I Thought It Was Love (Part I)

When I was 11, my brother and I went to a new foster home. I met Tony the first day I got there.
Tony (not his real name) was our foster mother’s oldest son. He was 23.
He drove a truck, and on that first day, I went with my foster mother to pick him up from work. When we got to his job, he was waiting out front. He was tall and mad cute. Immediately I got a little crush on him.
Our new foster home was fun for a while. There were times that my new foster mother would be so sweet and tell me, “I love you. You are the daughter I always wanted.”
An Unhappy Home
But then she began to have mood swings and there were days that she would say, “What the hell? You can’t do anything right. You are good for nothing.” That would really hurt.
She also gave us lots of chores. I had to clean the kitchen and the living room. I also had to take care of a younger foster child that she also had. I had to bathe her and wash her clothes. I was too scared to say anything because I didn’t want to get hit.
My Foster Brother Made Me Blush
Unlike his mother, Tony was always nice to me. I really had a big crush on Tony. Every time I would see him I would start blushing. I liked when he would come home from work and put on his stereo in the living room and blast it. He would play rap and r&b. He would start to sing and I would laugh because he couldn’t sing but he sounded so cute.
He and my brother were also mad cool. They liked to have jokes on me. They would say, “Damn, you have a big head.” They would laugh and I would laugh with them.
The Touching Began
Then one Friday, about a year and a half after I had been in that home, my foster mother went to her friend’s house for a visit. My brother and I were both in Tony’s room playing video games. I was lying next to Tony.
Then I felt someone’s foot rubbing on mine, and when I looked, it was Tony’s foot. I had a tingling feeling and a big smile. I did not really think anything was wrong with that because I liked Tony a lot.
After a while, my brother left to go to bed and it was only Tony and I. I was so nervous. I was never nervous before, but this time I didn’t know what to do. I was only 12 and Tony was 24.
‘Our Little Secret’
Then Tony turned off his light and laid under his sheets and told me to rub his back with lotion. I did. That’s when he started touching me. He started rubbing on my chest and then started to go further down. I was feeling uncomfortable. I did not know what to do. I was scared. But I liked him so much.
Before I left the room he told me, “Keep this between you and me. This is our little secret.”
Even though I was scared that first night, after a while, I liked and enjoyed that Tony was touching me. Tony never actually had intercourse with me, but him touching me made me feel close to him. I thought that he loved me. Every time he would go out to hang out with his friends and then come back home, he would come to my room and I would feel him touching me. I thought that this was what it took for a guy to love a girl-for her to give it up.
He Could Be Sweet, But…
Sometimes he would come home with a girl and I would get really mad. But I would look at her and say silently, “So what? You’re just another girl who he is going to have sex with and leave.” I thought that he loved me.
This kept on for about two and a half years.
Tony was sweet when he was in the mood to be sweet. When he was in a good mood, we would laugh and make fun of each other and start to play fight. He’d tell me that I was pretty, but not prettier than him, and we’d go back and forth about who looked better.
When we were alone, he also made me feel good. He would caress my body and tell me that my skin was nice and soft and that I smelled good. He made me feel like he loved me when he would say those things.
But other times he would find things that I did wrong and start yelling at me. He was the man of the house, and if my foster mother did not like the way I washed the dishes, or if I was fooling around when I was supposed to be cleaning the kitchen, she’d tell him and he would yell at me.
He’d say, “Damn, you’re so slow,” almost every day. Then at night he would come to my room and say, “You know, I was just playing with you.”
I used to think he was probably yelling at me so my foster mother would not suspect anything was going on between us. But then there were days that he would yell at me when she was not around. I felt confused when he would apologize.
One day Tony came from work and asked me, “Why didn’t you fold my socks?”
I told him I hadn’t had time. Then he pushed me into the TV. A cord was hanging out and my leg went straight into it. I got a big open cut and was bleeding.
The Hitting Began
After, I went to my room and I was crying so much. I felt like this had become an abusive relationship. But Tony was the first person besides my brother who I thought ever loved me. I was looking for someone to love me so badly that I did not want to let go. No one could have told me that he did not love me. I did not want to hear it. I just wanted to hear the way I felt.
That was the first time he hit me, but unfortunately, it was not the last time. Whenever he felt that I was not listening to him, he would hit me. And since he knew that I was not going to tell anyone, he started doing it harder.
I think he knew that he could hit me and call me names because I loved him and I would always forgive him. He knew he could do anything he wanted and I would not say anything.
Who Could I Tell?
