I couldn’t believe my ears when my twin sister’s boyfriend suggested that we all mess around together. “Double the pleasure, double the fun,” he said, thinking he was being cute. When some guys see two attractive girls who look alike they think we’re the Double Mint girls and come together as a package. Well, we don’t. We’re two separate people with different personalities and feelings.
Even though people constantly confuse us, my sister and I are different in many ways. I even think we look very different. I’m a little shorter and weigh a few more pounds then my sister and we have very different styles. I usually wear my hair down or in a ponytail or bun. She wears funky hairstyles with lots of braids and buns (think da’ Brat or Bjork).
To Each Her Own Style
I’ve kept the same hairstyle basically all my life: long, dark brown hair (although I dyed it black recently for a change). My sister is constantly dying and cutting her hair (to assert her individuality as well as to express herself). At different stages she has had short, curly red hair, straight purple hair and a burgundy bob with bangs. Now it’s strawberry blond with streaks of platinum in the front.
We also dress differently. I’ve always just wanted to look nice but my sister has always been impressed by what’s different. She was a punk-goth for a long time and wore dark, heavy makeup with pale, pale skin (she used white face powder); dressed mostly in black and other dark colors; wore fishnets, combat boots, a nose ring and eight holes in her ear.
Now she wears really baggy clothes, a lot of men’s clothes and army jackets. I dress more feminine, although still on the hip-hop tip (we both listen to a lot of rap and reggae). I wear a lot of dresses and skirts and wear boots and shoes instead of sneakers.
“Good girl” v. “Troublemaker”
It’s not just appearances that set us apart; we also have very different personalities. I’ve always done well in school and graduated from high school in June. My sister dropped out at the end of her senior year after switching to three different schools.
She’s the “troublemaker;” I like to follow the rules. She’s always getting fired from her jobs for not showing up or coming in stoned. Even worse, she is always getting arrested-for jumping the turnstiles, leaving a restaurant without paying the bill, drinking beer or smoking weed on the train. Whenever she’s broke she cons people for money, telling them she comes from Long Island and her purse was stolen.
It hurts me to see her degrade herself to get $5 or $10. Sometimes I feel guilty for feeling ashamed-like I should stand by her no matter what-but I can’t help feeling embarrassed. I try to get her to stop by telling her that I think it’s wrong but she just gets annoyed. She tells me that she’ll do whatever she has to do to get what she wants and that she won’t change. I guess that’s just something I have to accept.
Switching Identities
As different as we are, we have still been able to take advantage of our special status as twins. We used to go to each other’s classes when one of us wanted to cut.
Once there was a guy my sister liked in my class so she took my seat and proceeded to write notes to him and get his number. He was really surprised to find out it wasn’t me but my twin.
And once when I was walking down the street I saw this really annoying guy who kept asking me out. I walked past him pretending not to know who he was. When he called out my name I turned around and told him that he must have confused me with my twin sister. People who don’t know us well can be fooled very easily.
Not Two of A Kind
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.