that he needed to do for himself because no one cared about him. He ran away numerous times and turned to stealing cars to get by. For years he was in and out of detention centers. Finally, on the day he turned 18, the woman who adopted his younger siblings (who he never knew about) agreed to take him in.
Alfonso was sure that nobody would ever want him, but he was also hungry for this woman’s love. From the first day, he called her “Mom.” But Alfonso constantly tested the woman, not following her rules, not going to his GED classes or getting a job. After being mistreated for many years, his only instinct was to rebel.
How Can We Learn to Trust?
Reading his story, I thought, “How do you train a stray dog? Most people don’t even try, and those who attempt usually give up.” Alfonso’s new “mom” made a small effort, but quickly kicked him out.
Psychologically, Alfonso seemed the most like me and the kids I knew in care. What Alfonso (and most of the kids in the book) experience is mental rejection of themselves and rejection by others. Alfonso’s distrust and fear of being rejected led him to act out, his acting out led him to get rejected, and rejection led to more depression, impulsive actions and improper decision making.
Reading his story made me depressed and angry. What hope is there for kids like Alfonso? If no adult will ever take care of him, how can he learn to trust? I felt hopeless when I saw how trapped he was by his past, and how, because he was 18, nobody considered it their responsibility to help him grow up.
Blamed for Their Pain
On Their Own touches on the psychological anguish of the kids it profiles, but it lacks depth. The book simply conveys the kids’ emotional and behavioral patterns, without exploring whether the kids understood why they were doing what they were doing, or what could help them break the patterns. Most of the kids are dealing with some sort of emotional problem, whether it’s a mental illness or a pattern of self-destructive habits.
Almost every kid in the book had been seriously mistreated, at home or in foster care, and had been kicked out of care the minute they turned 18 or 21, which often feels like another rejection. Yet the adults in the book seemed to blame the kids for their troubles finishing school or holding a job, rather than seeing their improper behavior as a typical response to the pain they experienced growing up.
Too Enraged to Read
I was surprised that the adults seemed to see these teens as capable of undoing the psychological effects of years of mistreatment, and expressed annoyance and anger when the kids couldn’t. I thought, “How do you expect someone to act right when her whole life she’s seen wrong?”
Often while reading On Their Own, I felt so enraged that I had to stop reading. Most of the stories showed kids in care getting flipped around like a pack of cards. Many times I wanted to get up and fling something across the room. I wondered, “Is the government simply unaware of the harsh circumstances kids face when they leave foster care? Why are they so willing to burn all our bridges? How can a society as rich as ours let young kids end up in prison or on the streets for no reason?”
Not Ready at 18
The book’s introduction explained that while most states expect foster youth to live independently at 18, studies show that most young people don’t become fully independent of their families until age 26. Up until then, they depend on their families for financial help, housing and emotional help. I felt outraged when I read that. Most kids have a cushion to fall back on, but troubled kids like myself get thrown into the jungle at 18 or 21 and are left to fend for themselves.
It seemed to me that the system is like Las Vegas: You need luck in order to win. When you enter the system, whether you do any better than you might have at home is all a gamble.
Determination and Luck
Your success depends on how strong your mind is, whether you actually find someone loving who cares about you, and whether you’re naturally smart, talented and resilient.
If you get into a great group home or live with a great foster parent, and are psychologically ready to take advantage of the services you do get, you might make it. But if you’re just an average messed up kid in an average messed up system, you probably won’t.
On Their Own should challenge the people in charge of the system to rethink how they treat the kids in their care-when we’re still kids, and well after we age out.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.