It Hurts to Fall (in Love)

The names in this story have been changed.
“Falling in love is not a blessing, it’s a danger. Love yourself rather than a stranger.”
That’s a true saying from a true poet-me. It refers to a lesson I learned about relationships. Too bad I had to learn it the hard way.
Two years back, when I was 14, I met the guy who would later inspire me to write those lines. I was walking home from school on a warm September day, and I kept hearing a car horn blowing. Not to be conceited, but I was pretty sure that it was honking for me.
He Honked and Pulled Over
I was wearing a miniskirt that day and figured that was why I had attracted the driver’s attention. I didn’t pay much mind; I just went along my way. But that didn’t mean I wasn’t flattered!
Whoever this guy was, he wasn’t giving up. The car circled me about three times and finally pulled up at the corner just ahead of me.
Just then, I bumped into my best friend, Penny, and pointed out the car that had stopped for me. She started smiling because she knew the driver. It was Roger, this guy she always talked about. She had often told me what a good and caring friend he was.
Penny started to pull me towards the car. I was reluctant to go, due to my shyness. She introduced me to Roger and my heart started pounding as I looked into those brown eyes of his.
The First of Many Phone Calls
I don’t think Roger even saw my face because I was hiding behind Penny. I heard him mention something about his phone number and I shook my head meaning, “yes.” He handed me a piece of paper. I took it and quickly left.
On the way home, I thought about how handsome Roger was and what a soft and soothing voice he had. And, of course, I thought about whether I should call him. It didn’t take me long to decide-about 15 minutes after meeting him, I knew I had to hear his sweet voice over the phone.
One phone call led to another and pretty soon we were talking on a daily basis. At first our conversations were friendly, nothing more. He told me he had a girlfriend so I figured he wasn’t interested in me in that way. Mostly we talked about our interests, such as music and TV shows.
Just Friends…At First
About a week into this phone relationship, Roger told me that he was 20. I was surprised. Penny had never told me how old he was and I had thought he was probably 16 or 17.
We were becoming good friends but I thought the age difference would make things a bit awkward, and that we probably didn’t have as much in common as I thought.
But the more we talked, the more we opened up to each other, sharing our problems and giving each other advice. Despite the difference in our ages, I knew there was something between us.
We would often talk about relationship problems. He would tell me that he thought his girlfriend might be cheating on him and I would tell him to give her another chance.
After a while, I regretted saying that because the more I got to know Roger, the more I wanted him to forget about his girlfriend and go out with me.
I’m Not Allowed to Date
A couple of weeks after we met, Roger and his girlfriend broke up and our friendly conversations became more and more flirtatious.
I would usually call him as soon as I got home from school and the first thing he would say is that he missed me and was so happy that I called. Just the mention of another girl’s name would get me jealous and if I mentioned another guy, I would hear a different tone in Roger’s voice.
About two months later, we finally revealed that we liked each other. That should have been the end of our problems, but it was just the beginning. I had to tell Roger that as much as I wanted to, we couldn’t actually date. My parents are very strict and don’t allow me to have boyfriends.
Once, when I was about 12, my mother came home early one day from the store and caught me and this guy just talking in the hallway of our building. She had a fit.
She cursed me for about a half hour and threatened to tell my father (if he found out, I knew he would hit me). So I knew there was no way they were going to let me see Roger.
We Promised to Wait For Each Other
Roger said that maybe it was for the best that we couldn’t see each other right then. He had just broken up with his previous girlfriend and was busy looking for a job, so he thought it would be good for him to be single for a while. He told me that we would be together some day, that I was worth the wait.
Since there was really nothing we could do about it, I agreed to be patient. Roger and I made a promise to wait for each other for five years. By that time, I would be an adult and not have to worry about what my parents might say.
This seemed like a good idea at first. Knowing that we would be together someday kept me going, but it wasn’t easy. Never getting to see Roger was driving me crazy.
I couldn’t concentrate on my schoolwork because I would think of him so much. I yearned to hear his sweet voice every day and every night. Sometimes we talked on the phone from 11:30 p.m. till 2:30 a.m., sharing our hopes, wishes, dreams and desires.
Two Minutes Together
Finally, I couldn’t bear it any longer. I had to see my love. One day when my mom went out to do an errand, I called him and told him that he should come by.
