More Harm than Good

I can bet that the people who thought of this solution have never been through the things that we’ve encountered after being separated from our parents.
Since I left home a year ago, I’ve had to live each day as it came, never knowing who I could count on or where I would end up next. My life has constantly been affected by forces beyond my control-I’ve been homeless and jobless-and no one seems to care.
(I must also add that foster care has at times been a life saver. It has protected some young people from home situations that would have been much worse. But to purposely take children from loving parents who simply can’t afford to support them is crazy.)
Times Have Changed
Things aren’t the same as they were years ago. Orphanages might have worked back then, but now things are more complicated. Children aren’t as angelic anymore. They can be easily influenced by negativity and easily frustrated, and there definitely aren’t too many Daddy Warbucks around to save the day. I don’t think it’s fair for government officials to play with the lives of others just to fulfill their childhood fantasies of orphanages.
Newt Gingrich has based his orphanage plan on the 1938 movie Boys Town-a film about a forever-optimistic priest who miraculously transforms young “vagabonds” into well-behaved children.
In today’s world that priest and his motives wouldn’t survive a week. For example, whenever the boys in the movie had a dispute among themselves, they resolved it in a boxing match-with the priest as referee. In the group homes we come from, that sort of “resolution” would only cause more violence.
Why Not Ask Us?
Larger, overcrowded orphanages will lead to more problems for youth. Big buildings will be overflowing with depressed children, and drug dealers and pimps won’t be able to resist the temptation. Drug abuse will increase and crimes will follow, no matter how many security guards and nuns are in charge. Then again, maybe that’s what these government officials want.
Maybe the government should ask the young people who are already in foster care if they’d rather be where they are or with a loving parent. I’m sure most would choose the parent, even if it meant living with a single parent through hard times. Isn’t that what families are about-staying together through thick and thin?
Maybe if Gingrich (the drunk driver behind the wheel) spent more time trying to understand what the lives of foster care youth are like, he would know what he’s attempting to do to innocent children.
Trying to rush a solution to a problem (poverty) that has been around for a long time can only bring greater problems. Taking children away from their parents will cause them psychological problems in the long run.
If I was on welfare and those payments were cut off and, for some justifiable reason, I could not get a job, I would as soon attack the person in charge of this conspiracy rather than put my child through what I’ve had to go through. And I’m sure I’m not the only one who feels that way.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.