No Longer Daddy’s Little Girl

I once bought a keychain that said “Daddy’s Girl” in dark navy block letters. I was about 8 years old at the time, and I thought my dad was just the coolest.
My earliest memory of my dad is of us having this silly conversation:
“I love you the most,” he would say.
“Well I love you more than the ocean!” I’d say back, thinking I got him.
“Well, I love you more than the sky,” and so on, back and forth. I used to sit on his shoulders and we would rule the world together. He was my mentor, my hero. He told me stories about magical places and would let me hold his hand when I was scared. I loved him, I really did, and I wasn’t afraid to show it.
My family works in pairs. Before I was 10, it was me and my dad, and my brother and my mom. My dad and I used to imagine whole worlds and talk about our favorite books together. I didn’t have anything intellectual to say when I was younger; it was all “dinosaurs are cool” and “I want a puppy.”
But as I got older, I realized that, when I did have something to say, my dad didn’t really respond in the way I would have liked. It’s not because we were starting to talk about more mature topics; we could be talking about the color of my shorts and he would either just look at me, saying “What?” in this obnoxious voice, or talk about some philosophical quote that didn’t really relate to my original question.
I’m not sure if he had been doing it all along, and only when I was older did I perceive it as obnoxious, or if he just started responding this way as I got older. In any case, I didn’t like it. I felt like I couldn’t have an actual conversation with him, so I started to withdraw from him.
My dad tried to connect with me, emailing me interesting articles and giving me books he thought I should read. For example, when I was 10 he would try to get me to read Pride and Prejudice or Farewell to Arms. He wanted me to know the “classics,” telling me that this was real literature, and I ought to read the right books. I didn’t even know half the words in the books, and even when I told him so, he would just tell me to look it up.
“That’s how you learn,” he would say. I understood that, but I wasn’t ready to read those things in 5th grade. He would make fun of the fact that I read Twilight or some other teen book, but what did he expect? I didn’t understand great literature, and frankly I just wasn’t into that kind of stuff.
Drifting Further Apart
My perfect image of my dad started cracking. Of course I still loved him; I just didn’t love him more than the sky anymore. Before we used to make fun of each other as a joke, but later, in bouts of hormonal, prepubescent rage, I would burst out and call him the worst dad in the world.
Things I loved about him when I was 5, I had started to resent. I hated how he called me his little girl; I hated saying I love you; I hated holding his hand; I hated when he tried to fix things for me.
It seemed like he didn’t understand that I had to grow up, that I needed space to have my own thoughts and opinions, even if they clashed with his. I didn’t want him tagging along when I went to the movies or when I would spend time with my friends from school. Whenever he wanted to hang out, I would tell him to stop annoying me. He would get upset about that and lecture me for disrespecting him, which irritated me even more.
“Just because you’re older now doesn’t mean you can do whatever you want. You have to learn how to balance your life,” he would say. I would just roll my eyes. How would he know how I should run my life?
My dad can be very opinionated and intolerant of people who disagree with him. When I once asked him why we didn’t go to church when my grandma did, he suddenly started spouting about how God isn’t real and that evolution is key, and gave me books to read on the subject. He could’ve just said we weren’t religious; I didn’t need all the background-or the judgmental attitude.
I wouldn’t mind hearing his opinion if it didn’t come with an air of superiority. He doesn’t let me interject and say my own ideas; he’s so full of his own beliefs that he’s not open to hearing others. So I started reacting by avoiding him. What was the point in trying to connect? I felt like he’d never really understand how I felt.
It’s Easier With Mom
Starting in middle school, it seemed my dad sort of gave up on trying to connect with me. I guess he didn’t want to deal with my outbursts and “teen angst” anymore. He started focusing on my brother and all the “guy” things they could do together. While they went mountain biking and to chess tournaments, they left me and my mom, whom I love, but with whom I just didn’t have the same kind of bond. I realized I missed talking about books and creating characters with my dad.
My mom and I have a different relationship, more open and kind. During the time I drifted from my dad, I realized that my mom and I rarely fight. We go shopping and find similar things funny. I guess it’s because she acts like a teenager sometimes.
My mom says that when she was my age she had to grow up and act older because that’s the way her parents raised her. She had to cook the meals and help clean the house. She says she’s living her teenage years now, something that allows us to relate more.
My mom leaves me alone; she never nags or bothers me unless I do something horrible. She will confront me, but not try to run my life. I don’t normally approach my mom with problems, but when I do have one she’s always there to just nod and say that everything is going to be all right. She expects and trusts me to do the right thing, only giving me a little nudge when she thinks I need it. Like when I get a bad grade, she suggests I go to after-school tutoring, but doesn’t force me.
My dad, on the other hand, sits me down and says something like, “Why did this happen? Did you not study? Do you not understand it? You have no excuse.” It makes me feel stupid and inferior. He doesn’t understand that I don’t work well under those methods. It makes me not want to tell him anything.
My mom sometimes tries to help the relationship with my dad and me, telling me to “take it easy on him.” But I always roll my eyes and ignore her. I usually think that whatever I’m doing is totally justifiable, even if it isn’t.
I Want Him to See Me
I once ripped up a really nice picture of the two of us just because we had a fight. I can’t even remember the fight now; it was probably something stupid, like he asked me to turn off the lights and I didn’t want to. But in my rage I ripped it, dropped it on my desk, and forgot about it.
When my dad came in later to check on me, he saw the picture and just sighed. He knew I was mad, but I could tell he thought I’d overreacted. He took all the pieces in his hands and walked out. I thought he was going to throw it away but the next day it was all mended again with clear Scotch tape. You could only see the rips if you looked close enough.
Looking back now, I think I started to act out because I wanted attention, because I wanted my dad to notice me. I wanted him to understand that I was growing up and becoming a different person. I guess I was jealous and angry that instead of recognizing and appreciating who I am now, he just started hanging out with my brother. My resentment only created a bigger distance between us. I didn’t realize that I just wanted him to acknowledge who I was and relate to me-not as a child, but as someone becoming an adult.
By the time I was 13, we’d become so distant that I would yell at him and blame him directly for my problems. Failed a test? Forgot my homework? Got into a fight? Obviously my dad was the one to blame. Because he still thought of me as his little girl, he was an easy target. He gave in to me because he didn’t want to make me angrier. If I asked him to leave me alone, he would leave me alone, and if I asked him to be quiet, he would be quiet.
I just didn’t know how else to deal with my problems. I would even ignore him for days for no reason. Every time he’d try to talk to me, I’d shrug it off and complain about him being so annoying. I wouldn’t allow him in my room, and I’d yell if he tried to hug or show any kind of affectionate behavior.
Tired of My Role
I have a vivid memory of how I pushed him away, from the 8th grade. I had memorized the sound of my dad’s footsteps, deep and heavy. I knew exactly when he came home, and it wasn’t something I looked forward to. I could hear his footsteps stomping their way to my door.
There was a hesitant knock, and a “Hey, you there?” I rolled my eyes at his stupid question. My lights were on, and I was playing music at full volume. I was obviously there, but I ignored him.
“Can I come in?” he asked tentatively, as if he didn’t know if he should or not.
“No,” I said. Who did he think he was?
“I just wanted to say I love you.” His voice was soft and low, as if it was a secret. I got angry about this. I didn’t remember how to say I love you back.
A part of me wanted to say OK and let him in. Really deep down, I just wanted to jump into his arms and cry and tell him everything. I just didn’t know how.
I felt like I had a role to fill, the role of the “unresponsive, mean daughter,” screaming, yelling, and ignoring. It was awkward to suddenly go back to being the loving, caring daughter I used to be.
“Leave me alone,” I finally mumbled, burying my face into my pillow. I hear his footsteps retreat, and I felt regret and sadness.

