Imagining a Brighter Future: How Independent Living Needs to be Reformed

While many are pleased that foster care teens are getting attention and increased funds from the federal government, Youth Advocacy Center believes that if the current independent living programs are not rethought, this money will not significantly help young people learn to live on their own.
For teens in New York City, independent living programs vary greatly. A few do a good job supporting young people living in their own apartments or in job training. But many more programs offer rote classes which are repeated every few weeks or months, attempting to teach things like budgeting or finding an apartment by reading the newspaper or a book.
Not surprisingly, a lot of foster youth don’t attend these classes, and many of those who do say they go only to pick up a $25 stipend check. The Government Accounting Office testified before Congress that the few available studies show that many former foster care youth don’t complete high school, are dependent on welfare, become homeless, and generally have trouble becoming self-sufficient.
Overall, too few teens are helped by independent living classes.
We, at Youth Advocacy Center, have some suggestions for how IL can be improved:
1) Downplay the dismal outlook and focus on what teens can achieve by changing the idea of “independent living” to “future planning.”
Independent living programs focus on avoiding “negatives,” like homelessness, drugs and unplanned pregnancy. Logically, it is difficult to attract people to a program that identifies them as future losers.
People are more likely to attend programs that focus on their futures in a positive way. Young people in care need help in planning their futures in a way that demonstrates that they have a chance at success–not just a chance at avoiding failure.
2) Put more resources into helping individuals reach goals and less on teaching rote tasks.
Right now, the state requires programs to provide formal instruction in job search, career counseling, apartment finding, budgeting, shopping and house cleaning. In addition to that, many programs try to fit in sessions about parenting, safe sex, legal rights, hygiene and cooking. This is too much, with too few resources, and not in a context that makes sense to teens.
IL “skills” can be taught more effectively by helping teens actually plan for their own futures. For instance, at Youth Advocacy, instead of focusing on teaching specific skills–like how to dress for an interview–we first have teens visualize where they want to be in five years. Then we help them make a concrete plan of action for how they’ll get there. This helps them learn how to take responsibility for their futures.
3) Expose teens to adult and peer leaders with experience in the “real world.”
Young people in foster care need contact with adults other than their foster parents, social workers and court-appointed lawyers. They need to learn how to build relationships with adults who are not paid to care for them.
Programs to serve teens in foster care should recruit and train adults from the world outside of foster care to serve as teachers, guest speakers and mentors. If the program’s focus is on mentoring, teach young people how to be mentored. A key part of that is for teens to identify their own goals and to consider how the mentor can help them toward those.
Young people who have been through foster care should be recruited and trained to serve as peer educators, role models and as informal supports.
4) Create programs with high expectations of teens.
Many IL programs don’t expect much from teens. Instead, programs should expect teens to attend when enrolled. Expect them to be on time. Expect them to do assigned homework. Expect them to listen to others, and to ask questions. Respond to their questions seriously. Do not tolerate behavior that would not be tolerated in a work or college situation.
Teens will respond to high expectations. While some will drop out or be dropped from the program, many others will reward the program with respect.
Young people deserve and will respond to programs based on their hopes and goals for a brighter future.

SIDEBAR:
In my group home we have independent living about once a year and they would have a staff come in and teach us, but they’d be quick to get it over with. They’d run through it so fast that we didn’t understand what they be talking about.
–Naquan Walker, 18
To me I find that the times I’ve gone to an IL class was boring. The class lasted an hour but it felt like a longer period of time. Every year we learn about the same topics that we learned about the year before. We discuss things like budgeting and how to use a checkbook, how to write a resume, things like that. We get this booklet that we skim through, and then for the rest of the time we talk about the topic. If a person is coming from school they are not going to want to feel like they’re in school again.
–Anne Ueland, 15
Independent living is boring. If I could tell them why I’d say: “Every time I come to the program all you do is talk about the same old sh-t. If I wanted to listen to the same old sad love song, I’d listen to Toni Braxton.”
–Forever Broughton, 20

SIDEBAR: OK, so we’re going to receive more money for independent living. But how much money will be used for each kid?
The John H. Chafee Foster Care Independence Program increases federal funding of independent living programs from $70 million to $140 million-or less. The law authorizes $140 million for programs for teens in foster care, but that does not mean the full amount will be used. Only $105 million is available so far, according to Rep. Benjamin Cardin, one of the sponsors of the bill. But even if Congress does end up setting aside the whole $140 million for teens in foster care, because there are about 150,000 teens in care in the country, that would be only about $900 per teen per year. It will be even less than that per teen for many other reasons. For instance, the law lets states use up to 30% of the money they receive for room and board for 18-21 year olds who have left foster care. This is important because in most states teens must leave the system at 18, and they certainly need help living on their own. But it also means that the money will be spread out over even more young people than the 150,000 teens in care. The law also requires Health and Human Services (HHS) to use 1.5% of the $140 million ($2.1 million) for evaluation of state Independent Living (IL) programs. They will evaluate independent living programs by looking at former foster youth’s education, employment, ability to avoid dependency, homelessness rate, rate of non-marital childbirth, high-risk behavior and incarceration. This is important because, before now, no one was required to evaluate IL programs and how effective they were or weren’t. With proper evaluation, hopefully the programs will change. But, again, using this money for evaluating IL makes for less money per teen. In the end, the money will not be a large amount per teen in foster care. A relatively small increase of money to the same IL programs as before will not result in dramatic changes. For this money to be effective, current IL programs need to be improved.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.