Besides, who would I have told? I could not tell my foster mother because he was her favorite son and she would say that I was lying. I couldn’t tell my brother because he was really close with Tony and I didn’t know how he would take it. I definitely did not want to tell my social worker because it would come back to my foster mother and my foster mother would tell Tony and I would get into so much trouble.
One day, a few months later, I cut school and went to Chinatown in Manhattan. I almost never cut school, but I really wanted to go out and have fun.
When I got home that evening, I went to my room. The phone rang and Tony picked it up. Then Tony called me.
“Come here,” he said. I was so scared. When I know that I am going to get hurt, the tears just come down and I already feel the pain that is coming to me.
I went into his room and he asked me, “Did you go to school today?”
“Yes,” I said.
“So why is your teacher on the phone asking me why you were not in school today?”
I Said No, But He Didn’t Listen
I just stood there looking at him. Then he put me on the phone with my teacher. My teacher asked me, “What did you do in shop class today?” It was a trick question, because the shop teacher had been absent that day, so of course I got the answer wrong.
After that I confessed that I did not go to school. Then I hung up the phone and Tony took a book and hit me on the head. Then he kicked me. He told me, “Wait until Mommy comes back from the store.”
When my foster mother came back I was in my bed. Tony yelled, “Mom, come upstairs.” When she came I started to cry even more. When he told her what I had done, she took a wire hanger and hit me with it and gave me a big cut on my arm.
She started cursing me out in Spanish and English. She told me, “You are a piece of sh-t and you are not worth nothing. You are going to grow up and be nothing.” Every time she said something, she would hit me with the hanger. But the hitting was not really hurting me as much as the words were.
When she was done, Tony walked by and said, “Good for you.” When he said that, I really felt for the first time that he did not care.
That night, my foster mother went to her friend’s upstate and left me and my brother with Tony. I did my chores and went to my room. Then Tony came to my room and started playing around with me. I told him to leave me alone. That was the first time I ever told him that. But he did not want to.
I turned over to the wall by my bed so he would leave me alone. He shut my light and closed the door. I thought he had left, but when I turned back around, he was sitting on my bed. Then he started touching me on my chest, then went down to my private spot.
Tired of Taking It
I got so sick of it I just lay there and did not care anymore. I felt so disgusted and dirty. I felt invaded. I felt like I was trash. I just wanted him to finish and get away from me.
After he finished, I went to take a shower and got into bed. I was thinking about running away while I fell asleep. I still loved him, but I was so tired of him hitting me and then telling me that he was sorry.
The weekend went by and Monday morning came. Tony left early, around 6 a.m., to go to work. I got up, took a shower, dressed the little girl, gave her something to eat, and told my brother that I was leaving.
I had decided I couldn’t take it anymore. I was tired. I loved my brother and I loved Tony. But when I got sick of it, I really got sick.
I Left
My brother asked me where I was going. I told him, “Somewhere out of here.” I just told him that I was tired of getting hit. He didn’t know about the everything else with me and Tony, and I did not tell him.
He said, “Go ahead. I’m staying.”
Part of me did not want to leave because I really still did love Tony. And I did not want to leave my brother. Besides Tony, my brother, was the only person I ever loved and who loved me. But I hoped I could find someplace better. So I took my bag and I left.
I called my agency from the street and told them that I ran away from my foster home. When they came to pick me up, I explained about the physical abuse-although I didn’t tell them anything about the sexual relationship that I had been having with Tony. After that they placed me in a home where I was loved. My new foster mother never hit me. Whenever I would do something wrong, she would sit down and talk to me. She made me feel comfortable. She would hold me in her arms and tell me that she loved me.
I Confessed
Still, I missed my brother so much. We hardly got to see each other at all. And even though I was angry at Tony for all the times he hit me, I missed him, too. I missed when he would blast his music and when we would play fight and when he would hold me. Despite the pain that I went through with him, I still loved him.
Then, a few months after I moved into my new home, I started catching pains on my right side. My foster mother took me to the emergency room and they ran tests on me. The next evening, my foster mother came home from work and gave me a hug. Then she told me that the doctor said I had a sexually transmitted disease.
Actually, they were false results, which I found out later, when they ran even more tests on me. But at the time, I didn’t know much about STDs, and I thought Tony had given it to me. I was really scared and angry, so I told my foster mom all about Tony.
While I was explaining, I started to cry. She told me that Tony took advantage of me. But I was in love with Tony, and I had wanted to be with him. I told her that I let him do it and that I had wanted it. Then she asked me, “How old were you and how old was he? You’re young. He’s a grown man. He sexually molested you.”
But I did not want to hear it. I was mad. All I kept saying was that I let him do it to me and I wanted it, so he did not sexually molest me.
