Immigrant Workers: Who’s the Victim Here?

Immigrant Workers: Who’s the Victim Here?

“These lazy immigrants, they come here to get on welfare and live off our taxes.”
“They’re taking away our jobs.”
“There’s so many of them. They’re like ants.”
Sound familiar? I hear it all the time.
Maybe some immigrants are here to get on welfare, but the ones I know are decent, hardworking human beings. They want to make things better-for everyone. But many are shunned and alienated because of the stereotypes.
I think a novel that I recently read in my immigrant literature class best describes the growing tension between immigrants and American-born citizens. Jasmine, by Bharati Mukherjee, is about an Indian woman who emigrates to America to escape religious violence in her homeland.
One of the most powerful things in the book is a description of an America’s Most Wanted-type TV show, where U.S. Immigration agents raid a Texas lawn furniture “factory” that employs illegal Mexican immigrants. A reporter interviews local residents about the incident.
“To tell you the truth,” one woman tells him, “I don’t know what to feel anymore…Steve, my husband, lost his job. That was last November. We were doing so good, now we can’t make the house and car payments. Are you listening, Mr. President?”
“I wanted to shout [at] the lady,” says Jasmine. “What kind of crazy connection are you trying to make between Mexicans and car payments? Who’s the victim here?”
Now, that’s an important question: Who is the victim? Is it the “average” American? Is it the immigrant worker? And where’s the connection between Mexicans and Steve losing his job?
The Real Bad Guys
Factories and sweatshops were created by American businesses in order to make some good ol’ American profits. And how do you make a profit? By cutting costs like salaries and worker benefits.
Immigrants (especially “illegals”) can’t complain about one or two dollar-an-hour wages, unsafe and unsanitary working conditions, or 60 hours-a-week of slave labor. Nor can immigrant workers unionize, and negotiate for better wages and conditions.
They take such horrible jobs because they have no choice. They slave hoping to save $10 to send back home each month. That $10 can sometimes feed an entire family. Now what American would want to take such a job? Not Steve. No way.
Immigrants don’t come here to take away anyone’s job. We’re here to work hard and better ourselves, and we’re anxious to contribute to American society. But far too often we’re scorned and rejected. We become scapegoats for economic and social problems like unemployment, failing schools, and hard times.
The real culprit is American greed, wealthy businessmen who would do anything to save a buck, including building factories in foreign countries where they can exploit even more desperate foreigners. Those are the people who took away Steve’s job, and millions of others like it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.