Forget Cinderella and Snow White: Life Is Not a Fairy Tale

Growing up I loved to read fairy tales and have them read to me. They were an escape from the everyday world into a place where the good people always won and everyone lived happily ever after. I thought that someday I, like the heroines of the stories, would be swept off my feet by a handsome prince who would marry me and take care of me. It never bothered me that the female characters never had to worry about working or other adult responsibilities. I was content as long as the story ended with them riding off into the sunset on the prince’s white horse.
Now I work in the children’s section of a public library. Remembering my childhood love of fairy tales, I recently browsed through some of them again. I wasn’t thrilled with what I read: although girls and women have important roles in these tales, I haven’t found one fairy tale with a strong, likable female character.
Smart and Evil or Sweet and Clueless
When I was younger, I never noticed that most of the women in fairy tales are either helpless damsels in distress or villains. Now I see that characters like Snow White and Cinderella are incapable of solving their own problems. They don’t use intelligence to get out of trouble, but either rely on their sweet nature or wait for a man to save them.
The women who do show strength are villains, like the evil queen and the wicked stepmother. This seems to idealize girls who cannot help themselves and vilify those who do.
In Snow White, both female characters fit these stereotypes. The pretty, helpless princess, Snow White, is hated by her stepmother, the vain, jealous queen, only because she is beautiful. When her stepmother orders a woodsman to kill her, he lets Snow White go and she is rescued by dwarves. They let her stay with them because she is sweet and beautiful and willing to take on domestic responsibilities such as cooking and cleaning. Two messages are subtly being given: she needs men to take care of her and females naturally fill the role of hired help.
The story also makes clear that while Snow White is beautiful and sweet, she’s not very bright. Though the queen repeatedly tries to kill Snow White, first by disguising herself and giving Snow White a poisonous comb and later returning with a poisoned apple, Snow White remains clueless. She accepts the apple, despite her experience with the first “gift” and despite the dwarves’ repeated warnings not to accept things from strangers. (After she is poisoned by the apple, the dwarves put her in a glass coffin where the prince, captivated by her beauty, rescues her from her coma and they live happily ever after.)
Waiting To Be Rescued
This story sends several unflattering messages about women. First, it says that women are always competing and shouldn’t trust each other. It also equates beauty with goodness and kindness and makes it clear that it is better to be pretty than smart. Finally, it says that a girl must rely on a man to save her and make her life complete rather than take the initiative and help herself.
Cinderella is another fairy tale whose main character is sweet, beautiful and helpless. Cinderella’s stepmother is jealous of Cinderella’s beauty and forces her to wear rags and do housework (another domestic?) while she spoils her two ugly daughters. When the prince holds a ball to find a bride and invites every girl in the kingdom, Cinderella’s family leaves her behind to cry and wish that she could go too. She is rescued by a fairy godmother who magically conjures up a gown and coach, but warns her to return before the spell wears off.
Cinderella captures the prince’s heart, but must run off at midnight, leaving behind one of her glass slippers. He finds her and marries her and they live happily ever after. Like Snow White, this is a tale of jealousy and envy among women, again equating physical beauty with inner goodness. Once again, the heroine is first victimized by and later triumphs over her ugly, evil rivals. And her triumph is being chosen by the handsome prince.
What Makes Them So Popular?
I think these stories encourage little girls to wait for a man to take care of them, rather than try to find fulfillment on their own. I started to wonder why fairy tales are still so popular (they’re often checked out of the library where I work) despite their anti-feminist messages.
To find out, I read a couple of books on the subject. I checked out Don’t Tell the Grown-Ups: Subversive Children’s Literature, a book of literary criticism by Alison Lurie, to see if she shared my opinion that fairy tales encourage passivity and dependence among girls. Lurie explains that in the best known tales the heroines are either princesses awaiting rescue from some danger or enchantment (Snow White and Sleeping Beauty), or deserving but poor girls who will become princesses if they are lucky and good (Cinderella and Rapunzel).
Lurie explains that the idea of passive princesses “has always appealed to men, and it turns up again and again in their fiction.” The poor but deserving girls who become princesses appealed to women in the past because they reinforced the popular idea that marrying above one’s class was the key to happiness.
Although it may have been true in past centuries that women could only improve their status through marriage, today women have other options-they can have their own careers and make their own money. But these tales still give young girls the impression that marrying a rich, handsome man is the answer to life’s problems and that nothing else is as important.
As for wicked stepmothers, Lurie says they are used to explain the side of a child’s mother who scolds and disciplines her. In The Uses of Enchantment, child psychologist Bruno Bettelheim offers a different explanation. He writes that wicked stepmothers and evil queens are outlets for a child’s Oedipal/Electra conflicts (that’s when a little girl is in love with her father and resents her mother for being married to him). The evil queen or wicked stepmother represents the girl’s fear and hatred of her mother. The girl sees herself as the damsel in distress waiting for her prince (a fatherlike figure) to save her.
We Need New Stories
Both these explanations make sense, but I still think that strong women are portrayed very negatively and that this image makes it seem that being in control is an undesirable quality in a woman. Even today, the girl who tries to be her own person is labeled unfeminine or butch rather than encouraged to pursue her interests.
Over the years, I’ve often been told by both authority figures (such as teachers and relatives) and by my peers that girls aren’t supposed to or simply can’t do certain things that boys can do. I began to realize that in many cases girls and women were treated unfairly and are expected to be more docile and passive than boys. I now realize that the fairy tales I read as a child contain that same message.
I don’t think fairy tales should be banned, but I’d like to find some that don’t portray women as weak and helpless and which don’t end with the prince and princess riding off into the sunset. I’d like to see more fairy tales with girls who take charge, yet aren’t cruel and selfish. I’d like to see fairy tales about girls whose happiness lies in something other than marrying a prince.
Fairy tales have taught many of us to accept the role of passive princess waiting to be rescued. We encounter enough sexism and “You can’t do that. You’re a girl,” in our everyday lives. We need stories that help prepare us to stand up for ourselves, not stories that encourage passivity and dependence on men.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.