Immigrant Students Have a Right to Education…

Immigrant Students Have a Right to Education…

In 1982 the United States Supreme Court said that immigrant parents had the right to send their children to school, even if they were here illegally.
But until recently, the Immigrant Students Rights Project was getting calls from immigrant parents saying schools were asking for identification in order to enroll their children, according to staff member Kathy Jarvis. Thanks to the work of organizations like hers, she said such calls virtually dropped off to zero.
After that it wasn’t a question of whether parents were being welcomed into schools, but how they were being welcomed. “You don’t have an access problem,” Jarvis said. “What we continue to work on is sensitizing school personnel.”
To do this, in November, 1986, AFC sponsored a hearing to identify problems immigrant families faced in and out of the school system.
At that time, access to school was still a major issue. But Brooklyn housing lawyer, Roger Juan Maldonado, said that even after immigrant students were admitted into school they were often placed in classes where they didn’t belong: “When the [placement] evaluation is conducted, the chances of it being an appropriate evaluation are almost nil,” he said. “How can you possibly determine [the source of a child’s problems] if the evaluator does not understand the language of the child and is not familiar with the [child’s] background and culture?”
School Children Denied Lunch
Daniel Abreu, a bilingual educator in Upper Manhattan, said when he began teaching in the late 70s, “Hundreds of non-English speaking children were denied lunch on a regular basis for not following the rules given to them in English or because they had made errors when they filled out their lunch forms…In general, the reception given to the immigrant children was so negative and hostile that many of them were turned off to their new society.” By 1986, Abreu added, the situation had not significantly improved.
Since that hearing four years ago, Advocates for Children (AFC, the sponsor of the Immigrants Students Rights Project) has helped to establish a Chancellor’s Advisory Committee on Immigrant Affairs.
Last year, on the committee’s recommendation, all school districts were instructed to appoint one person to coordinate services for immigrant students and monitor the progress of individual schools.
When asked about the effectiveness of sensitivity training for staff versus a more hard-line approach, Jarvis said, “Unless you win over those liaisons to really feeling that they have a responsibility…unless people have a commitment, then [rules and regulations] don’t mean anything.”
Reaching Out To Parents
She added that she has been very encouraged by the work of the liaisons. In District 25 in Queens, Jarvis said guidance counselors have begun to reach out to parents who work long hours by setting up weekend and evening conferences and providing materials in Chinese.
Besides building pockets of increased awareness and commitment throughout the school system, AFC is working to make sure immigrant students are also treated fairly in society at large. Last year, due to their efforts and those of other community organizations, the City University began charging the much cheaper resident tuition to undocumented students living in New York City.
Meanwhile, they struggle to reach the immigrant students themselves to let them know about their rights and the many services available to them. Through community organizations they reach parents and others who stay far away from “the system.”
Reaching Out To Teens
One particular group Jarvis would like to reach out to in the future are teenagers who are here on their own, working illegally, and sending money back home to their families. She said they are mostly young men who share apartments with other young men and work in grocery stores or other small businesses. They don’t go to school and “don’t know [their rights]…without outreach, just forget it,” Jarvis added.
[For information on immigrant rights, call the Project at 718-729-8866 on Monday or Wednesday between 1 p.m. and 5 p.m.]

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.