As teenagers in this city we’re faced with constant criticism from adults who don’t take us seriously. What, after all, do teenagers know about anything? That was the attitude that I encountered when I went to my school’s college office last month.
I walked in to give Mr. D my completed SUNY application. Mr. D was a teacher of mine in the ninth grade and knows me pretty well. He understands me and knows what I’m capable of. I had spoken to him several times in the hallway about my choices and I wanted him to be my advisor.
We talked for a while about school and my internship with New Youth Connections. Then I gave him the application. Originally I had selected only two SUNY schools but you’re allowed four and Mr. D had suggested I pick two more. My choices were Binghamton, Buffalo, Albany and Geneseo, all top SUNY schools.
Mr. D had some concerns about my choices since they were all hard to get into. He got up and went to get Ms. R, the head college advisor, who was standing right outside his office.
Until this year, she was the only advisor in the school. I had seen her a couple of times before. A friend of mine had told me about a meeting that she had with her and how Ms. R told her that she should change her choice of schools since they weren’t “realistic.”
Ms. R stood outside the door flipping through my SUNY application. I couldn’t understand what the big deal was. “What other schools are you applying to?” she asked as though she was in a state of shock from my application. “Brown, Syracuse, Ithaca, Cornell and Trinity,” I replied.
Get Real, Kid
“Cornell and Brown are very far fetched,” she said with her eyes still on my application. According to her, applying to one of them was a dream, let alone applying to both. “You have no backup schools,” she added. “And your SAT scores aren’t high enough to get into any of [those] schools.”
I admit that my test scores were low and I don’t know that they will go up, but a lot of the schools I am applying to don’t have a cut-off score. When I went up to visit SUNY/Binghamton, the admissions officer told me not to worry about my score. I had so many other things on my transcript that it was “evened out.”
I had researched the schools that I wanted to apply for and taken my SAT scores into account when making the decision. My family and I have thought long and hard about college. I had even spoken to graduates of certain schools. Since the end of my sophomore year I’ve been looking for the school that will suit me best.
Most of my SUNY choices are extremely competitive and even more rigid about things like SAT scores than private schools like Brown and Cornell. I never thought of them as backup schools. But I’m very confident about getting into two schools on my list.
Ms. R went on to tell me that the internship I am doing is a bad idea because now I’ll have to compete with students who are taking AP courses.
Who Was She Talking To?
It’s not as if this internship were the only thing I have going for me. In my sophomore year, I was chosen to be a participant in a foreign exchange program and I studied in Budapest, Hungary for six months. I am the editor of my school newspaper, a member of the National Honor society, and I rank in the top five percent of my class. So why all the doubt?
I was still sitting in Mr. D’s office. Ms. R moved in closer and stood over me with an artificial look of compassion. She handed me back my application and babbled on about how hard these schools were to get into.
Mr. D was still sitting next to me. “She has a lot of other things,” he started to say, but Ms. R interrupted him. She continued to drone on about my SAT scores.
I told her that I would be taking my SAT again the following week. “You can’t assume that they are going to go up,” she said. “For all you know, they could go down.”
I tried to explain to her that my scores were the way they were because I was very ill when I took the exam. I thought that would be enough. (I didn’t want to tell her that I had just been released from the hospital.) I think that one flew right over her head because she just continued to talk about my SAT score and about my ability (or lack of ability) to get into college.
I was about to kill her. The room felt like it was closing in and I could see my fingers wrapping themselves around her neck and squeezing all the life out of her. I wondered where she went to college.
A War of Wills
But I just sat there, numb, barely paying attention to her but all the time looking as though I cared about what she was saying. I could feel my face turning red and the heat that penetrated my cheeks was almost unbearable. If I opened my mouth I knew that only cruel and obnoxious things would come out but I tried anyway. “These are the schools that my parents are happy with,” I told her.
“Who’s the one that’s going to college?” she replied as if my parents had made the decision all by themselves. “We decided,” I snapped back at her.
Ms. R insisted that I take my application home and change one of the schools on the list to a school that I could be 100% sure of getting into. “If your parents would like to speak with me they can call me,” she said, shaking her head.
I told her that I’d think about it but I probably wouldn’t change the application because I liked these schools. Her response was, “Let’s be reasonable.” Reasonable, my butt. She uses that line on a lot of students. Reasonable for who? For me? I don’t think so.
I left the college office and went to work to call my father. I was very upset, more angry and annoyed than anything else. I told him exactly what Ms. R said and he-well, let’s just say that he wasn’t a happy person.
