My Long-Time Companion, My Thumb

“Hello, my name is Victoria and I am a thumb-sucker.” I stare at my reflection and feel like I belong in a clinic that specializes in curing childhood fixations.
I’ve been sucking my thumb as long as I can remember, and have been yelled at about it just as long. Teachers and parents and friends have shouted, “Vicky, get your finger out of your mouth!”
Does that make me want to stop? Sure. Can I? No. Since the pleasure derived from the habit is stronger than my desire to quit, I simply can’t.
My Friend ‘Sucky’
I get some weird comfort out of sucking my thumb, like it’s a safety net. It’s the ultimate problem solver; if all else fails, curl up and suck your thumb.
When I was little, I needed to hold onto a soft blanket to fall asleep. I didn’t have my “blankie” at my grandparents’ house, so my grandmother gave me an old satin scarf to use there. I named the scarf Sucky. Sucky and my thumb were my constant companions at my grandparents’ house.
But when I was 5, my grandfather said I couldn’t have Sucky anymore. He took it away, putting it in the kitchen junk drawer, thinking that taking away Sucky would make me get over my habit.
“You’re too big to suck your thumb,” he said. That was the first time someone told me I had to stop.
Big Girls Don’t Suck Thumbs
I was stunned. How would I fall asleep without my thumb? I needed it. But every time I stuck my thumb in my mouth, my grandfather would give my hand a light swat. “You’re a big girl now,” he said. “And big girls don’t suck their thumbs.”
That makes me laugh now, since I’m a big girl and I still suck my thumb. But when he told me then, I cried.
When I started kindergarten, my teacher, Miss Loux, tried to make me stop, too. She asked me why I did it and I replied, “Because it tastes yummy.”
“What does it taste like?” she asked.
“Like vanilla and chocolate combined,” I told her.
She said if I quit sucking my thumb the class would have a party with vanilla and chocolate. But I still didn’t quit, even with that incentive.
Because my classmates wanted a party too, every time I sucked my thumb, the kids in class yelled at me.
So I learned how to hide it. I pretended I was biting my nail or (very obviously, but as a kindergartner I thought it was ingenious) I covered my other hand over my fist.
My grandmother tried to get me to quit by wrapping my finger in Band-Aids and gauze at night. This kept my thumb out of my mouth for a bit, but later on during the night I got frustrated and sucked my thumb over the Band-Aid. I was a tenacious child.
As a result of my thumb sucking, I have light lines on my thumb and a small callus on my knuckle.
Speech and Teeth Affected
More importantly, I developed an overbite and a few speech impediments. I used to slur my words and had a slight lisp. Kids in school made fun of me, which made me self-conscious about talking in class. But my thumb was still there for comfort.
To get me to quit, my orthodontist put a dental device called “the hook” in my mouth. He attached it to two molars on opposite sides so that where my tongue usually rests against my teeth, there was a band of metal in the shape of an “m.”
This was supposed to make my habit uncomfortable, which it did. But after a while I got used to it and sucked my thumb anyway.
Outsmarting Myself
As I got older, I tried on my own to quit. I tried putting a chemical, typically used to stop nail biters, on my thumbnail.
But every time I used the chemical, I just found another way to suck my thumb, like turning it over so the nail didn’t touch my tongue or just putting the tip of my thumb in my mouth. It didn’t give me the same sense of calm, but it was better than nothing.
Since it’s often an unconscious act, I end up sucking my thumb in public. Sometimes I’m half asleep on the train, and then I notice someone across the aisle or next to me making a funny face or giving me a dirty look. Then I get embarrassed and quickly pull my thumb from my mouth.
When someone calls me on it, I feel hurt and betrayed. I just don’t know by who, as there’s really no one to blame except myself.
I’m Not the Only One
Since it’s a comfort device, too, I still do it at school. A few days ago, when a girl in my class laughed at me because of something I’d said, my thumb shot up to my mouth.
I didn’t notice it until my friend Michelle poked me in the arm and said, “Hey, I suck my thumb too.” She told me that it made her feel a little better that someone else did it.
And hearing about her habit gave me a sense of relief. I’m glad I’m not the only thumb-sucker in school.
We got into a deep conversation about it. Michelle said her parents made her feel bad when she sucked her thumb.
“I’ve tried to quit, but I just can’t,” she said.
When she got a tongue ring, she finally quit because that was something to suck on instead, but when she took the ring out she began to suck her thumb again.
But most of my friends don’t understand my need for the thumb. NYC writer Naomi Hopkins told me, “It’s a dirty immature habit and you should be placed under the jail.”
Healthier Habit Than Smoking
I laughed and told her that it’s not. It’s healthier than most habits, like smoking or drinking, neither of which I do.
My boyfriend doesn’t like when I suck my thumb, either. When we’re on the couch together, I often start sucking my thumb because I’m in a relaxed mood. Then he yanks it out of my mouth. Really hard!
So I snatch his, and tell him, “If you quit smoking, I’ll stop sucking my thumb.” He’ll bring up his latest feeble attempt to quit, saying, “I’ve only had three cigarettes today.”
“It’s a lot harder to quit sucking your thumb than to quit smoking,” I tell him. “My thumb is attached to my body, so it’s always there. You have to go out to buy cigarettes.”
“I’ve been smoking for nine years,” he whines.
“Yeah, well, I’ve been sucking my thumb my entire life,” I reply.
Content to Rely on My Thumb
If I could, I’d stop, but right now it’s just too hard for me. I need something to calm me down when I’m anxious, and my thumb is always there for me.
Besides, I reason that while it may not be pretty, it’s not the worst habit in the world. Sucking my thumb doesn’t hurt anyone. And it doesn’t hurt me, well, save for that over-bite I have, but it’s cute!
So I see no reason to quit at this point in my life. I have plenty of other worries to focus on, like finals, college and finding a job.

SIDEBAR: I’m Not Alone
Pediatricians say that the average age for children to quit sucking their thumbs is between 2 and 5. I’m 18 and still suck mine. “Thumb sucking in older children,” the Disney Encyclopedia of Children’s Health states, “may be caused by intense insecurities or shyness and thumb sucking may be used to relieve tension. Others may resort to thumb sucking to alleviate boredom or to help them fall asleep.” This is true for me. I need my thumb to put me to sleep and in almost every nervous situation, my mouth aches for my thumb. Thumb sucking is a cheap, convenient and effective way to calm oneself, according to ThumbSuckingAdults.com. It typically puts the thumb sucker in an instant state of meditation, lowering her heart rate. The site also says that sucking my thumb doesn’t necessarily mean there’s something wrong with me. It’s a coping mechanism and a habit. They surveyed 89 thumb-suckers between the ages of 11 and 45. In the survey, people listed their thumb sucking rituals. The most popular ritual respondents had was hooking their fingers over their noses, which I do. The next most popular was cuddling with a blanket, which I do when I go to sleep. As awkward as I feel about my habit, I’m glad I’m not the only one who does it. Maybe it’s not such a weird quality after all.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.