Hounded by a Stalker: He Won’t Leave Me Alone (Part I)

One day last winter, my sister and I were alone in the house when there was a knock at the door. I looked through the peephole but I didn’t see anyone. When I opened the door it was one of my neighbors, a dark-skinned man in his late 20s with a moustache and a few gray hairs. He looked as if he had just woken up. I had met him that Christmas when he came to my house with his family. After that he came by again just to say hello. I didn’t pay much attention.
This time I asked him what he wanted. “I want to go out with you,” he said. “I like you a lot. You are really beautiful, you know that?”
I told him that I had a boyfriend. “Doesn’t matter,” he said. “I’m not jealous.” The way he said that, I felt like he wanted something else. He looked me over from head to toe. I could see in his eyes that his intentions weren’t honorable. “Bye,” I said. “Bye.” And I tried to close the door but he put out his right hand and held it open. I got really scared then. I said goodbye again and pushed the door closed.
He Wouldn’t Take the Hint
About a month later there he was again. Again I told him that I couldn’t go out with him but he insisted. I told him I had a lot of homework to do and he offered to help me. I said my boyfriend was already on his way over to help me. (I wasn’t really expecting anybody, I just wanted to get rid of him.) Well, my lie worked and he went away.
I told my father about this man and everything he said. My father advised me not to open the door at all. He said if the man came back again, he would tell him to stop bothering me.
Two weeks later, he was back. This time he was all dressed up. I wasn’t home, I was at school. My father opened the door and asked him what he wanted and the man asked for me. My father told him I wasn’t home and would he please go away and stop bothering us. He explained that I wasn’t interested in him; that I had a boyfriend and even if I wanted to go out with him my father would never permit it.
“Why not?” he asked. “What has this boyfriend got that I haven’t got?”
Right then I got home from school. The man-let’s call him Mr. W-told me what my father had said and asked me if it was true that he was bothering me. I said it was. He asked me what it was about him that I didn’t like. I just told him that he already knew I had a boyfriend and that I loved him very much. Then he asked if we could be friends, if I could teach him English. I told him I didn’t know enough English to teach anyone else nor did I have time for that-that was what school was for. He said he knew that, but that he wanted to learn from me, no one else.
Friends?!
I told him again that I couldn’t do it but he wouldn’t listen. He said he would wait for me in the literature section of the local library. After that I stopped going to the library.
That was in March. After that, he left me alone for awhile. Then, in June, I was in a sporting goods store near my house when Mr. W appeared out of nowhere. He started yelling, “Don’t you ever touch me! I warn you not to touch me again.” I was frightened. I didn’t know what he was talking about. He looked so angry I thought he was going to hit me or something.
I didn’t say anything. I just walked very fast toward the basement where my boyfriend was waiting. When I got there my boyfriend asked me why I was so pale. I told him to look over by the stairs and I told him what happened. He bought a baseball bat-just in case.
Mr. W kept staring at us from the stairs, then suddenly he disappeared. I was relieved. My boyfriend and I went to the first floor to look at some shorts we had seen on the way in. As we were picking out the ones we wanted, we saw Mr. W again. He was watching us from behind a rack of clothing, like a detective. My boyfriend told me not to look at him but I couldn’t help it. I thought that at any moment he could come from behind and stab us in the back or do something crazy.
He Grabbed My Wrist
Then he came over to us and said to me, “We have to talk!”
“I don’t want to,” I answered him. My boyfriend pushed me aside and I felt like I was going to faint. “She doesn’t want to talk to you,” he said. “And if she doesn’t want to, no one can make her, least of all you”
“I want to talk to her, not with you,” the man said defiantly. “And who are you anyway?”
“I’m her boyfriend,” he replied. “Look, if she doesn’t want to talk, why don’t you just leave her alone?”
“I don’t care who you are or what you say,” Mr. W said, grabbing me by my wrist and pulling me toward him. My boyfriend got hold of my other hand and was pulling too. With his help, I managed to get loose and go to him. Mr. W tried to grab me again but my boyfriend pushed him away.
I wasn’t sure what he was going to do, but my first thought was that he was going to pull out a gun. (He almost always kept his hands in his pockets.)
Even though I hadn’t done anything to make this guy behave like this, somehow I felt it was all my fault. He was about to shove my boyfriend back when, lucky for us, two security guards appeared. They held him because at that moment he seemed to be the one who was causing trouble.
