One day last spring, I came home from school in a dancing mood. I went to my room, turned on the radio, and on came “Basketcase” by Green Day. Since I was home alone, I turned the sound up really high and started dancing. A few seconds later the door swung open.
“Turn that trash off,” yelled my older brother, Ahmed.
I turned the sound down but that wasn’t good enough for him-he wanted it off. He yanked the plug out of the wall and said, “No more juice.” That made me mad. It seemed he was always trying to control what music I listened to.
I started watching rock music videos back when we got MTV about a year and a half ago. Ever since, it’s been a constant battle between me and my brother. Ahmed listens to hip-hop groups like A Tribe Called Quest, Wu-Tang Clan, and the Artifacts. He loves rap about as much as I love rock and he can’t see why a Black person would listen to anything other than “Black” music.
My other brother and sister listen to hip-hop too and my parents listen to jazz mostly. Out of a family of six, I’m the only one who listens to rock.
A New Frontier
I used to listen to r&b, but then the lyrics all started to sound alike and I got bored. Listening to rock made me feel like I was discovering new territory. It was great learning new songs and seeing new bands. I began to see myself as someone who likes to try new and different things.
My brother Ahmed, on the other hand, isn’t one to experiment. According to him, Blacks should listen to music made by Blacks and Whites should listen to music made by Whites. I think a person has a right to listen to whatever she feels comfortable with. Music should not be another racial issue dividing our society.
When we were younger, Ahmed and I used to listen to hip-hop music together. We would play video games and listen to rap at the same time for motivation. We’d sing along or dance to new r&b songs on the radio and stay up late listening to 98.7 KISS-FM whenever there was an all-night rap show.
So when I started listening to rock, Ahmed didn’t go along with it. The problem was not so much the music itself, but the fact that I, a Black girl, listened to “White” music. He felt strongly that I was running away from my culture and trying to be something I’m not.
Listening In Secret
I always looked up to my brother and cared what he thought of me. At first I tried to hide the fact that I liked rock. One day two summers ago, when he walked in on me while I was watching “Black Hole Sun” by Soundgarden on MTV, I pretended I wasn’t enjoying it as much as I was. “You like this crap?” he asked in surprise.
“No,” I said, embarrassed. “I hate this group.” And I changed the channel.
After a while I just stopped caring what he thought of my music. But Ahmed made fun of it every chance he got. He’d come into my room and talk about “Devil’s music” or call it “suicidal.” He would imitate the singers and do crazy dances.
He Made Fun of Me
He would also change around the lyrics to songs that I liked to make them seem ridiculous. In the song “Killing in the Name of” by Rage Against the Machine, for example, there’s a line that goes, “Now you do what they taught ya.” But my brother twisted it up and said, “Kill yourself if you want ta.”
In the beginning I found his silly imitations funny, but after a while I started to get annoyed and felt like he wasn’t just making fun of the music- he was making fun of me.
After Kurt Cobain killed himself, Ahmed called him “Kurt blow-my-brain Cobain.” He thought the whole thing was a big joke. I don’t think joking about someone’s death is right so I got angry.
After about three months of his joking, I started to get very defensive. And almost every other day, we began to yell at each other. On some occasions, I’d try to get the channel changer away from him or we’d throw things at each other.
One time last fall, Ahmed turned the sound on his radio up real high. Since our rooms are so close together the noise was blocking out my music, so I turned my radio up.
This went on for about five minutes until finally you couldn’t distinguish one song from the other. My parents were downstairs so I didn’t think they would hear. But my father, who couldn’t believe the racket, came upstairs.
‘Grow Up Already’
He yelled, “Turn that down!” which we did.
Usually when Ahmed and I fought, my father would come in annoyed and ask, “What’s the deal now?”
When he found out it was about music he would say, “Not this petty bull again. Why don’t you two grow up and stop acting like children?”
My mother tried to talk some sense into us too. “You should know better, Ahmed,” she would say. “Being the oldest, you have to set an example.”
After a while I learned to cope with my brother’s annoying behavior. Whenever he came home I would turn the radio off so I wouldn’t have to get into another argument. To avoid being made fun of, I listened to my music through earphones.
But then I noticed Ahmed still listened to his music as if nothing had happened. I felt disrespected, and I knew I had to think of something to put an end to this problem before I went out of control and broke everything in Ahmed’s room.
‘Let’s Take Turns’
So, I went to see him.
“I have an idea about how we can both listen to our music,” I said.
“Did I invite you in my room?” he asked coldly.
“It’ll just take a minute,” I said. “We can take turns listening to our music. I can listen to rock music for an hour, then you can listen to your music for an hour. What do you think?”
“I’m not listening to rock music for no amount of time,” he said. “Now get out.”
I tried other things such as asking him to close his door so he wouldn’t hear my music. But, since our rooms are right across the hall from each other, that didn’t work either. I tried to get him to wear earphones too, so neither one of us would bother the other, but he hardly ever went along with that.
Finally, in May, my father provided a lasting solution. It was early one Thursday morning, and my music was playing at a moderate level. My brother woke up, came into my room and pulled the plug.
“It’s too loud.” he said.
“No it’s not.”
‘He Started It!’
Who was he to turn my music off? I was angry and couldn’t think straight so I threw books and hangers at him.
Just then my father came down the hallway and poked his head in the door.
“What happened?” he asked.
No one spoke. My father waited a few seconds before asking again.
“What happened? No one wants to talk?” he said.
“It’s Zakiyya,” Ahmed said.
“No it’s not!” I yelled. “Ahmed started it. He comes in my room and turns off my music because he said it was too loud.”
“Well, what sound level did you have it on?” my father asked.
I plugged the radio back into the wall.
“That is a bit too loud for morning,” my father said. “Why don’t you put [the volume low enough] so that no one will be disturbed?”
He walked over to the radio and turned it down.
“Is that OK for you. Ahmed?” he asked.
Respecting Each Other
“Yeah,” my brother said.
Then my father went into Ahmed’s room and adjusted the sound on his radio.
“Is that OK for you, Zakiyya?” he asked.
“It’s fine,” I said.
From then on we’ve had to listen to our music at that volume. My father also got us to agree to respect each other’s styles by not criticizing the music we listen to or the clothes we wear.
My father’s solution brought back a certain level of maturity between me and my brother. It enabled us to respect one another again. Nowadays Ahmed and I argue less and are a little more tolerant of each other’s styles. He’s beginning to realize that I’m serious about rock music and it’s not just a phase I’m going through. And I’m taking advantage of the fact that I can listen to my music without any problems.
Music Wars
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.