One afternoon, a few weeks ago, Devika Murray, 15, of Dana Hall School, went to the ice-cream parlor with some friends. Devika ordered chocolate and one of her friends ordered vanilla. When the ice cream arrived, Devika said it reminded her of Michael Jackson and how he’s changed over the years. “This is Michael before,” she told her friends, pointing to the chocolate, “and this is Michael now,” she said, pointing to the vanilla.
The changes in Michael Jackson’s appearance have been causing rumors and gossip for years. After all, when Michael first became a star, as the lead singer of the Jackson 5, he looked like most African-American boys. He had a dark complexion, broad nose, big lips, and an Afro hairstyle. Now, he looks more like a Caucasian man with pale skin, straight nose, long hair, and thin lips. It’s hard to believe he’s the same person.
People wondered: Did he bleach his skin somehow? Have plastic surgery? What was he doing to himself? And why? More than 90 million people watched his interview with Oprah back in February to find out.
Michael told the world, through Oprah, that he has a skin disease. But that didn’t end the controversy. Some people believed him, while others didn’t. Some wondered why, if he has to use makeup to give himself an even skin tone, he doesn’t use a darker shade. Some people felt sorry for him, while others, like Devika, made fun of him.
Why are people so interested in Michael’s appearance? Does the fact that the color he is now is different from the one he was born with affect how people feel about him as a performer? To find out, I interviewed several teenagers as well as some adults who remember what he looked like when he was a child.
He’s Putting Down His Race
A number of people I spoke with didn’t believe Michael when he said he had a disease. “It is highly unlikely,” said Nordia Garnett, 15, of Clara Barton HS. Nordia was one of several African-Americans I spoke with who are angry at Michael for “putting down his own race” as she put it.
For some people, Michael is the ultimate example of a Black person trying to be White. Because he is so famous, he represents the Black community in the larger society and some people believe that what he does reflects on the rest of us. “We don’t want people to have the impression that there is something wrong with being Black,” said Devika.
Jacob Dennis, a guidance counselor at Paul Robeson HS, remembers growing up with Michael Jackson. He said he wasn’t convinced by Michael’s story because his skin isn’t the only thing that has changed. “He had a number of plastic surgeries to reshape his features to resemble those of the Caucasian race, indicating to people that he doesn’t feel good about himself as a Black man,” he said.
Stefanie Siegel, a teacher at Robeson, agreed that Michael is trying to be something he’s not. She asked why he didn’t respond to all the rumors that were going around sooner, if he really had a skin disease. “He is trying to make himself into someone else by trying to change his looks,” she said.
Why Would He Lie?
Despite all these criticisms and accusations, Michael’s loyal fans continue to defend him. They tended to blame the media for going over the limit and focusing on this negative controversy rather than the positive things about Michael-his talents and how he’s used his money and fame to support worthy causes.
The media “are jealous of his talents, riches, and wealth” said Deneva, 20, of Borough of Manhattan Community College.
Sheila McClintock-Fraser, a teacher at Robeson HS, agreed. “If you are a Black person who makes a lot of money, the media want to make money off you.” She said she believes Jackson has a skin disease because “Why would he come out on worldwide television and say something that’s false? I don’t believe he would do it because, if push comes to shove, it can be proven.”
There are also a few people, including me, who don’t care what Michael Jackson looks like. As Ms. Davis, another teacher at Robeson, put it, “He can do anything he wants with himself. It doesn’t matter to me that he has or has not a skin problem. All that matters is that I love his music and he is number one.”
Michael Jackson: Does It Matter If He’s Black or White?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.