You Haven’t Heard the End of This
“What’s going on here?” one of them asked. Mr. W doesn’t speak English but my boyfriend does. He explained to the guards that Mr. W came to bother us while we were trying to buy something. A couple of people who saw what happened confirmed this and the guards took Mr. W out of the store. “You haven’t heard the end of this,” he shouted. “You’ll see.”
Even though I was protected by the guards and by my boyfriend I couldn’t stop shaking. I still felt vulnerable and afraid. I never imagined that he would come after the people close to me too.
My boyfriend and I paid for the shorts but when we were leaving one of the people who worked there told us Mr. W was waiting for us outside. We called the police and while we were waiting we could see him pacing back and forth between the store and the corner.
After 40 minutes the police still hadn’t shown up and we decided to leave-without letting Mr. W see us, of course. When he was walking toward the corner, the two of us left the store and went quickly in the opposite direction. We ducked around the corner and headed for my house.
We were both a little shaken up. My boyfriend admitted that Mr. W had scared him because he acted like someone who had nothing to lose. “Negrita, tell me the truth,” he asked me. “Did you ever have something going with that guy? He acts like the two of you have a history.”
I told him it surprised me that he would doubt my word and he said it was just that Mr. W treated me with such familiarity.
“And what do you expect from a madman like that?” I asked him. “That’s probably just what he wants, for you to doubt me. That way maybe you’ll leave the field open so he can bother me easier.”
When we were coming to my house my boyfriend suggested we go straight to the police station and report what happened.
When we were coming to my house my boyfriend suggested we go straight to the police station and report what happened. But my little sister was alone in the house and didn’t know what was going on. We decided to go get her.
When we got there, I called the police immediately. A little later, the buzzer started ringing and ringing. My boyfriend had already left and my sister and I were all alone. I was scared. I went to the intercom and asked who it was (I already had my suspicions). “Is your mother there?” asked Mr. W’s voice.
“She’s not home,” I yelled. “And besides, you don’t have anything to talk to her about. Go away! You’ve got no business around here. The police are already on their way.”
“I don’t need to talk to you,” he said. “I want to talk to your mother.”
“I told you she’s not here. Go away and quit bothering me!”
Enter the Police
Finally, he left. Our neighbor came by to see how we were and we told her the whole story. “You can’t stay here all alone,” she said. “Come over to my house.” I was relieved. Even though we didn’t know her that well, she really supported us. We told her we’d come later on.
Right then the police showed up and I explained everything. They asked for Mr. W’s address. I didn’t know it exactly but I knew where he lived so I took them down to the street and pointed it out to them.
My parents were in Colombia during all this and I was afraid to spend the night at home. I tried to find another place to sleep but couldn’t. I called the lady that was taking care of us and she came over and slept at our place.
From then until the time my parents got home, my boyfriend picked us up every morning and took us to school. My little sister has to walk six big blocks to get there. Mr W’s cousin goes to the same school and sometimes he takes her. I have to take the subway and he could follow me.
Filing a Complaint
I didn’t see Mr. W for a while, but when my father got back we went to the local precinct to report him anyway. From there they sent us to the Court Dispute Referral Center (CDRC). They made me fill out a form with my name and address, the name and address of the accused, and the details of what had happened. I summed up everything that he did, making sure not to leave out the most serious part, which was when he grabbed me in the store.
While I was waiting my turn, I had doubts about what I was doing there. What if he bothered me more because I had gone to the police? I thought. On the other hand, this way I’d have a record and it wouldn’t just be my word against his. If he kept it up, maybe this would make it easier to have him arrested.
When they finally called my name, my mom and I went to a private office and the man started reading my form. “Do you know this guy?” he asked as he read.
“No.” I said. “I just know he’s my neighbor.”
“You’ve never had a romantic thing with him or even a friendship?” he insisted.
“No sir, nothing like that. Like I told you, I only know he’s my neighbor, nothing more.” I repeated, but he seemed like he didn’t believe me.
A Peaceful Solution?
Then he asked me what I wanted to do about the problem. I told him as far as I was concerned they could throw the guy in jail. He said that because there hadn’t been any physical aggression, he couldn’t even get me a court order to keep Mr. W away from me-let alone lock him up. Instead, he sent me to mediation, a system for people to resolve their differences peacefully.
He gave me an appointment to meet with Mr. W and a “mediator.” After that I had to go to Mr. W’s house and personally deliver a notice. The next day I went to the police station to get a cop to go to his house with me. Mr. W wasn’t home, his brother told me to leave it with him and he’d see that he got it.