My father said that maybe we should put one more school on the list of hopefuls, not because Ms. R said I had no chance with my schools, but just to be on the safe side. I told him that was impossible because the college office would only process six applications and that would make seven. “She’ll process as many applications as I god damn well give her!” he yelled into the phone.
A Second Opinion
That night, we called a friend of ours who is a college advisor on Long Island. She had never before heard of such behavior. She heard what I had going for me and what I had against me and told me that, in her opinion, there were at least three schools that I could consider myself “in.” This made me and my parents feel a lot better.
The next day, I had to go back to school with my SUNY application. I had warned Mr. D that I would probably be returning with an unchanged application and I was right. There was no way that my parents were going to change that application and neither was I.
When I got to school, Mr. D was leaving. He said that I should leave my application with Ms. R. I felt uncomfortable with this idea since my parents didn’t want her to go anywhere near me or my application. Unfortunately, I had no choice.
You cannot imagine how much Ms. R had changed. I told her that I had sought outside advice from another college advisor and her only reply was, “You have a lot going for you.” All of a sudden I had a “good chance” of getting into at least two of the schools, she said. It was…scary.
What happened to the woman that made me feel like I had no chance of getting in anywhere? Maybe I had just gotten her on a bad day. I never did find out.
But what Ms. R had said really got to me. She didn’t have to tell me that my SAT scores weren’t good enough or that doing this internship would leave me in a bad position. Colleges don’t just look at one thing. This experience makes me a well-rounded person. I don’t just sit at home and study, I take initiative when it comes to my future.
She Made Me Feel Like a Fool
Besides, if I want to apply to a college and if my parents are willing to pay the application fee then I should be allowed to apply anywhere I want. Nobody has the right to put me down and tell me that I’m not good enough to get into the school I want. That may not be how she intended it but that’s what I heard her saying.
I understand that there is only one full-time advisor that deals with the applications in our college office and it is a lot of work. I feel for her. I’m sure she’s very helpful to a lot of students who don’t have the resources I do. But that doesn’t give her the right to insult me and make me feel like an incompetent fool.
As an advisor, her job is to sit down with me, answer my questions, go over my entire record and suggest some ideas towards a college that might suit me. She never did that with me and I wasn’t really asking her to. Still, it bothers me that I didn’t once see her pick up my transcript or ask me what activities I have participated in. She just jumped in with a conclusion that was based on a tiny fraction of the facts.
A college advisor’s job is not to insult you or make you feel like you’re worthless. If you’re determined to apply to a school that has high expectations of its students then who’s to say you’re wrong? Nobody has that right. I don’t care if they’re a college advisor or a psychic advisor, it’s wrong to take away someone’s dream.
SIDEBAR: Her Side of the Story
I decided to go back and interview Ms. R to find out why counselors may try to limit kids’ college selections or steer them away from their top choices. We ended up talking about many of the issues in this article including how important the SATs are. She conceded that if you have good grades “[colleges] might take a lower SAT. It depends on circumstances.” Ms. R also said one of the biggest problems her students have when choosing a college is that “they’re not being realistic because they don’t know what the reality is. They don’t have the credentials…They’re not really looking at themselves. It’s painful sometimes.” But sometimes it’s not the student’s fault. “I see kids being pushed by parents,” she said. “Parents make certain demands.” Nevertheless, she insists that students have to be honest with themselves about their record, their financial situation, and their willingness and ability to handle the college work. “Try to find something within [those] realities,” she says. But with so many different types of colleges in this country, a lot of students don’t understand why people like Mrs. R tell you only to apply to six. Sooner or later, she explained, “the student has to learn to work in limits and think hard about choices.” Ms. R feels it ought to be sooner. “A student can only go to one college,” she added. Another concern for college advisors is that if a college accepts a lot of students from a particular high school and none of them end up going there, the college might not take the applications of students from that school as seriously in the future. When a student applies to more than six or seven schools, Ms. R says not only is she wasting a lot of time and money on the applications, she’s also “jerking the colleges around…hurting other kids…future classes get screwed.” Ms. R concedes that another reason advisors want to set limits is that too many applications are hard on the college advisor too, especially in a big school where she has to advise more than 500 students. “I don’t have enough time to do the counseling,” Ms. R said with a hint of frustration in her voice. “This college office can’t handle more [applications]. We can’t physically do it.” Having a heavy workload may not give her the right to speak to me the way she did, but after my interview, I got to thinking about what it would be like to be Ms. R. I still question her theory about being “realistic.” Whose reality do you go by, the student’s or hers? But when she said, “Our kids are real needy, they need a lot of help,” I could tell that she really did care. Who knows, maybe I just got her on a bad day after all.
