Keeping It Private

When I was 16, my friends advised me not to go to a gynecologist. They told me that if I wasn’t a virgin or had performed some other sexual act, the doctor would tell my mom and I’d get in trouble. At that point, I had nothing to hide, since I hadn’t had sex, and so I didn’t worry.
But my friends were wrong. Even as a minor, I had the right to keep my exam private, so it stayed only between the doctor and me.
As a teen, it’s hard to know what rights you have to services-or privacy-when you need health care. Many teens don’t get the care they need because they fear that the doctors or nurses will disclose personal information about them to their parents or guardians.
Medical Records Marked Private
It’s true that in some situations, minors aren’t allowed to make health care decisions without parental involvement. But in many cases, laws protect teens’ rights to confidential health care services without a parent’s consent. Confidential means that the doctor won’t tell your parent or guardian about your visit, what you and the doctor talked about, or any medical care you may have had.
Carolina Lajara, community liaison at Metropolitan Hospital’s Youth Health Services, explained that their clinic puts a special number on a patient’s medical records so that it will show up on the computer as private; aside from the health care workers there, only the patient is allowed to see her record.
Sometimes, to get back in touch with patients, the clinic mails them a color-coded flyer. “Once they see the color coded flyer, they call us up and we can easily identify them,” she said. “We might need to ask the patient’s address and parents’ name, but that’s only for registry purposes and that information is not used anywhere else.”
Get Birth Control on Your Own
Many teens become sexually active before they turn 18-and before their parents want them to. They may not want their parents to know that they’re sexually active, or even just thinking about having sex.
But in New York, you can get birth control without having to tell your parents. You can also get emergency contraception-the “morning after pill” that prevents pregnancy if taken shortly after unprotected sex.
And if you’re pregnant, you can get prenatal care or decide to have an abortion without parental involvement. You can also get confidential treatment for sexually transmitted infections (STIs), including HIV.
New York has similar laws about mental health treatment. A minor can get many kinds of mental health or substance abuse treatment without his parents’ consent or notification if the parent is unavailable or refuses to consent, or if the doctor decides that parental involvement would do more harm than good.
Doctor-Patient Privilege
Teens who are victims of sexual assault usually need both physical and mental health care-and that’s kept confidential, too. The New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU), in its guide to teens’ health care rights, gives the example of a 15-year-old girl who’s been sexually assaulted. She needs an STI check up, emergency contraception, care for bruises and other injuries, and to see a rape crisis counselor.
If she’s afraid to tell her parents, she can still get the help she needs, and they won’t be notified. The hospital can’t tell her parents without her permission, or report the assault to the police unless she agrees, due to confidentiality laws. Confidentiality laws are known as “doctor-patient privilege” and mean that whatever you and your doctor, nurse, or counselor discuss stays between the two of you.
Too Dangerous for Privacy
There are some times when doctors or others treating you may be required to tell parents or other authorities about your problem. For example, if health care providers find out or suspect that you’re being beaten or sexually abused by a parent or guardian, they must report child abuse.
And psychologists and psychiatrists may disclose confidential information about you if they feel that you’re a danger to yourself or to others. For example, if you tell a therapist that you’re thinking about suicide, she’ll most likely tell your parents and urge them to get you immediate treatment, such as hospitalization.
In school, staff and parents have the right to access official health records, such as immunization, height, weight, sick absences, and anything else that is general and not covered by laws as specifically private. But if the student goes to the school nurse to discuss anything private, like pregnancy or any other sex-related topic, that matter is supposed to be kept confidential.
Be aware, though, that confidentiality laws only cover health care providers. If you ask your gym teacher to excuse you from gym because you’re pregnant, the teacher may share that information with others, because there is no law preventing her from doing so. It all depends on the teacher.
What About the Bill?
Even if you feel safe about going to the doctor and keeping it confidential, there’s still the bill to deal with. Does it come home? And if it does, will it break your cover?
Some insurance companies may compromise confidentiality by sending bills home. However, the state does require insurance companies to let patients know about a possible disclosure that may occur during billing.
Minors should always ask if their treatment or lab bills will be sent home, and if that’s a problem, arrange another address for billing, such as a trusted friend’s.
Sometimes, too, if a payment is delayed or the insurance denies payment, the bill will be sent home. And many insurance companies send records of all medical visits to the person who holds the insurance policy.
But some clinics will let you pay cash on a sliding scale-meaning whatever you can afford. And some clinics that deal with minors, like Metropolitan Youth Services, are free. If avoiding disclosure is essential, you’re better off going to a free clinic, or asking the clinic to send the bill to another address or take the complete payment right there.
We Had the Doctor Call Me
This is useful information to know, as I found out recently when I took a friend of mine to a gynecologist. Brianna (not her real name) is 14, and was worried she might be pregnant. She wanted to have a confidential exam.
During the visit, we asked the doctor if she was going to notify Brianna’s parents, but she said that she’d keep all the information private. We also asked about the billing process and if that would risk Brianna’s confidentiality, but the clinic arranged for the bill to be dealt with between them and an insurance company.
Brianna also got tested for different STIs. In order to keep the tests confidential, the clinic agreed to call me and let me know the results so her parents wouldn’t be tipped off. (I did say I was her cousin, though, and I’m over 18, so that may have helped.)
Brianna and I were satisfied with the visit, because the clinic respected her rights. And since Brianna’s only problem was stress, it was a great relief to her that she didn’t have to alert her parents about her false alarm.
To find confidential services for teens, check out the list on page 25. And to learn more about your health care rights, go to NYCLU’s Teen Rights Initiative web site: http://www.nyclu.org/thi/index.html

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.