I first heard of Facebook from my sister in 2005 when I was a junior in high school. “Another MySpace,” I thought, paying it no mind.
Like MySpace, Facebook is a social networking website. People join to meet new people with similar interests, but mostly to communicate with existing friends. You can post pictures of yourself, send messages to your friends, leave comments on your friends’ personal pages, list your class schedule and create online clubs. Seeing as how I had no good pictures and I saw my friends every day, I thought it was pointless to join.
But last summer, most of my friends who were entering college created accounts. Facebook is by far the most popular networking site for college students. In 2005, 85% of college students signed up to the site, and over 60% visited it every day, according to a Facebook spokesman in an interview on techcrunch.com. Not wanting to feel like the odd man out, I decided to sign up too. On the first day of school this year, I went to the Facebook website and clicked to the “Register” page.
Odd Man Out
“Enter your college email,” was the first thing I read on my screen. “That’s odd,” I thought. Most sites just ask you for your email so they can send you stuff. My optimism died down a little when I realized that getting into Facebook was going to take some effort. I didn’t have a college email because I wasn’t in college. So I did what anyone would do in my situation-I made one up. I typed in “[email protected],” the most common name I could think of.
“That email is not recognized by Facebook,” it said.
Faking it wasn’t going to work. I figured the site must check people’s email addresses against each college’s list of student email addresses to see if they’re valid.
What about using someone else’s college email? That seemed simple enough. I tried my sister’s old Hunter College email, which she hadn’t used since she’d transferred to another college two years ago.
I got in with no problem, but then I realized how silly it was to borrow someone else’s credentials to use a site. For one thing, I’d be automatically entered into the Hunter College network-grouped with a bunch of “friends” I didn’t even know. I couldn’t view my actual friends’ pages without asking permission first.
I figured it wasn’t worth the hassle of explaining to people how I’d been “accepted” to Hunter a week after their classes had begun. So for a while, I was out of the “Facebook club” because it was restricted to college students. Or so I thought.
High School Students Out!
About a month later, I found out that a high school version of Facebook had been created in September 2005 and no one had bothered to tell me.
And last February, Facebook began allowing college and high school students to add each other as friends. Until very recently though, you could only get in if another high school student invited you (now anyone can join). I got an invite from a high school classmate in October and I was finally in.
But after I was in, I discovered that the college students on Facebook resented high school students being able to register. They had formed online groups to write long, indignant rants about it. The most popular is the Anti-High School Facebook Coalition. At one point, it had more than 1,000 members. Its purpose? To complain until they convince Facebook to not let high schoolers join.
One of the mature, adult messages they posted was: “High School Students on Facebook Is WHACK!”
“But why?” I asked a friend of mine from Brooklyn College. She summed it up for me.
“High school kids have Sconex and MySpace. Facebook should be for us,” she said.
‘That’s Not Fair’
I noticed two funny things about her response. One was that although we were friends, I apparently wasn’t included in the “us,” because I wasn’t in college. And also, she said “high school kids.” We were in high school together just three months ago. We never called ourselves kids then. Did she now consider me a kid?
My friend wasn’t the only one who had this reaction. When I told my college-age sister I’d registered for Facebook, her first response was, “That’s not fair. You didn’t even have to do anything for it.” As if me being a member made her membership less meaningful.
Growing Pains
Despite the anti-high schooler stuff, I was still interested in Facebook, so I decided to do some research. I found out that Facebook started out just for Harvard students in 2004. Then it expanded to several other Ivy League colleges, and eventually to most colleges in the U.S.
Every time Facebook expanded, some of the original members protested in online groups. I wondered why they wanted to keep others out of an experience they enjoyed so much. Could it be that some college students, maybe even most, have come to think of signing up for Facebook as a rite of passage?
The idea behind the site is based on an old “coming of age” tradition of sorts. Facebooks-what the site gets its name from-are guides that colleges traditionally give to freshman when they first arrive.
They include things like pictures of faculty and students, along with their contact information, information about the campus and school rules, and a letter from the school president or dean welcoming them to the university. Basically, it’s a way for the college to tell freshmen, “Congratulations, you’ve made it.” In other words, it’s a rite of passage.
A College Tradition
But many colleges, especially large public universities, don’t seem to give out these facebooks anymore. Most of my college friends thought that “facebook” was a word the website had made up. For a lot of them, signing up on Facebook is a way, sometimes the only way, to declare to themselves and others that they’veentered a new community.
As someone who hasn’t graduated from high school yet, I’m not part of that community. I can’t meet someone from my dorm and add them to my list of friends on Facebook, or find out about an upcoming party on campus. And no, I can’t join together with other people online to mock high schoolers. The more time passes, the less I use Facebook.
No Need to Exclude
Part of me understands why many college students wish the high school students on Facebook would go away. they’vegraduated high school and made it into college, what society tells us every teenager should achieve. It makes sense to want to honor your achievements and share them with others; after all, that’s what a rite of passage is all about.
And I suppose some people have to feel left out in order for others to feel like they’re a part of something special. In a way, Facebook is like prom, graduation, joining a fraternity or anything else that signifies you’ve moved on to something bigger-just this time, it’s out there for millions of people to see.
At the same time, though, I don’t think you have to exclude or put down others to feel good about yourself. I hope that when I enter college, I remember that. Because a real rite of passage should be about joining others who’ve shared the same experiences as you-not about leaving others out.
Is Facebook a Modern Rite of Passage?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.