Police at My Door
But when we stopped talking, I couldn’t make the thoughts go away. I had it on my mind all night. I was confused and I needed to talk to someone. So that week I told my therapist what Tony had been doing to me. I revealed my biggest secret to her. She called the police.
I did not know that she was going to tell the police. I thought that she was going to talk to me and ask me what I wanted to do. But instead, she rushed ahead with everything without me.
She didn’t tell me after she had called, either. I didn’t know she had called the police until that evening, when a detective called my house and said that he needed to talk to me. I was so scared and mad at myself because I still loved Tony. Everything happened so fast. Then he told me I would have to tell the prosecutor what had happened.
The next day, two detectives came to pick me up at home and take me to the district attorney’s office. When I arrived, I was mad scared. There were police all around and the office building was big.
Pressure From All Sides
I saw a lot of lawyers. Everybody was suited up, both women and men. I was hoping that I got a woman and thank God I did, because I would not feel comfortable talking to a male lawyer. My lawyer asked me questions like, “What did Tony do to you?” “Did he force himself on you?” “Where did he touch you?”
I started crying and did not know how to answer her. So many people were telling me, “He did wrong. He did wrong.” There was so much pressure and I was so tired of everybody telling me the same thing over and over again.
Part of me would say, “Nah, I let him and I wanted him to do it.” Besides, I still loved him. And I knew that Tony was across the street in the bull pens (jail). I wanted to see him and talk to him because I felt so bad.
But another part of me would think, “Damn, yo, maybe they are right.” And I was mad because I thought he had given me an STD. When I thought about that, part of me did want to tell on him.
Why Did I Tell?
My lawyer let me go outside with the detective so I could get something to drink and calm down. When I came back, she did not force me to say what I did not feel comfortable saying. I just had to shake my head yes or no if I did not want to answer the question verbally. No one asked me if I wanted to press charges. They just told me that I needed to tell them what had happened.
After they pressed charges on him, I felt so guilty. I felt that I had messed up Tony’s life for no reason. I thought he was going to be sent to Riker’s Island and be in jail for several months, if not longer. In the end, all that happened to him was that they sent him to a program for sexual molesters. But at the time, all I could think was, “Why did I have to tell?”
Afterward, a friend of mine asked me, “If you feel so guilty for telling, why did you tell?” It’s a good question that I’ve tried to answer for myself. But really, I had no answer for that when she asked me, and until this day I still have no answer for sure, except maybe that I felt so much pressure, and that I was so confused about how I felt myself.
Everything Happened So Fast
It’s been almost four years since I went to the lawyer. I didn’t have to go to court because Tony admitted what he had done as part of a plea bargain, so he never got a real sentence. And I haven’t seen Tony since.
Until just recently, I also lost all contact with my brother, because he was upset with me for pressing charges. We’re reunited now, but that’s a whole different story in my life. If I could have seen the future, that alone would have kept me from ever telling anyone what had happened.
Still, now that I’m older, part of me thinks it’s right that they pressed charges on Tony. Part of me knows that I was a child and what he did was wrong. But even so, I still feel it was handled the wrong way. Everything happened so fast.
The way things happened with my social worker and with the courts made me feel like I can trust no one. Now it’s hard for me to tell anyone anything because I feel that they are going to tell someone else right behind my back. It wasn’t only Tony who hurt me. The way they handled my case hurt me, too.
If I was an adult and a girl came and told me a similar story, I would talk to her and listen to her and comfort her. I would ask her if she wanted to report him. If I was a social worker or teacher and required by law to report what she told me, then I would tell her that I was required to tell before she confided in me. And I would tell her what she should expect so it did not come as a surprise.
Still Confused
I would ask her if there was anything she wanted to do, and I would be there to comfort her through the whole process. There was at least one person who was there for me like that-my foster mother-and she made a big difference in my life. I wish other adults had been more like her.
It’s been four years since I’ve had anything to do with Tony, but he is still on my mind. When I really think about it, I think that my foster mother was right. I feel stupid that Tony did not love me the way that I loved him. I feel used, cheap and dirty. I was just a little girl. I had nothing. I was not even developed. I did not even know what my period was yet. But at the time, I was blind.
Tony made me feel that all guys are just like him-dogs. Now I don’t trust guys and I refuse to date just one guy at a time. I do not want to get my feelings broken again. Sometimes I feel that Tony took everything from me.
But even though I have all this anger for Tony, till this day there’s a part of me that still loves him. Sure, I pressed charges. But all the court cases in the world can’t change the confusion I still feel. I was so young when it happened and when it ended, and it was so big and lasted so many years, that I think my love for Tony will never really leave.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.