GED vs. Diploma: Does It Make a Difference?

Some people think that GED stands for General Equivalency Diploma, but the initials actually stand for General Educational Development. I can see why they’d have that misperception, because people who don’t graduate from high school can take the GED test. By passing, they get a credential that fulfills the high school diploma requirement on most job and college applications.
Both of my parents took that route. My mom dropped out of high school in 1985, when she was 17. “I was a black teenage mother, dropping out of school, trying to earn a GED with a newborn baby,” said DeBorah A. Sauls-DeLaCruz. “But I earned it, and worked in the same companies that my peers who earned a high school diploma worked.”
The Diploma Advantage
Even though some people, like my mom, are able to make good lives for themselves with a GED instead of a high school diploma, others argue that GED recipients are at a disadvantage.
According to James Brown, a labor market analyst for the New York State Department of Labor, it’s easier for someone who has a high school diploma to be hired than a GED recipient. “Generally speaking, a high school diploma is looked higher upon than a GED,” he said.
And that can make a difference in salary, said Tom Dunn of the New York State Department of Education. “Over a lifetime, the difference between the income of a high school diploma and GED recipient is great,” he said.
College-No Ifs, Ands or Buts
Now that I’m 17 and a senior at Edward R. Murrow HS, I know that I’m going to finish high school and receive my diploma. The thought of quitting school never crossed my mind-not that my parents would’ve let it.
From an early age, it was instilled in me: finish elementary school, go on to junior high, then high school, then on to college; no ifs, ands or buts about it. In college, I plan on tackling the fields of computers, journalism and Japanese studies.
Still, I can understand why my mother dropped out of New Utrecht HS when she was pregnant (with me). “At that time, regular high schools did not allow pregnant teens to attend,” she explained. “The alternative was to transfer to a satellite school for teenage mothers.”
But that school was too far away, so my mom dropped out and decided to work for her GED instead.
Never Ashamed of a GED
Earning her GED increased her confidence to apply for jobs and to go to college.
“I never went into a job interview ashamed of having a GED,” she said. She could get the same city jobs as her friends who had high school diplomas, she said. And she worked on Wall Street as a bank vice president’s assistant before she went on to college.
My dad, Macario DeLaCruz, didn’t go to college, but he did get his GED. He dropped out of Pacific HS at age 16 because he thought he needed to make money.
“I thought I knew all the answers,” he said, and he didn’t think school was one of them.
Didn’t See the Big Picture
Leaving school and getting his GED was the “easy way out,” he admitted. “It wasn’t a very insightful decision. I didn’t see the big picture.”
When I asked him whether or not he thought earning a high school diploma would’ve made his life better, he said, “I don’t know if it would’ve been better or worse, but I know it would be different.”
With his GED, he was still able to become a tokenbooth clerk and a corrections officer. He now works at Madison Square Garden, where one of his jobs is getting food and drinks for people in the suite boxes at the top of the arena; he meets a lot of new people and celebrities.
Like my parents, some of my friends, like my boy Zachary (not his real name), have dropped out of high school. My friends mostly say that they just don’t like school, but they, too, plan on earning their GED.
I think Zach, 16, is finally seeing part of the picture because now he acknowledges he may have made a wrong decision. Zach dropped out of high school in 10th grade because he didn’t like school.
“I couldn’t take it no more,” he said. “I was like, ‘Mom and Dad, I can’t do it.’ Of course they didn’t like it.”
Even though Zach’s my boy and all, I don’t think his reasons for dropping out are reasonable. He didn’t like waking up early, doing homework, or studying for Regents tests, and he developed a bad cutting habit. He’d skip the last few classes of the day and sometimes the full day.
The freedom he felt when he wasn’t in school was “very addicting,” and he went less and less. Then he felt it was too late to catch up, so he dropped out for real.
Is it Too Late?
Now he feels it would be a waste of time for him to go back now to try to earn his high school diploma, because he’d have to repeat so many classes. Zach’s been looking for a job, but he tells me that he plans on getting his GED and eventually going to college to study computers. He admits he hasn’t been preparing for the GED test, though.
Zach is hoping that the GED will be easier than all the Regents exams he’d have to take to get a high school diploma. Under new rules in New York State, all public high school students are required to take-and pass-Regents exams in several subjects in order to graduate.
I asked Tom Dunn if more students would now drop out and take the GED rather than the required Regents. “We’ve seen very little evidence of that,” he said. “Yes, there is some concern, some anxiety, but students want a meaningful high school diploma. Students are rising to the expectations.”
Getting a GED instead of a Regents diploma won’t keep you out of college, if that’s where you want to go. More than 90% of colleges and universities accept GED holders, as long as they have certain scores and meet other qualifications for admission.
College Requirements
SUNY Stony Brook, for example, will consider applicants with a GED score of 300 or better. (Requirements for a passing GED score vary from state to state, but a minimum total score of 225 is often the standard.)
But getting accepted may not be that easy. “We like to see a strong academic background, strong college-prep curriculum,” said Robert Pertusati, an associate dean at SUNY Stony Brook. He said applicants should have at least an 1100 on the SAT and “strong letters of recommendation from teachers or employers are also looked highly upon, as well as a student’s personal statement,” or essay.
If the sight of such high numbers and your lack of accolades makes you cringe, don’t worry, just look for colleges with less demanding requirements. For example, at Brooklyn College, while you still need a 300 on the GED, you don’t need to take the SAT. And Long Island University will accept applicants with a 250 or higher GED score.
Moving Beyond the GED
Having a GED instead of a regular high school diploma didn’t keep my mom from getting into Parsons School of Design, where she got a BFA in Interior Architecture, with honors.
“I’ll admit that there are things that I missed out on by not completing high school, both academically and socially,” said my mom. “But regretting your decisions just stops you from improving on the decisions that you do make.”
Even though she didn’t go to her senior prom or get a high school yearbook, she said, “I do have my college memories, and a college reunion to look forward to.”

SIDEBAR: Who Can Take the GED?
Anyone 19 or older in New York State who left high school without a diploma can register and take the GED test. In New York, 17- and 18-year-olds may test if they’ve been out of school officially for one year, their original class already graduated or if they’ve applied for the armed services. If you’re 16, you have to have been part of an approved high school equivalency program in order to take the test. The GED (General Educational Development) test was created in 1942 during World War II. Originally, the test was only open to veterans, whose schooling might have been interrupted by the war. The test measures how well-rounded a person is in the skills and general knowledge required to succeed in a four-year high school environment. The five parts of the test cover writing, interpreting literature and the arts, social studies, science and math. Because some test-takers may have been out of school for a long period of time, the GED test is based on knowledge and skills gathered through daily activities and experiences, including watching the news or reading newspapers. The test is offered in Spanish and French as well as English. For more information on GED testing, check out these resources: The official website of the GED testing service: www.gedtest.org Literacy Assistance Center 32 Broadway, 10th fl. New York, NY 10004 For more information on where to find GED programs in New York City, you can call their Literacy Referral Hotline at 212-803-3333. Or go to their website: www.lacnyc.org/hotline/gedinformation.htm

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.