Can We Change?

My dad is special to me, and I do care for him. I’ve tried to be closer, but that old part of me always betrays any progress I think I’m making. Instead of saying something nice, it’s a reflex for me to be angry and tell him to leave me alone. I’ve grown accustomed to this insensitive relationship that I now hate, and it’s hard to break the pattern I’ve developed with my dad.
I’ve heard people say that it’s OK to hate your parents when you’re a teenager, that when you’re older you learn to appreciate them. But what if that never happens? What if the only good memories I have with my dad are from when I was 5?
I’ve thought about telling him that I want to know he notices and respects the person I am becoming. But my dad doesn’t have a lot to say when I try to have a heart-to-heart. What if he doesn’t respond the way I want? It’s so hard to make yourself vulnerable to someone, even if it’s your dad, whom you should trust with your life.
I recently tried to express to him how I felt and he walked away as if his whole body just shut off. I’m pretty sure I was yelling at him then, so maybe he didn’t want to deal with an upset and irrational daughter. But we haven’t really talked since then either. We just ignore our problems, hoping they’ll go away, I guess. I think we each have to work on our problems by talking them out without hostility. I try to remind myself that it takes baby steps.
I want to make a promise to myself and to my dad. I vow to one day have a great relationship with him. It doesn’t matter if it’s tomorrow or in 20 years, I promise it’ll happen. But I’m still trying to figure out how.

View the lessons based on this story

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.