As a Muslim teenager, I find myself having to explain a lot of my beliefs and traditions to non-Muslims, particularly when it comes to dating.
Because of religious tradition, most practicing Muslims don’t date. That comes as a shock to many American teenagers because they tend to fixate on romantic love and relationships.
Not dating makes me different from most of my classmates. I don’t have much of a life other than school, work and hanging out with friends. On weekends, I usually hang out with my family, which includes not only my brother and parents, but also my cousins, aunts and uncles.
In my culture-we’re Bangladeshi-families tend to be close; like mine, many get together almost every weekend, so that takes up time. I don’t know how I’d fit in time for a love life, even if I could have one.
Boys and Girls Can Be Friends
It’s not written in the Quran that Muslims aren’t allowed to date, but it’s implied, and that’s what our elders teach us. Boys and girls are allowed to be friends. But the closeness of the friendship has its limits.
If it reaches a point where it could almost be romantic, then it’s considered wrong. That’s why many Muslim parents don’t allow their children to have too much interaction with members of the opposite sex.
Adults don’t date either. Many Muslims who go to college marry in their early to mid-20s, after they graduate. And yes, many have arranged marriages.
I realize that many people think this concept is weird. “How do you not date?” they ask. “What, you all have arranged marriages? You can’t pick who you’re gonna marry?”
Parents’ Marriage Was Arranged
That’s not far from the truth, but an arranged marriage doesn’t mean it’s necessarily forced on the couple. Most people meet who they’re going to marry or at least have some sort of contact with them before that type of commitment is made.
Most arranged marriages I know of have worked out. I don’t know if it’s just a coincidence that the matches I know of are successful or if the couples are just lucky, but they seem happy and committed.
All the marriages in my family were arranged. Some knew each other beforehand. My parents were classmates in college before they got married. They liked each other and were friends, but the decision of whether they should get married or not was made by their parents.
My aunt and uncle only met each other once before their wedding, when he went with relatives to her house. They both agreed to the match. Both of these are good working marriages.
I Had Crushes on Boys
I know it may seem unreal and confusing to have arranged marriages and not date. But it doesn’t just confuse non-Muslims; some Muslims are puzzled as well.
I told my mother once during 9th grade that I was having a tough time dealing with not dating. I didn’t understand why I couldn’t do it. My mother and I hadn’t talked about the issue of dating before, because she didn’t think I was really into boys in junior high.
But I did have major crushes on boys, crushes I look back on and laugh at now because I was so into those guys, I constantly tried to talk to them in hopes of becoming friends.
Now I realize two things: First, I can’t flirt. I’m shy and flirting makes me uncomfortable. Second, I didn’t get the clue that they didn’t like me back.
‘We Don’t Do That’
But even if they had liked me back, nothing would’ve come out of the relationship. The thought of it happening was exciting, but actually going through with it would’ve been nerve-wracking for me.
I understood how my parents felt about American forms of romance because when we saw couples kissing outside, they’d say “We don’t do that,” as in Muslims don’t show public displays of affection. If there was kissing on TV, they’d change the channel.
My parents didn’t like me watching TV shows that featured teen romance, so I was stuck watching kiddie shows like Barney when I was 13. When I turned to a channel that depicted romance, they made me change it or told me that I shouldn’t watch those shows.
But I snuck to the TV sometimes and watched Beverly Hills 90210 and Dawson’s Creek anyway.
Missing a ‘Normal’ Teen Life
By the time I turned 14, though, it seemed that all my classmates were dating while I wasn’t. I felt I didn’t have much to talk about with my friends and classmates, because our conversations mostly focused on their dating lives. Dating seemed like a “normal” part of a teen’s life to me after witnessing my friend’s lives and seeing it on TV and hearing about it in songs.
But even though I wasn’t dating, I worried that my parents thought I might be. I didn’t talk a lot about my friends or my life in school with my parents and I worried that they thought I was hiding something. I felt guilty trying to watch the romantic TV shows that they didn’t approve of.
Now, I think my fears that they didn’t trust me had more to do with my own doubts of whether I could trust myself to be obedient. I didn’t like feeling left out, but I also didn’t want to defy my parents.
Talking It Out With Mom
A couple of months into my freshman year, my mother realized that I had something on my mind. “Abanty, what’s wrong?” she began.
I was reluctant to answer. But she saw right through me.
“Why are you sad lately?” she asked. “Did you do bad on a test? Or did you have a fight with friends?”
