Should I hate my mom? She did put me in foster care. Or should I love her like any child should love their mom. Or should I hate my aunt for making it seem like I should hate my mom because of it? I don’t know what to do. My mind has no path to follow. I’m tired of feeling like I have to choose between who I love and who I hate. They are my feelings aren’t they? My mom has made many mistakes, but should I hate her for it? My aunt makes a pretty good point. My mother did give me and my sisters up. That’s not love. Or is it?
That’s one of my first entries from my first journal. I was 9 years old and in the 4th grade. My Aunt Carol had bought me the journal because I was always angry and she thought that writing down my feelings could help me.
I would wake up to the noise of my mom and my Aunt Carol arguing almost every other day. My mom had given me and my sisters up for care when I was 3 and my sisters were 8 and 10. My grandmother took me in, and Carol lived with us there.
My mother had given up legal rights to her kids, and she wasn’t supposed to be living with us. But often she would ask my grandmother to stay with us, and my grandmother let her. She was there in my grandmother’s house on and off the whole time we were in care.
And when my other aunt, Connie, would visit, the arguments got even worse. Those were the arguments my sisters had to physically break up. Those were the arguments-fights-that I hated the most.
I was being pulled in many directions. I didn’t know how to feel toward my mother or my aunts. Writing was my way of balancing my feelings. It helped me figure out my own emotions. Even if I didn’t get an outcome I got a better sense through writing of why I felt all these things.
For My Eyes Only?
Fourth grade was a very hard year for me in school. I got into a lot of fights and was out of control. I needed a new escape, because fighting obviously wasn’t working for me. In the journal I could let all my emotions out. My confusion, my tribulations, everything I was going through could be put on paper. In the journal, I could react to situations and problems privately.
I needed it to be private so I wouldn’t have to tell people how I felt. Aunt Carol was always pushing me to say things I didn’t want to say. She would get furious when I’d call my biological mother “Mommy.” She’d scream, “Remember, she’s the one who gave you away! And I’m the one who takes care of you! How could you love her?”
My aunt always threw in my face that my mother was on drugs. My mom carried her purse all the time, and when she would go in the bathroom you could hear sniffles. My aunt would say, “There it goes.” It seemed she was always trying to get me to say, “Yes, Mommy’s on drugs.”
So the journal was a place where my mind could be my own-or that’s what I thought. One day in 4th grade I was talking to Aunt Carol in the kitchen. Joking around, I said, “You need a boyfriend, you don’t do anything.” She opened the refrigerator and said, “According to you I don’t date men.” I didn’t understand at first but then it then hit me: One day when I was angry at her, I wrote in my journal that she was a lesbian. Which meant she had been reading my journal.
I got so pissed. But I didn’t show it. Instead I went to my room and wrote about why the person who bought me the journal would be reading it. I wrote at the bottom of the entry, ” I hope you like this one!”
Untangling My Feelings
I started to wonder if my aunt was telling the truth about my mom taking drugs. I felt like if it were true that she was a drug addict then I would have to hate her. And by hating her I would be pleasing everyone. Whether or not it was my aunt’s intention to make me feel this way, that’s how I felt.
It seemed like she was demanding that I say that I didn’t love my mother, sending me on a guilt trip of no return. Hating my mother would make me feel guilty because it wouldn’t be 100% my emotions. It would be based on stuff I heard from other people.
I could start to resent my mother, but then again my aunt wasn’t the cream of the crop either. She made my life difficult and complicated in so many ways. The name calling, the arguments, and sometimes just being around her was stressful.
Writing helped me out so much. Sitting alone with my journal gave me the space to be confused and to feel all my emotions. Because it was more than just picking sides: This was my life and I didn’t know how to manage my feelings. They were always flying around everywhere and writing seemed to condense them. My emotions flowed through my body into the pen and turned into words. Writing helped me deal with everything without getting into fights.
Several years later, when I was 11, Aunt Carol adopted the youngest of my two sisters and me. My other sister, the oldest one, did not want to be adopted but remained living with us. I was ecstatic to be free of the social workers’ visits and always being asked about how I felt about care. But I couldn’t understand how Carol could go from saying mean things to me-she called me a “crack baby” in one fight-to saying she loves me and adopting me.
The adoption made my life look more settled, but I was as confused as ever. Why was everyone close to me so unpredictable? Why had my mom given me up? What was going to happen to me?
It Worked for the Slaves
In school I learned about slavery and how the slaves wrote poetry and songs to express themselves. With all the emotions going through my head about my aunt, my mom, foster care, and myself I decided to try another style of writing.
My first poem wasn’t about my mom and my aunts; it was about my dad. I didn’t see him often. When I did see him I actually had a lot of fun. He usually took me out to eat or to movies. He got me tickets to a lot of concerts. The poem was about him not being there and an argument that escalated into me hitting him.
The words just came and the message was there, yet no one ever knew what I was talking about.
He can’t appreciate anything
He’s always cold
He’s always in the dark
He’s always alone.
Poetry is different than my journal because the journal entries were like notes that only I could understand. They had no structure. But poetry needs structure to make sense. There was always a rhyme that could describe what I felt.
It was amazing to me that poetry could do that. What did I feel about my dad, my mom, my aunts, fighting, my temper, being in care, being adopted? Somehow it made sense as poetry. As the rhymes came, they brought meaning to my thoughts.
Darkness has come
I’m alone in the night
Hiding my feelings
From everyone’s sight.
Hiding in the Poems
I look at poems and say “That’s how I feel now” or “I can’t believe I felt like that.” Looking back at my past, I can now say how I felt. I actually don’t like writing about my past because I have to re-live my feelings and the conflict to write the poem and it’s painful. Yet I write the poems because now that I’m older I can give my emotions names.
Even though I showed the poems to people, I was still able to keep my privacy. For example, older kids in my neighborhood called me “duck feet” or “two left feet.” I didn’t like it, but I never told them to stop it. Maybe they wouldn’t have stopped just because I said so, but they would have known that I didn’t like it-and I’d know they weren’t real friends if they continued.
But I never opened my mouth and said anything. I went home and wrote this instead:
Stick and stones
Will break your bones
But your words
Will never hurt this soul.
Dealing with issues that I had with other people usually led to arguing and that wasn’t good. I didn’t do well with confrontation. My temper wasn’t in control enough for me to confront anyone. I could just write that poem and be fine with it. The rhymes in my poems were so obvious yet so discreet.
New Functions
Now at 14 years old, writing has evolved for me. There’s still a lot I can’t control and a lot I can’t express, especially within my family (but at least my mom has gotten off drugs). When I’m confused or sad or angry about something I don’t want to deal with or can’t change, I still write poetry alone at home on my computer.
But now I have an iPhone, and writing is more immediate. The phone makes writing a lot easier, literally, because I’m not really writing. I’m touching the screen and I type. I’ve had my phone for a couple of months now. What the iPhone calls the Notes function, I call my journal.
I can pull my phone out anywhere and start typing and it helps me get through my day. I have written poems on my iPhone. I’ve even written a few iPhone poems with a friend. That writing feels less like an escape from life, since I’m doing it together with someone else. My writing overall is not as much about hiding my feelings. Now I want people-my friends, mostly-to know how I feel so things can change.
My Refuge
Writing helps me understand my feelings
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.