I recently saw a magazine ad for Quorum cologne that showed a good looking man, dressed in a suit and tie, smiling confidently. He’s the perfect image of the yuppie businessman, except for one thing-the smiling baby strapped securely to his back.
The slogan across the top of the page says, “Success is knowing which appointments to keep.” This man is making time for his child as well as his career and is doing a great job with both.
In an advertisement for Emeraude perfume, there are little “snapshots” of a happy couple’s relationship. The man is calling the woman at the office, taking her to movies, remembering their six-month anniversary, baking her a birthday cake from scratch. The logo in the corner says, “Play for keeps.”
This man is devoted and romantic. He gives almost unconditionally to his girlfriend and seems eager to settle down. He does things that we usually associate with women, like remembering special occasions and baking.
Lately, there have been more and more ads like these that use the image of a new kind of guy to sell products to both men and women. This man is successful in his career but provides his family with more than just financial support.
The Sensitive Type
He thinks up romantic surprises for his wife or girlfriend and spends quality time with his kids. He cooks, and he might even do it well. He’s good-looking and wants to stay that way. He cares about what he wears and what kind of soap he uses and finds time for working out.
Ads in magazines that are targeted to women, such as Vogue and Mademoiselle, emphasize this man’s romantic side. A Sand and Sable perfume ad shows a man and a woman sitting on the beach about to kiss. In an Esprit clothing ad we see a man kissing a woman on the cheek. Estee Lauder mascara is hyped with a photograph of a man’s lips delicately kissing a woman’s eyebrows.
In magazines that are targeted more towards men, you see fewer of these ads and more that depict a family man. An Eternity cologne ad uses a picture of a man cradling a child protectively. A Chemical Bank advertisement shows a father and child building a sand castle on the beach.
But whether they’re interacting with women or children, the men that appear in advertisements today are sensitive, expressive, and loving.
Careers, Cars, and Cigarettes
Forty years ago, this image of men was unheard of and would have been ridiculed. Looking at commercials and magazine ads from the 1950s at the library and the Museum of Radio and Television, I saw very different ideas of what a man was supposed to be.
For the 50’s man, work was more important than anything else. He may have loved his wife and children, but he wouldn’t admit to any kind of emotion, even if he was being tortured. He didn’t worry about how he looked. In his spare time, he tinkered with his car, smoked cigarettes, and drank beer with the boys; he certainly didn’t bake cakes.
Commercials and ads from those days show a clear division between men’s and women’s roles. It was extremely rare to see men doing anything around the house.
The exceptions were a commercial for S.O.S. Brillo pads that showed a woman screaming at a man to wash a bunch of dirty pots. They start singing (most commercials from that time had some kind of music in them), only the woman is singing in a deep bass voice, and the man is singing in a high soprano.
In a commercial for Ajax, also from the 1950’s, male elves are shown scrubbing a bathtub. The message of these commercials is that a “real” man wouldn’t be cleaning the bathtub or scrubbing pots. Only men with something wrong with them would do that-small men or men that are in some way feminine.
Mr. Know-It-All
The commercials in those days were clear about what kind of activities were masculine. A commercial from the late 1940’s for Marlboro cigarettes is a good example. It shows a man fixing his car. He’s all dirty and grungy and says that there is nothing he likes better than spending the day in his garage.
Except, maybe, smoking. And boy, does he love Marlboros, and not just for the taste. Since he’s mechanically inclined, he admires well-made things, like the flip top box the cigarettes come in.
In all of the commercials from that era, men were painted as technical experts. They were authorities on everything from toothpaste to cars. Even your average Joe was turned on by a well made box.
In general, men admired something functional rather than something beautiful. This ideal even applied to their personal appearance. The fanciest this guy would get, as far as grooming products went, was dandruff shampoo.
In fact, the only 50’s ad for a grooming product for men that I saw was for Tegrin medicated shampoo. It showed a small picture of a man washing his hair. The text below the picture suggested that men with serious dandruff problems see a doctor, because it was probably a sign of a medical condition. The assumption was that the only reason a man would care about what kind of shampoo to use would be if he had a medical problem.
Looking Good!
Today advertisements assume that men care just as much about their appearance as women do (if not more). Suddenly, grooming is more than just a shave and a comb through. Ads for shampoos and soaps that are targeted to men these days talk about the way they make you look and smell, not about whether they make you clean and healthy.
A recent ad for Nexus shampoo, shows two blondes-a man and a woman-sitting side by side. Both have shiny, perfectly styled hair. The message is that having beautiful hair is equally important to men and women. Both are looking for the shampoo that’s going to make their hair look good.
Why has the way men are depicted in advertising changed so much? I think that it’s because our society’s values have changed. Men and women used to have the same expectations, both of themselves and of each other. The woman would be the homemaker, and the man would be the breadwinner.
Now that those set roles have become archaic, men and women want different things from life and from their relationships with each other. The advertisements of today seem to be saying that what’s important to men is having a family and a career, whereas women want romance and a career. Interest in and responsibility for children and family have moved from women to men.
This image of men may not be realistic (women are still more likely to take care of the kids and do the household chores) but it’s good to see that men are being exposed to different kinds of role models.
Guys in Advertising: They’re Not the Men They Used To Be
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.