“I just have a lot on my mind,” I told her. Somehow we slowly got on the topic of dating without mentioning it straightforwardly. We sat in the kitchen for some time discussing how tough it is to live in America as a Muslim teenager.
“I was a depressed teenager,” my mother said. “I got upset and overwhelmed myself with the smallest things until I talked to someone about it and realized that others have the same problems.
“And I know that you don’t exactly feel that way, because it seems that everyone else has different experiences than you and it makes you feel left out.” It was a relief to feel like my mother understood.
Some Parents Are Too Strict
I’m thankful to my parents for allowing me to be independent, yet giving me rules to follow and support. They don’t believe that constantly forcing a child to follow her parents’ rules is the best way to get the child to listen and obey.
They find that encouragement and support in other aspects of life, such as career choices, are more positive parental influences.
They even realized that the TV shows I like to watch had little effect on me and gave me more freedom to watch them.
But I have some Muslim friends whose parents worry so much about their children dating that they hold onto them with a leash. One Muslim girl I know got in trouble for sneaking around with her boyfriend. Her parents found out and forced her not to see him again, but she kept seeing him and ended up getting caught once more.
She finally ended the relationship, but her parents are now reluctant to trust her. She has to live with her parents being even more overprotective and overbearing than before.
My Friends Are Enough
I’ve had the opportunity to pursue relationships, but I’ve held off for a few reasons. One is that it’s not a huge priority for me at this point in my life. I know that’s hard to believe, but if it really was, then I’d have done it already.
After my unhappiness freshman year about not being able to date, I gradually decided that my friends were as much as I could handle socially.
Many of my friends who date complain about how it takes up too much of their time or they get annoyed with the person they’re seeing. I like not having to deal with that.
Not dating has kept me more focused on things I want to do with my life right now, like writing for this paper and working hard in school.
Also, my parent’s trust is very important to me. Sneaking around wouldn’t make them more supportive. And I don’t want them to be disappointed over having a disobedient daughter.
Not Dating Is a Big Deal
Finally, and most importantly, I haven’t found someone I feel is worth getting into that much trouble for this early in my life. I’m sure my parents would eventually find out.
Being a Muslim teenager in America is complicated enough. Having to be a Muslim teen who hides a relationship from her family, including her own parents, would be doubly difficult.
Still, not dating is hard. Non-dating Muslims don’t run around yelling, “I can’t date. It’s depressing!” But that doesn’t mean we’re not affected by it or sometimes upset about it.
It’s Hard Not to Be Attracted
There are a few Muslim teens I know who say they’ve never thought about dating; they’re so strict about their beliefs that they feel they’re defying Islam just by thinking about it.
I find that difficult to believe, because it’s hard not to be attracted to people. Also I feel that it’s not thinking about attraction that’s wrong, but acting on those thoughts. I don’t believe I’m doing anything wrong by being truthful.
Most of my friends who don’t date, some Muslim and some not, are usually saddened because they’re alone. I think relationships, whether friendly or romantic, are part of a teenager’s life, and without experiencing the latter, I sometimes feel like I’m missing out.
My Cousins Understand
Usually when I have problems with it, I talk to my cousins or my friends. Those who have been in the “real” dating world advise me on things to look out for, like getting too emotionally involved with guys, and other situations that might be hard for me to handle.
My cousins also have to deal with not being allowed to date, so it doesn’t feel weird when we talk to each other about it. My friends are sympathetic, but only a few don’t date, so even though they care, they can’t relate to my situation.
Still, they help me get through my sad little problems by talking and giving me advice on how to be happier and confident with my life.
An Arranged Marriage for Me?
I’m hoping that if I can survive through high school without giving into the pressure of dating, I should be able to make it through college without many problems. I’ll probably start thinking about meeting a guy to marry around the time of my college graduation.
Thinking about it now makes me laugh, because I don’t feel ready to go through that process. I don’t know whether or not I’ll have an arranged marriage, though it’s a strong possibility; I have to wait and see.
I realize that if I go away to college and I’m not living at home, it may be tougher to maintain my non dating stand. But I know that I’m level headed enough to do what suits me.
Maybe I’m being Little Ms. Goody-Goody, but if my actions-or no actions-leave me happy and without any regrets, then that’s what’s right for me. And if I can stay true to my parents and my religion while being self-reliant, then that’s even better.
Living Single
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.