I went to the appointment with my father and when we got there, Mr. W was already waiting. The whole time we were waiting for them to call our names, the guy never took his eyes off us. Then a man came out and said, “Sandra Vargas, A— W–, please come in.”
The mediator showed us where to sit: my father and I on one side of the table, Mr. W on the other. He sat in the middle. To begin with, we all had to sign a contract that said that we were there of our own free will and were willing to try to settle things in good faith.
Angry Words
I noticed something strange-Mr. W read the English side of the contract even though I’m pretty sure he doesn’t speak English. Well, that’s his problem. Anyway, we all signed and then the mediator let me go first since I was the one who made the complaint.
I started by saying that I didn’t like him and I didn’t want him bothering me anymore. That he took liberties with me he had no right to, like asking me to talk to him when I didn’t want to and even trying to force me by going to my house and following me around in public.
Then it was his turn. “I didn’t mean to bother you,” he said. “I like you a lot. I want you to go out with me.”
“I’ve got a boyfriend I love a lot and I’d never trade him for you-not if you were the last man on earth,” I told him.
He started telling us how he desired me sexually, how he dreamed about me and, in his dreams, I was touching him and wouldn’t let him sleep. In the dreams I was the one who was after him, he said. Whenever he saw me, he said he had to masturbate and was sure he wasn’t the only guy who felt that way about me because I was so beautiful.
That got my father really mad and he started to take a swing at him…
That got my father really mad and he was about to take a swing at him but the mediator told him to please calm down.
“Isn’t she really pretty, though?” Mr. W asked the mediator.
“Señor, we’re not here to talk about that. We’re here to discuss the two of you,” he said. “Sure she’s pretty but that doesn’t mean that anybody who happens to like her can just grab her. She’s not a thing and if she doesn’t like you, you’ve got to respect that. Nobody has the right to force a person to be with someone they don’t like.”
But Mr. W went on and on about how I was making him crazy, ill. He talked about strange stuff like “the occult,” and “spirits.”
“You know what your problem is? You’re crazy,” I told him. “What you need is a good psychiatrist to help you get rid of this obsession you have with me. I’ve never given you any cause even to think I’d be interested.”
But he wouldn’t give up. Finally my father decided to end the meeting and take the guy to court. The mediator gave us the name of someone there who could help us but my father has two jobs and didn’t have time to go that week or the week after.
The End of the Ordeal
Meanwhile, we didn’t hear anything more from Mr. W. We figured he got scared off and it was all over. But after a couple of months he was back in my life again.
One night last September, I ran into him on the street and he followed me home. When I told my parents they just said, “As long as he doesn’t say anything to you, he can walk wherever he wants.” That made sense, even though now I was more afraid of him than ever after what he had said during the mediation session about having to masturbate whenever he saw me.
About two weeks after that, the editors of NYC gave us an assignment that involved giving another teen reporter a tour of our neighborhoods. After taking her all over, I decided to show Donna the public library.
“I really hope I don’t run into anybody I don’t want to see,” I told her before we went in. We went inside and, I don’t know why, but we walked all the way to the back. Sure enough, there he was, staring at me.
“I knew you’d come,” he said.
I felt weak, like I was about to faint. I grabbed my friend and the two of us got out of there fast. I remember asking her if he was following us and she said he was. I could tell she was dying of fright even though she didn’t understand what was going on. I tried to explain while we walked but I was too nervous and my English failed me.
Nowhere To Turn
When we got outside I crossed the street because I didn’t know which way to turn. I completely forgot about Donna. There’s a bus station there, but there weren’t any
busses. I stopped to think of where to go next and Mr. W came up behind me and grabbed my arm.
“I need for us to talk,” he said. “I want us to talk.”
I didn’t answer at all. I went a few steps to see if anyone could help me but there wasn’t anybody around. He repeated what he had said and grabbed my arm more roughly.
“I don’t know you,” I shouted in English so Donna, who was standing nearby, would know what was going on.
He got right in my face and said, “Yes, you do. You know me.”
I was praying to God to send me some help, but nothing happened. Then I saw a police van at the corner. I didn’t even look to see if any cars were coming, I just darted across the street towards my salvation. When I got to the van I started crying and told the policewoman that this man was bothering me.
He had come after me and was asking to talk to me, right in front of the policewoman. One of the cops pulled him aside, I’m not sure what for. The other asked me if I was alone and that’s when I remembered my friend. I looked around to see where she was and she was standing about half a block away. I called to her and the policewoman told me to go home. We ran all the way.
