I Hated My Mother

Before the divorce, my father and I didn’t have what you would call the ideal father-daughter relationship. But I knew he loved me even though he didn’t show it, and I loved him too.
Usual Mother-Daughter Fights
Back then, my mother and I got along okay. We were having the usual mother-daughter fights but they were about little things like picking up after myself and washing the dishes. But the arguments became pretty serious when I tried to do things my way and ignored or challenged what she tried to tell me.
During the divorce, my hair started falling out because of the amount of pressure I was under both at school and at home. My father was still living at home, so between my parents’ screaming and yelling and their periodic bouts of angry silence, I felt like I was on the verge of a mental breakdown. My grades slipped dramatically. My teachers didn’t know why and I didn’t explain it. At the time, I really didn’t care.
My father left after the divorce was final. He moved into his own apartment in Brooklyn. Since I didn’t see him that much anymore, I thought my relationship with my mother would improve. But it only got worse.
We Felt Smothered
My mother centered her whole life around my brother and me. (My brother was nine years old, two years younger than me.) I resented this because I felt she was trying to live her life through us. My mother immediately started to assume that we would be like her when she was growing up in Panama. (Both my mother and father were from Panama.) In fact, whenever my brother or I got into trouble, she would say, “Back in Panama, when I was a kid…” And the lecture would begin.
My mother smothered us with her over-protective love. We had to first get permission from her if we wanted to go anywhere. And when we did go out, we had to give her a number where we could be reached. She wouldn’t even allow us to go to the corner store which was only a block and a half away from our house in Queens Village, even though our neighborhood is fairly safe. We couldn’t go anywhere after school. And when we visited our friends, she would drive us to their house and then pick us back up.
The way my brother reacted to these restrictions was with an I-don’t-care-attitude. So I had to be the go-between for my brother and my mother because he wouldn’t listen to anything she said. I was left to be the “semi-adult” in the house. This role put a lot of pressure on me.
It’s not like my mother treated me differently than my brother, she treated us equally. (To her credit, she never played favorites with us.) But my brother and I reacted differently to her overprotective treatment.
‘You Don’t Need Friends’
My way of dealing with my mother was to rebel against everything she tried to tell me. For example, I have many friends and my mother doesn’t trust friends. She feels that all friends do is ruin your life. She always said me “You don’t need friends…what can friends do for you except hurt you…look at your father-look at what friends have done for him.” Since my father wasn’t successful, my mother immediately put the blame on his friends. (On the other hand, she is a successful computer specialist.)
Since my father left, I felt I needed someone to care for, so I decided to get a dog. My mother protested a little but then finally agreed. I named him Sebastian and I really loved him a lot. He taught me not to give up on something you love.
I had Sebastian for about six months before my mom decided to get rid of him. Her reason was he made too much of a mess. I admit, Sebastian wasn’t totally housebroken, but I felt there was another reason why she got rid of him. I guess it was a little extreme when I yelled at her, “You always get rid of the things I love most!” This remark really upset her. Whenever we got into an argument, she would always throw it in my face.
We Couldn’t Communicate
My mother and I still couldn’t communicate in a calm and rational manner. Even if we tried to sit down and talk things out, we would always end up either in shouting matches or with her putting me down. Sometimes I’d start to cry and leave her presence at once.
The problem was that my mother wanted to take control of my life and I wouldn’t allow her to do it. We were in constant competition for control and I guess that was why we always argued. It has been almost six years since the divorce but I think the older my brother and I got, the tighter the hold she wanted to have on us.
This past summer was a time of rebellion for both my brother and me. He started staying out late with his girlfriend and hanging out with gangs during and after summer school. (My brother is now 15 years old.)
The Wheels of Rebellion
I had my little rebellion too-I made a duplicate of my mother’s car keys and used to take her car for a spin while she was at work. Although I didn’t have a license, I had a permit.
I used to drive to summer school in the morning, then in the afternoon I’d drive all over the place. Everything was okay as long as I replaced the gas that I used and took the car back home by five o’clock.
This went on for about a month before my mother caught on. She approached my brother and me and asked us if we had been using her car. We didn’t even bother denying it.
We were grounded for three months. All of our privileges were taken away. We couldn’t make or receive phone calls, have friends over, or go to anyone’s house. And forget about parties, movies, or money to buy anything.
I don’t regret taking the car at all. I did it partly to prove to my mother and myself that I was capable of this “grown-up” responsibility. At least I have one good story to tell my kids, if I have any.
Before she took us off punishment, my brother left home and went to live with our grandmother (my mother’s mother). It took my brother’s absence for my mother to realize that she should start to lighten up and treat us as young adults.
After a week, my brother came back home and things did change-for the better. Now the problems between my mother and I have been somewhat resolved. Every now and then we still have arguments, but they are not as serious as before.
My mother finally understands that at 17, I am almost a grown woman and I need my own space. She’s beginning to let go and allow me to make my own decisions.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.