A few minutes later, I heard a car horn. It was a cold winter night when I came out of the house to see him, no coat, no shoes. I gave him a letter and a necklace that said “Someone Special.”
We were only together for a minute, maybe two. My knees felt weak, my heart was pounding, and my hands were trembling. I had been in love with his voice on the phone, but that night, meeting face to face, I felt that love in my soul.
Roger asked me for a kiss but I was too shy in front of him. Anytime he looked at me, I looked down at the sidewalk.
I wanted to touch him, to kiss him, so badly that night, but I was so scared, and excited, and shy that I just couldn’t.
I knew my mother would be back any minute. I really had to get back into the house, so we said goodbye.
I looked through the window to see if he was still there-he was. I took one last glance and saw that my mom had pulled up right beside him. I was more than lucky that night.
Phone Calls Weren’t Enough Anymore
A couple of days later, Roger and I had a long talk on the phone. I told him I wouldn’t mind cutting school once in a while to see him, but he didn’t want me getting in trouble for him.
I told him I was willing to take that chance, but he wouldn’t hear it.
That was the first of several unsuccessful attempts to end our “thing.” Though we made a “promise” not to speak to each other for a while, I didn’t keep my word. I was so miserable and lonely that I beeped him the next day.
Then, two days later, he beeped me. He told me he missed me a lot, too. His voice was so loving and caring. I felt him in my heart. His love was with me and that was all I could ask for at that moment.
I Couldn’t Take 5 Years of This
But I couldn’t take not seeing him, not having our relationship develop. Five years was starting to seem like too long to wait.
A couple of months later, I said to him, “Remember when you told me you weren’t ready and you needed time and you didn’t want a relationship? Well, now I’m not ready for the friendship.”
I knew I couldn’t keep talking to him on the phone like a regular friend would, knowing I had these strong feelings for him.
I think both of us were finally realizing that we might never get to be together. So, we said goodbye to each other on the phone. The pain that day was unbearable.
I didn’t want to let him go and I didn’t want him to let me go, but it seemed like I had no choice. I wanted to be Roger’s girlfriend right then, not in five years.
A couple of days later, I saw Roger on the street and called him over. He came up to me. I said his name, twice. He looked at me for a second, then he kind of smiled and walked away.
That’s when I realized that things were never going to be the same again. After our close friendship and all those late night phone conversations, it ended like that-with him turning away from me.
I Thought We Were in Love
When we were talking, not a day had gone by when he didn’t say something sweet to me or let me know that I was loved by him.
He spoke to me as if I were the most precious thing in the world, and it was his sweetness that made me hold on for so long.
It had never crossed my mind that maybe Roger didn’t love me as much as he said. Then, a couple of months after we stopped talking, I found out that he had started seeing a girl named Janet.
I couldn’t believe it. Roger and I spent eight months getting to know each other, he knew I cared for him a lot, but then he went out with someone who he barely knew.
A few weeks later, I heard that they had broken up. I thought that meant that Janet wasn’t the one for Roger, that only I could make him happy.
Just when I started to think that we had a future together after all, I found out Roger was going out with another girl.
Now He’s Dating a Friend of Mine
His new girl, Anna, is a friend of mine and she is one of a kind. It’s so hard for me to hate her. She is going out with the guy I love, but she’s too sweet and loving for anyone to hate.
I never mentioned to Anna that I had loved her boyfriend, and he didn’t mention it to her either. When Anna tells me all of these things about him, it’s very hard not to get jealous. But most of all, I’m sad because I wanted Roger to be with me.
I think it would be much easier if I didn’t hear his name so much. It hurts a lot when I see them together and when she tells me how much she loves him.
Roger and I will never get back the closeness we once shared, but I still call him once in a while to see how he’s doing.
It Still Hurts
Though the hurt is still there when I hear his voice, it makes me feel mature to know that I can talk to him without breaking down and crying or doing something foolish like asking him if we could have another chance, even though, deep down, I still think we would be perfect together.
I really believed that because we loved each other everything would work out between us in spite of the odds.
One lesson I learned from my experience with Roger is that relationships are more complicated than that.
So, if you fall (in love), you better make sure you’ll be able to get back up. It’s taken me two years to get over Roger, and I’m still working on it. It’s kind of hard to forget about someone who touched your heart with his words and even harder when your skin has never even felt his touch.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.