Hollywood Movies: Where Are the Latinos At?

I loved the novel The House of the Spirits by Chilean author Isabel Allende. When I heard that the movie version was coming to a theater near me, I jumped for joy. I was a little worried that the movie wouldn’t be as good as the book, but I pushed those thoughts to the back of my mind. Then I saw Jeremy Irons and Meryl Streep on the movie poster and I really started having second thoughts about the whole thing.
I was right to worry. The movie reeked so badly that I almost wanted to yell, “Fire,” so that everyone could rush out of the theater and save themselves from further disappointment.
What made it so vile were the actors. They couldn’t make me believe that they were Chileans. They were White. They didn’t even use Spanish accents. What were they thinking?
You see, the movie, like the book, is set in Chile. It’s the story of a woman named Clara, whose supernatural powers and good heart capture the love of her husband Esteban, a loving but power-hungry man, and that of his loyal and submissive sister Ferula.
The story follows the family into the next generation to show Blanca, the daughter of Clara and Esteban, all grown up and totally in love with Pedro, a peasant who works on her father’s plantation. It’s about romance, but also about politics and history.
Say It In Spanish
By the end of the movie, I heard people in the audience saying, “I didn’t know Americans lived in Chile during the roaring ’20s” Of course, I understand how they could make a mistake like that. The characters were so American sounding that Winona Ryder, who plays Blanca, should’ve said “Surf’s up” as one of her opening lines.
What I can’t understand is why the movie wasn’t done in Spanish with subtitles or why the actors couldn’t have put on a little accent to indicate that their characters live in South America.
But no, they had to make the movie in English with top-rated American actors who don’t look even slightly Hispanic. The worst part was that the only characters that looked authentic were the minor ones–the peasants and the low-wage workers who had no speaking parts.
What kind of image of Hispanics is the movie industry trying to present? Are they saying we’re not good enough to play major roles? Are we only good enough for nonspeaking parts that encourage stereotypes of Hispanics as poor and uneducated?
When I was going home after the movie, I started wondering how come other ethnic groups don’t get treated this way. I mean, the leading roles in The Godfather trilogy and Goodfellas were played by Italian actors. And the stars of The Joy Luck Club and The Last Emperor were Asian. But it seems like whenever there’s a movie about Hispanics, the directors and producers cast white actors.
Al Pacino, Quit Playing Latinos
It’s about time the movie industry gave more work to Hispanic actors, directors, and producers. I’m sorry, but I don’t want to see Al Pacino play any more Hispanic roles like the leads in Scarface and Carlito’s Way. In Carlito’s Way, he’s supposed to be playing a street-smart Puerto Rican drug dealer who wants out, but instead he comes across as a trigger happy dweeb. And Al’s attempts to achieve that infamous Puerto Rican accent just make him sound like he has a frog stuck in his throat.
At least in Scarface (when he was much younger and more eager) he sounded and carried himself like a Cuban. That’s the only movie I can remember where a person who wasn’t Latino played a Hispanic character well.
I know it sounds rather harsh saying that only Hispanics should play Hispanic roles, but think how silly the movie The Last Emperor would be if Jeremy Irons played the emperor. What if Winona Ryder were one of the daughters in The Joy Luck Club? It wouldn’t look realistic because they’re not Asian, right? So why should movies about Latinos be held to a different standard?
Few Good Parts For Hispanic Actors
If there were lots of movies being made about Hispanics, then maybe I would feel differently. If Hispanics were always getting good movie roles and got to play White characters, then I’d be OK with Whites playing Hispanic roles. But it’s just not that way. So for now, only Hispanics should get to play Hispanic roles. I firmly stand by this.
I’ve felt this way ever since I discovered that a lot of the Puerto Rican characters in West Side Story were played by White people (that’s not counting the great Rita Moreno). Like the part of Maria: When I found out that Natalie Wood wasn’t Puerto Rican and that the guy who played Bernardo was also Caucasian, I flipped. They played their roles well, I’ll admit, but their presence made the movie seem so unreal to me. Whenever I saw Maria and Bernardo on the screen, I’d think, “But they’re White.”
West Side Story was done in the ’60s. Isn’t it funny how 30 years later movies like The House of the Spirits continue to deny Hispanic actors the opportunity to play Hispanic roles?
Movies That Could Make Me Proud
When I was kid, every time I finished watching a TV show or a movie, I would sit and wait for all the credits to appear to see if any Hispanics had contributed to the production. I guess I wanted to feel a sense of pride that my people were a part of something as classy and glamorous as the movie industry. Of course I would see a Perez and Gonzalez here and there, but they were usually something like the electrician’s helper, never the actors or the producers.
Even though movies and TV exaggerate a lot, they are the mirrors of what society is really all about. When I see Latinos in movies playing drug pushers, addicts, and prostitutes, I can’t help wondering if that negative image is all that other people see when they look at us.
If it is, then they have forgotten the many writers, painters, politicians, and singers that have contributed to Hispanic culture. I’d like to see some movies about them for a change. And yes, I’d like those movies to star Hispanic actors.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.