Movie Review: Dirty Girl in Search of a Missing Father

The other day I went to see the film Dirty Girl , thinking it would be an amusing little ’80s road trip movie. The trailer for it barely hinted at what was actually expressed in the movie. I was taken aback at how much I connected to the film’s plot and characters, and how it got me thinking about similar issues in my own life.

Dirty Girl takes place in a small Oklahoma town in 1987, where Danielle is the girl with the bad reputation at Norman High. In the opening scene she primps herself after exiting a noisily swaying car in the school’s parking lot. Danielle (played by Juno Temple) lives with her mother and never knew her father. Her soon-to-be-stepfather moves in with his two kids, and announces that he wants to adopt her and convert her to Mormonism. He tells Danielle that now she’ll have a father and “a real family.” Danielle resents him and her mom, whose sudden interest in religion seems phony.

In a scene where Danielle argues with her stepfather as her mother looks on, I was reminded of the friction in my own home when my stepfather first moved in. At 12, I was furious that he thought he could come into our home and take over. I was afraid that my mother would always side with him, and that’s what it seemed like for much of the time.

Danielle fulfills her need for attention and control of her situation by acting out at school and sleeping with a lot of guys. After she asks an honest question about sex in class, the principal calls her a “dirty girl” and puts her into special ed class.
Parenting a Flour Sack
In special ed, most of the students just seem to have issues at home, not necessarily learning disorders. Misfits, “bad kids,” and the pregnant girl make up the small class, along with Clarke, the friendless fat kid who sits in the back of the room. Clarke (played by Jeremy Dozier) has yet to come out of the closet, but his father suspects that he’s gay. The father beats Clarke and sends him to a therapist to “cure” his homosexuality. The therapist shows Clarke graphic heterosexual porn and tells him if he’s not aroused, something must be wrong with him.

At first, Danielle and Clarke are brought together through a project where they’re supposed to raise a flour sack as if it were their baby. The assignment doesn’t seem important at first, but their relationship morphs into a solid friendship as they start to embrace their co-parenting project.
Clarke reveals to Danielle that his father beats him, and she opens up to him, too. Danielle longs to know her real father, and with Clarke’s help she finds him in her mom’s yearbook. After convincing Clarke to steal his father’s car and credit card, the new friends take off to California with their flour sack baby.

On the trip west, Clarke accepts that he’s gay as Danielle prepares to meet her father. She hopes to start a new life and get away from the bad reputation she has back home. However, once she gets to California, Danielle is distraught that her father (played by Tim McGraw) has his own family and doesn’t welcome her as she’d imagined. The scene when she first meets her father’s family was the most emotional for me.
Fatherless?
Dirty Girl had a serious impact on me because I grew up without my father much of the time, and faced the same conflicting emotions that Danielle presented in the movie. When she and her stepfather argue, she explains that she doesn’t want to be adopted because she has her own father. I feel the same way. Although my father is absent, I don’t see a need for a substitute or a replacement.

Though I had met my father before he vanished from my life, Danielle’s story mirrored my relationship with my father, because he’s married and has a family that I’m not a part of. I feel tinges of resentment because he’s never been there for me the way he has for his other children.

Part of me feels as though I’m not a complete person without a relationship with my father. Something seems to be missing. The movie captured that feeling by showing how far Danielle went to connect with her dad. She changed her outfit to meet him, and tried to carry herself in a way that would win his approval. Danielle and I want our fathers to be proud of us.

I felt connected to Danielle because she tried so hard to convince everyone that she was strong and in control, and didn’t need a father figure. I’ve longed to know if my dad actually wanted me, and like Danielle, I’d tell myself and others that I didn’t need my father to be happy or successful, and that one day he’ll regret that he wasn’t a part of my life.
Hurt and Confusion
I’d push everyone away, including my mother, to make it seem as though I didn’t need their support or approval, because I really only wanted that attention from one person. Danielle and her mother display that same strained relationship in the movie. My father’s absence also molded my actions when it came to boys and dating and how I felt about myself. Like Danielle, I had sex before I was fully ready to and I think it was because of my longing for some sort of male attention.

I still feel confused and frustrated because I’m not really sure if I need my father as emotional support. There are times when I think about how far I’ve come without a father figure and feel good about myself, but when I see some of my friends with their dads I see something there that I don’t have. What bothers me the most is that I don’t feel acknowledged or accepted as his child. I feel as though my father doesn’t want me to exist at all.
Once Danielle and her father meet, he apologizes to her, saying that he didn’t know she existed and that he thought her mother, pregnant in high school, “would get rid of it.” It hurt me to think about a parent wanting nothing to do with his own child. It reminded me of times when I questioned why parents were together in the first place if they couldn’t handle raising a child.

I’ve felt the same longing to be close with my father for years, and seeing my emotions on a big screen made me feel less alone, especially now that I’m attempting to accept my situation. Dirty Girl will stir up different emotions in everyone because it covers so many teen issues. I’m glad that the advertisements drew me in enough to see it, because it’s more than a fluffy’80s comedy.
Dirty Girl should be available on Netflix soon.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.