Forced Off the Air

Teens Respond to the Don Imus Scandal

Radio host Don Imus has “made a career out of saying the outrageous,” news anchor Katie Couric said on the April 9 edition of the CBS Evening News.
CBS broadcast Imus’s program, Imus in the Morning, for more than 30 years, and MSNBC has been simulcasting the show on cable TV for the past 10 years, according to a recent article in The New York Times.
But on April 4th, Don Imus called the Rutgers University women’s basketball team “nappy-headed ho’s” on his show, the day after the team lost the NCAA basketball championship to the University of Tennessee. Both CBS and MSNBC gave Don Imus a two-week suspension. But even after he personally apologized to the Rutgers basketball team for his comments, the pressure to fire him quickly grew.
Show Canceled
The young women on the team, which includes eight African-American and two white players, were “highly angered” and “deeply saddened” by his words, according to an April 10 New York Times article.
They weren’t the only ones who were angry. Advertisers announced that they intended to pull their commercials from Mr. Imus’s show, according to an April 12 New York Times article.
A week after Imus made his comment, black leaders Rev. Al Sharpton and Rev. Jesse Jackson met with CBS Chief Executive Officer Leslie Moonves to demand that Imus be fired, promising a rally outside CBS headquarters, according to an Associated Press article. In the end, CBS chose to permanently cancel Imus’s show on April 12th, one day after MSNBC had canceled the TV simulcast of the show.
When CBS executive Leslie Moonves announced the decision, according to the Associated Press article, he said, “There has been much discussion of the effect language like this has on our young people, particularly young women of color trying to make their way in this society.”
I wanted to hear directly from young people what they thought about the Imus situation, since all I’d heard in the news came from adults. So I decided to interview a few of my peers.
Blown Out of Proportion?
The teens I talked to differed in their reactions to Imus’s comment. Patrick Claude, 17, a student at Brooklyn International HS, said he was shocked that a professional host who knows how the media works would say such a racist comment on the air. “He shouldn’t say something like that and get away with it,” said Patrick.
Angelo Landers, 17, from East New York Transit Tech HS, agreed. “Anyone, no matter what race and gender they are, shouldn’t be called anything but their names,” he said.
But two other teens I spoke to thought that while Imus’s comment was immoral, it was also blown out of proportion by the media.
“If an African-American had said it they wouldn’t have taken it seriously, but since a white man said it, I think they [overreacted],” said Earlynn Bernadin, 16, who goes to Midwood HS.
Pierre Gedeon, 15, a student at Brooklyn International HS, agreed that there was a double standard when it came to race.
“I think he deserved another chance because he was influenced by the way [these words are] used in the black community. If rappers use these words all the time, why can’t he use them and get a second chance?” said Pierre.
But all four teens said that in the end, firing Imus was the only solution, especially since advertisers were already pulling away from the show and CBS would’ve lost a lot of money if they’d kept him on the air.
Apology Not Accepted
I was really surprised that all the teens I interviewed thought that canceling the show was the right thing to do. Personally, I thought it would’ve been enough to put Imus on temporary probation until he learned his lesson. After all, he did apologize.
But Patrick and Angelo pointed out that if CBS had given Imus a second chance, he and other “shock jocks” like him would think that making offensive comments wasn’t a big deal and would continue to do it. They also didn’t believe that his apology was enough to let him off the hook.
“You can apologize all you want, but once the words come out of your mouth, it means that you had the thought of saying it-that at the time, it was intentional,” said Angelo.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.