America is searching for its soul. Heated debates are taking place across the country over our very identity as a people.
I recently took part in one such dialogue. Along with United Federation of Teachers (UFT) President Sandra Feldman, and Council of Supervisors and Administrators (CSA-the principals’ union) President Donald Singer, I was invited to discuss various issues facing the New York City public school system on a recent segment of the CBS talk show “Sunday Edition.”
We talked about multiculturalism and the campaign to recognize the contributions of different groups to America’s development in the classrooms and history books.
Jim Jensen, a senior CBS News correspondent and the show’s host, was very critical of recent efforts to implement a minority- centered curriculum in classrooms throughout the city and nation. He stressed the need to teach the “three Rs” (reading, writing, and arithmetic) first and foremost.
“For years, many companies in New York have complained that they can not get a good, stable entry-level workforce from the school system,” said Jensen, “that they have youngsters who can not read [or write] a page of English correctly or add a column of numbers.
Emphasizing ‘the Basics’
“…Now, everybody is screaming about changing the educational system, making it more ‘Afro-centered,’ more ‘Indian-centered,’ more ‘women-centered.’ That’s all well and good…It would probably be very important. But isn’t the important thing here reading, writing and arithmetic?”
Jensen insisted that schools’ main purpose is teaching “the basics.” Multiculturalism, he said, is only a distraction from this goal.
At this point, I interjected. I said that the “three Rs” could be taught-and taught well-within the context of learning about other cultures and different peoples’ contributions to the American experience. I cited my background as a Lebanese who came to this country at the age of nine.
“But two and two in Lebanon is still four-same as it is in Brazil,” Jensen interrupted, trying to ridicule the notion that different groups could actually see arithmetic any differently.
“It is,” I agreed. “But, I’d feel much better in math class if someone told me that an Arab invented the zero concept.” This seemed to escape his grasp and he asked me why. “I’d feel that my people contributed to this…[That] my people contributed to what I’m learning,” I explained.
Jensen’s reaction was typical of a person to whom history has always done justice and for whom the textbooks make an awful lot of sense. “All peoples, all races, all over the world made contributions to our whole educational plan from the year one,” he said.
A Shallow Debate
This was the standard “melting pot” response. In effect, Jensen was telling his viewers that the problem could simply be wished away by calling for a common and unified American culture-upheld by an educational system that has rediscovered the “basics.” It was the fitting conclusion for this shallow TV debate, with lots of catchy exchanges but no really meaningful discussion.
One point I would have liked to make, given a little more time, is that as a nine-year-old who had just left his war-torn homeland, I was very confused and insecure. Almost the instant I stepped off the plane at JFK airport I was faced with a critical decision: whether or not to assimilate-bury my past and dive headlong into the melting pot. Assimilating was, by far, the easiest thing to do since I’ve heard next to nothing about Lebanon or any other Arab country during my six years of schooling in New York.
The second, more difficult option was to hold on to my heritage, to remain an Arab in a prejudiced society. I decided to follow the harder course. In so doing, I’ve had to deal with countless stereotypes depicting all Arabs as terrorists and airplane hijackers. I’ve had to cope with classmates and teachers who know nothing about the Middle East, let alone my country, and thus cannot appreciate my perspective.
Worst of all, I’ve had to battle a society in which people like Jim Jensen constantly urge me to forget all about my past and embrace their vision of the future.
Pride In My Arab Origins
I have succeeded because my identity was mainly shaped during those harsh years I spent in Lebanon. Despite the persistent fighting and turmoil of the civil war there (or maybe because of it), I was able to develop as an individual-a person with a strong sense of his history and an unshakable pride in his origins.
But I am an exception. Few immigrants, especially Arabs, can preserve their identity in the American melting pot. Unfortunately, once you let go of your heritage, your past, you no longer have the tools with which to forge any kind of future.
How can you become an “Arab-American” if you have renounced the Arab within you? And what does it mean to be just plain “American” especially if your family comes from Lebanon, Egypt, or Bahrain?
Those who sever their roots in the hope of assimilating or fitting in lose themselves in the process. They become people without a culture and, by extension, without an identity.
Learning that an Arab invented the zero concept (something I learned in a Lebanese schoolroom) re-enforces my identity and, at the same time, includes me in America’s common culture.
Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to get this point across in a TV soundbite. This is an issue that is fundamentally altering the face of American education-and society. What we need is a full-scale debate in the media, in our schools and, perhaps most importantly, within our homes. Six minutes of soundbites on CBS just isn’t enough.
I’m Arab and American Both
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.