One morning I saw a video on MTV by the rock band Boys Like Girls. It was the first time I’d heard of them, so I listened closely to their song, “The Great Escape.” I liked it-until I heard the lead singer belt out, “Let’s get drunk and ride around.”
I was disgusted. How could a band popular among teens like me choose to celebrate drunk driving? But my disgust soon turned to puzzlement. I thought of all of the hip-hop videos I’d seen where the word “gun” or the mention of drugs got censored on MTV. Why wasn’t “Let’s get drunk and ride around” censored, too?
‘No ID’ Edited Out
Shortly after, I saw the rapper Young Buck’s video, “Let Me In,” and that made me more confused. When Young Buck raps, “I know you gonna let me drink with no ID,” the words “with no ID” are edited out.
This makes no sense. Young Buck doesn’t actually say that he wants to drink while being under-aged. He simply says he wants to drink without being carded-and that’s censored. Yet drinking and driving isn’t censored in “The Great Escape.”
I started paying closer attention to what got censored on MTV. Of course, hip-hop gets censored a lot, which makes sense since it has so much obscene language. But it seemed that much of what’s censored in hip-hop songs is given more leeway in rock.
Is’White’ a Bad Word?
In the song “All Falls Down,” rapper Kanye West speculates that a “white man” ultimately benefits from various drug transactions. “White” is blocked out, as if it were a derogatory term. But in American Idol Carrie Underwood’s song, “Before He Cheats,” a woman is described as “singing some white trash version of Shania karaoke.” Here, “white trash” remains.
When rapper T.I. claims in “Rubberband Man,” that he’s as “wild as the Taliban,” the word “Taliban”-a staple of the nightly news-is edited out.
What was going on? Who was doing the censoring and why? I called MTV to find out, but after my repeated calls and even emailing my request-as they told me to do-no one ever got back to me.
So I called some record companies, whose employees told me they send their original videos to MTV, and they’re told what to change. And they agreed that when it comes to censoring, hip-hop gets away with less than other types of music. “Rock can get away with more than hip-hop,” a staffer who works at Atlantic Records’ video department told me. “They censor hip-hop more than other genres,” agreed Angel Martinez, a product manager at record label G-Unit.
No one could tell me why MTV is stricter on hip-hop. And it worries me. I’m a black teenager, and hip-hop is a huge part of my culture. And throughout history, many forms of black musical expression have been criticized and suppressed because of prejudice toward the black people who created it. Just as mainstream America once suppressed jazz, MTV is scrutinizing a form of black expression more zealously than other music. And this inconsistent censorship sends a bad message to teens like me.
Reinforcing Racist Ideas
Sure, we may not consciously realize what’s happening when we hear the words edited out of hip-hop remaining uncensored in rock songs. But we definitely sense it. And it teaches us to apply different standards to different races. It says to us that black artists need to be monitored especially closely.
I’m not saying MTV is racist. I’m not saying they do this on purpose, and I believe there are valid reasons to censor some of the violent hip-hop songs. But if MTV is not careful, some of its censorship practices may inadvertently reinforce racist ideas.
Is MTV Harder on Hip-Hop Than Rock?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.