“Howard Beach: Making the Case for Murder” Doesn’t Make Its Case

NYC Rating: *
Some events that have shocked the nation are better left in the past. TV docudramas, on the other hand, continue to remind us of them.
Most of the time they distort the facts, bringing back bad memories and horrible feelings, while also disrespecting the families involved in the events.
On Monday, December 4, NBC aired “Howard Beach: Making the Case for Murder.” It was appalling to see how inaccurate this docudrama was.
First of all, the movie focused on Charles Hynes (poorly played by Daniel Travanti), the special prosecutor in the murder trial. Hynes was portrayed as the hero.
The Real Heroes
New York Newsday columnist Sheryl McCarthy, in a recent column entitled, “TV Films Color Heroes White,” made this point: “The real heroes [of the Howard Beach incident] were C. Vernon Mason and Alton Maddox, the feisty lawyers who led the marches protesting the Howard Beach killings. They forced the issue of White-on-Black violence into the public eye. By withholding the cooperation of key witnesses, they forced the appointment of a special prosecutor. They were criticized by Blacks as well as Whites, but they were right.”
In this movie, the facts about the Howard Beach incident, which occurred in December 1986, were distorted by hearsay and fiction. For example, Maddox and Mason were merged into the character of one Black lawyer; in other words, this character was a composite of two real people. Also, the role that the fictional lawyer played in the outcome of the trial was portrayed as minor.
Both Timothy Grimes and Cedric Sandiford, the two Blacks who survived the attack, were cast as criminals. Grimes’ criminal record was stressed and his character was discredited. The movie made it seem as if the Black men got what they deserved when their car broke down in Howard Beach.
Embarrassing Speeches
At the end of the murder trial, the two young White defendants who were convicted made speeches before the judge, saying that they were so sorry. It was embarrassing-by their tone of voice, you’d think they were apologizing for wrecking the family car. It seemed that they were just sucking up to the judge in order to receive lighter sentences.
In fact, based on this movie, you’d think the White defendants were innocent kids who made a tiny mistake, and the Black victims were the guilty ones.
After the movie, reactions from the defendants’ families and the “real” special prosecutor, Charles Hynes, were shown on the news. The families were outraged at the docudrama. They said it brought back hateful memories and was full of lies. Of course, the real Charles Hynes felt that the docudrama portrayed him beautifully.
The family of Michael Griffith, who was killed in the attack, refused to be interviewed.
TV networks usually give people what they want to see so that they can get high ratings. This dramatization of the tragic death of Michael Griffith and its consequences did not respect the viewers or the facts.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.