My “Perfect” Brother: I’m Always In His Shadow

The names in this story have been changed.
My brother Kevin was always the best at everything he did. Everyone expected him to succeed. Year after year he stayed at the top of his class without having to lift a finger. His grades were like the stock market on a good week-they seemed to just go up on their own. I, on the other hand, had to work my butt off to get the high grades that came to him so easily.
I was always competing with Kevin and my whole family knew it. I wanted to prove to myself and to everyone else that I was just as good, if not better. I achieved my high grades not just to build my own success, but as a weapon to use in my continuing battle against my brother.
Second Best
Our warfare left no physical scars, but inside I had this nagging feeling that no matter what I did, I’d never be good enough. I’d always be in Kevin’s shadow.
Our parents and grandparents let this competition go on, playing the role of referees. They would only intervene to quiet us down when they were sick of hearing our bickering. Since they judged us according to our achievements, not our efforts, I was always on the losing end.
Grades weren’t the only area where I came in second. Kevin didn’t just excel in his schoolwork, he was also popular. He seemed to have so many friends that I lost track of them. At home, I was like a secretary, answering his phone calls. Even some of my friends got to know who he was from school clubs and they’re now friends with him, too.
I could never be as charming as my brother. I only have the chubby cheeks that made me cute when I was young. But they aren’t so helpful now that I’m older. Kevin has the fame and the brains. Of course, I’m jealous. Who wouldn’t be? My brother was always the center of attention. If you heard laughter in school, he was probably the cause of it.
I, on the other hand, was always the listener. I was like a psychiatrist, the one people would turn to if they had a problem. I would be their shoulder to cry on after they had their fun. But sometimes I wished that I could be the leader of the pack. Instead of sitting on the sidelines taking care of the casualties.
As if his long list of friends and his shining career in school weren’t enough, my brother developed an obsession with becoming an actor. And when he tried out for his first school play, he didn’t get just a bit part. No, he got the lead! He sang and danced and everyone-including me-knew he was good.
Charming In Public, Obnoxious At Home
But there is another side to my perfect brother. Charming as he may seem with outsiders, when he comes home, he turns into a spoiled child who will do anything to get what he wants. With his friends he is nice, polite, and a respectful adult. But when he’s at home, he changes into a selfish, inconsiderate, arrogant glory-hound.
After being perfect every hour of the day in public, Kevin would lash out at home. Kevin, our younger brother Eric, and I were frequently left home alone. With no parents around to interfere, there were no holds barred. Kevin and I would begin fighting the moment he entered the house. (Eric did not get involved with our fights.) We each had our own territory, and if one of us crossed the line, a fight would start. The TV was the only thing that could distract us from our fights, so it was always on.
Kevin and I fought about anything and everything. Our battles seemed endless. They often ended up with me crying on the floor. Occasionally I’d win, but that winning streak wouldn’t last.
Daily Battles
One fight we often had usually started after dinner, while everyone watched TV. I would look at the clock and notice that it was time for our parents to be coming home. Meanwhile, the dining table would be a mess and the dishes would be piled up in the sink. From there, I remember screams of, “Why do I have to do the dishes?” and “You’re so lazy, you don’t do anything around this house!” going back and forth between Kevin and me.
When I started those arguments about chores, I was sure that I was right-that he should help with the chores-and I would naturally win the argument. I needed a victory against him. But it didn’t work out that way. Somehow, I would end up being the one who got in trouble with our parents.
Although Kevin is 18 now-old enough to move out of the house-he still wants to boss us around. He acts as if he had a right to just because he was born first. In the Philippines, where we come from, the eldest sibling is supposed to be revered. This tradition comes about because the eldest sibling has the responsibility to take care of the younger ones if anything happens to the parents.
I can’t picture my brother ever taking care of us. He claims the privileges of being first born, but he doesn’t take the responsibility that comes with it. In other words, he doesn’t earn it. He doesn’t do any chores like the laundry, or help around the house. The only thing he does is wash his own dishes.
He comes and goes as he pleases, and is rarely around the family. He doesn’t attend mass with us on Sunday and he skips family gatherings, such as birthday parties or graduations (other than his own of course). My parents have tried to enforce their rules on him, but my brother manages to get his way. They got tired of fighting with him so they finally gave up.
A Kind of Truce
Eventually I got tired of fighting with him too. It seemed that the only time we didn’t fight was when we didn’t talk to each other. So one day, a couple of years ago, I decided not to talk to Kevin anymore. That’s how the silence between us started. Now we only talk if he asks me for something, like to use the computer in my room. “Sure,” is all I say.
In a way, I’d say this is what finally ended our rivalry. My mom said we’d just outgrown it, and maybe we did. There was no agreement that we would not fight anymore and no apologies were exchanged. I just accepted the fact that I will have to live with Kevin for a while longer and might as well get along with him. I treat him as I would a tree across the street. I know that he exists. But he’s not an active part of my life; he’s just there.
It’s still a mystery to me why, when Kevin’s surrounded by people outside the family, he turns into a nicer person. He’s going to college soon and I hope the new environment will bring about a permanent change in his personality. If not, I will try to swallow my pride, and accept him the way he is.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.