Don’t Open the Door!
After we got there, the buzzer rang. I told my mother not to open the door. She went downstairs to get my father and he went down right away to see what Mr. W wanted. By the time he got down to the street, Mr. W was already approaching his house, which is four or five houses up the street from ours. My dad followed him and punched him in the face.
I didn’t see what happened next, but my father tells me Mr. W followed him back to our building. Then I heard my father tell him that he’d warned him many times already to leave me alone. I heard them shouting and when I looked out the window, my father was hitting him with a stick.
Mr. W went to get a rock. I went and grabbed a knife and opened the apartment door, ready to go downstairs and confront him.
I heard my father tell him that he’d warned him many times already to leave me alone. I heard them shouting and when I looked out the window, my father was hitting him with a stick.
Mr. W went to get a rock and that’s when I grabbed a knife and opened the apartment door, ready to go downstairs and confront him. I felt it was high time somebody put an end to this. For one thing, my mother was pregnant at the time and now she was downstairs with this crazy person. I was afraid something would happen to her or to my father. I felt like this was all my fault and even thought that maybe I should have gone out with him so he’d leave everyone alone.
But my friend wouldn’t let me go downstairs. “Give me the knife,” she said really slowly. “Hand me the knife.”
And I did.
I don’t think I would have been able to actually kill anyone. My mother had broken up the fight, but we all had a good scare.
By this point it was clear that Mr. W. wasn’t just going to magically disappear and I decided to go back to the authorities yet another time.
Getting the Runaround
Later that day my boyfriend and I went back to the courthouse to find out what we could do. They sent us to Victim Services Agency (VSA), where they told me that first I had to go to the police and file a complaint.
The next day I went with my editor from New Youth Connections to the precinct to make another report but it seemed like no one was interested in even taking the complaint.
Then my editor broke in and said we were from a magazine. They called the lieutenant, who invited us into his office. He listened but said there was little he could do.
The next day I went to the courthouse again and tried to get a court order to keep him from coming near me or even calling. I talked to five or six different people and spent the whole day going from place to place. Finally, I got to see the judge and he gave me an “order of protection” for two weeks while they were processing my request for one that was longer term.
It was a little tough for me to get the order because Mr. W hadn’t physically harmed me and I hadn’t kept a careful record of the different incidents with the dates, names of officials I had spoken to, etc…But as they say, the squeaky wheel gets the grease.
I went with two police officers to serve Mr. W with a paper ordering him to appear in court. “Why are you doing this to me?” he asked. “Why?”
No More Games
“Because I’ve had it with you,” I told him. “No more playing games.”
Two weeks later we both had to appear in court and they extended the order of protection for six more months, during which time, if he bothered me, all I’d have to do was call the police and they could arrest him right away.
For several months I only saw him a couple of times from a distance. I felt safe.
Then, on March 9, I was walking to a shopping center near my house with three of my friends when Mr. W passed by us. “Hi, you dirty b-tch,” he said staring right at me. Then he walked on. The next thing I knew one of my friends screamed, “Sandra, look out he’s behind you!” I didn’t even have time to turn my head because he grabbed my hair and showed me a razor. “Next time I see you, you’ll wish you were never born, b-tch,” he said. He let go of my hair and went off.
The people who saw it didn’t do anything, they didn’t even ask me if I was OK. I started crying and went with my poor, terrified friends to the local precinct.
Justice At Last?
When we got there I asked for Lt. Byrne who I’d seen before. He assigned two officers to go with me to find Mr. W and arrest him. He had just violated the order of protection.
When we got to his house, his brother said Mr. W didn’t live there and he didn’t know where he did live. He said he was sorry about what happened to me, that his brother was crazy, mentally ill.
The next day I went with the same policemen to look for him at the library. We found him sleeping in the back. The officer woke him up and asked him if he’d attacked me. Right away he said he had. The cops told him he could be locked up for two or three months for that. “You’re gonna pay dearly for those two or three months,” he mumbled to me in Spanish.
I told the officer what he just said and he told him to shut up. They put handcuffs on him and told him he had the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney. We left the library. Lt. Byrne was waiting outside to take me back to the station, where I filed a complaint.
Mr. W was in jail overnight and all of the next day and had to pay $500 bail. Right now I’m waiting for the day of the hearing. I don’t know what’s going to happen but they’ve told me he could be sentenced to as little as 20 days or as much as an entire year in prison. We’ll soon see.
Editors Note: This is the end of a long and unfortunate story-we hope.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.