Mom’s Boyfriend Makes Home Hell

(All names have been changed.)
My parents divorced when I was 6, and I’ve lived with my mom and younger sister Tiffany since the split. I’d like to think that my mom’s made a better choice for herself the second time around, but I can’t.
After the divorce, Mom dated different people. Around two years later, she stuck with one guy, Earl, who she’s with now. Even though I liked Earl at first, we don’t get along now, which has affected my relationship with Mom and how relaxed I feel in my own home.
When I first started to hang out with Earl, I was in 2nd grade. He was a sarcastic, carefree guy. He always took me out for ice cream and movies, so I thought he was cool.
Like a Second Father
Soon, we started going as a family to places like Coney Island, Six Flags, Las Vegas and Disney World. We had a great time.
Whenever I was upset, I talked to Earl because he listened and offered comforting advice. I got into an argument once in 6th grade with my friend over an ugly sticker she gave me. (I know it sounds silly, but I was young.)
I told him what happened and he said, “Just apologize to her. It’s not worth fighting with a good friend.” I really appreciated that.
I started to consider Earl a second father because he was with me more than my dad, who I only saw on Sundays. After spending so much time with Earl and gradually accepting my parents’ divorce, I wanted Mom to marry him.
Noticed a Different Side
But by 7th grade, I started to notice things about him that I was too young to notice before. Or maybe it was because he was over at my house more. He had a set of keys and came over whenever he wanted, so I really got to know him.
He got angry over the stupidest things. If any of us disagreed with him, he wouldn’t talk to us for a week or two.
One night I had an argument with Mom. I was very angry, so I slammed the door to my room. The walls in my house are thin, so I can hear everything going on. I overheard Earl telling Mom she should punish me and that she’s too easy on me.
Mom disagreed and said it wasn’t a big deal. Earl’s temper exploded and he stormed out of the house. He didn’t speak to her for a week.
Angry Over a Donut
Every time my mom has a fight with Earl about my sister or me, she blames us for his actions. Every time I complain about Earl to my mom, she ignores me and says that Earl loves her. She defends him and says he’s right when it comes to their arguments.
But I want Mom to stand up for herself and not suck in everything Earl tells her. Other fights she’s had with him were so ridiculous. One time, we went to Dunkin’ Donuts, and Mom bought the wrong donut. Earl’s temper blew up.
He yelled, “You can’t follow a simple order. I wanted one donut and you messed it up.” Mom felt bad and offered to get him another one, but he said no, and was angry the whole night.
Whenever Earl treats Mom with no respect by yelling at her, I get angry. She doesn’t deserve to be treated like that.
Sometimes I tell him what he did was wrong. He just ignores me and pretends he didn’t hear me. It makes me want to strangle him because it feels like he doesn’t want to deal with his issues.
Punished Over Exaggerations
After five years of having him around the house, I now know Earl to be an instigator, exaggerator and liar.
When Tiffany and I fight, he not only tells Mom we had an argument, but exaggerates the situation, making it seem worse than it was. We then get punished because of his exaggerations.
Mom usually believes him over us, which pisses me off. Then I call my grandparents because they believe me, which makes me feel better. But I still want my mom to listen to me.
After slowly accepting my parents’ divorce, I now have to deal with my family being split up because of Earl’s lies. Last year, Earl planned a vacation for both his family and my family. Approximately a month before vacation, he told Mom that he saw Tiffany hanging out with five guys in Coney Island at midnight the previous weekend.
He Got Tiffany Grounded
But Tiffany was with me that night, and I told Mom that. I said that Earl was crazy. Mom just said Earl would never make up a lie like that. Usually I don’t defend Tiffany because we argue a lot, but this was ridiculous. Why did he tell such a lie?
My mother said that Tiffany couldn’t use the phone or hang out after school for a month. Tiffany was so angry she decided to skip the vacation. She didn’t want to go anywhere with Earl.
Then finally, the day before vacation, he admitted that he lied. Mom couldn’t figure out why he lied, but she forgave him, even though she felt terrible for grounding Tiffany. Everybody went on the vacation but my sister.
Couldn’t Find My Stuff
I missed Tiffany when we were away. I knew she would’ve had an amazing time. Mom felt bad that she wasn’t there and called her every night. Because Earl lied, he ruined a beautiful vacation for her, and that’s something I won’t forgive him for.
He’s also done freaky things, like hide our belongings. One day last year I couldn’t find my makeup, my sneakers or even my book bag. I had a feeling Earl was behind their disappearance, but my mom kept denying it. I was angry because I had a test 1st period and didn’t want to be late.
It took me 25 minutes to find my stuff, which was under the couch. I came in late for the test.
I was very angry that evening and when I asked Earl if he hid them, he denied it. But about a month later, he admitted to it.
Funny Guy or Troublemaker?
Mom still believes Earl over us even though she knows he’s a liar. When I ask her why she believes him, she usually says that it’s his sarcastic sense of humor, meaning he lies to be funny.
I disagree, because I don’t think he’s humorous. His “sarcasm” continues to cause my sister and me a lot of pain.
Recently, I cried because he decided to hide some of my belongings yet again while I was sleeping. I couldn’t find some of things I needed to get ready in the morning, and felt so frustrated.
I think Mom listens to Earl because she loves him and doesn’t want to lose him. To see her trust somebody who’s untrustworthy makes me feel like mom has lost respect for herself. I’m sorry, but if somebody keeps lying, there is no way I can trust that person.
Home Doesn’t Feel Like Home
I despise being around someone all the time who I don’t trust . I don’t care about the things Earl’s bought me and the trips he’s paid for. It’s not about the money. It’s about his lies and how he treats my family.
Home doesn’t feel like home to me. Whenever he’s over, I have to be careful about what I say to my sister. And I don’t have friends over when he’s there because I’m afraid he might hide their stuff or pull some other crazy stunt.
Sometimes I get so pissed at having to deal with this crap that I slam doors in my house and kick loose objects lying around in my room. After I calm down a little, I call up my friends and tell them how I’m feeling. They usually calm me down and ask if I want to come to their house, which I usually do.
Closer to My Sister
I also go over to my grandparents’ house to get away sometimes. When it’s late at night, and I’m stuck home with Earl, I play video games, listen to music or talk to my friends over the phone so I can avoid him and maintain my sanity.
Tiffany and I have also become closer as a result of the drama.
We don’t have much in common, but talking about Earl gives us something to bond over. We’ve agreed to stand up for each other and not talk to him if he’s going to continue his behavior.
Thankfully, I won’t have to deal with him much longer. I’m a senior now and when I’m a sophomore in college, I plan to get an apartment with my friends.
My Wish for Mom
But it’s still hard.
I love Mom very much and don’t want her to be with a man who’ll constantly be mad at her and treat her poorly.
Sometimes I wish it was just Mom, Tiffany and me. But since I know Mom doesn’t want to be alone romantically, I’d like for her to at least be with a kind and honest man.
I wish Mom could see who Earl really is and come to her senses. Even after I leave and don’t have to deal with him anymore, I hope one day Mom realizes she can make a better choice.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.