Fixing the Welfare System: Don’t Deny Me an Education!

Fixing the Welfare System
Don’t Deny Me an Education!
By Carmen D. Smith
As a 21-year-old, single, “welfare mother,” I am someone whom many taxpayers and politicians despise.
It’s not because they know me but because of the stereotype that people like me are greedy and sit around all day doing nothing. The various new welfare reform efforts are being publicized as a way to give us the motivation to finally do something with our lives and end the cycle of generations of children growing up on welfare.
But many of us are already doing a lot to better our lives.
We haven’t been on welfare for long and have no intention of staying on it any longer than is absolutely necessary for us to get the education we need to be able to support ourselves and our children and contribute to this society. And in my experience the laws that are supposed to get me off welfare have made that harder, not easier.
A Scholarship to NYU
I was 16 when my daughter, Adriana, was born and I knew that being able to take care of her meant getting the best education possible. With my mother’s help and with daycare provided by the Agency for Child Development (ACD), I was able to attend St. John’s Preparatory School in Queens.
I did so well in my studies there that I was a member of the National Honor Society and was accepted by every college that I applied to. NYU offered me a complete financial aid package consisting of a scholarship, student loans and government grants. And that’s where I decided to attend.
Everything was going great until a little over a year ago when my mother started having serious financial problems and was no longer in a position to help me and Adriana with our living expenses. I had never had to consider what would happen if my mother could not continue to support me through my final years at college.
It Was Either Drop Out or Apply For Welfare
All of a sudden I had to deal with the fact that if I wanted to finish school and get my daughter some medical coverage I would have to apply for welfare. I didn’t want to-in fact, I was ashamed-but I felt I had no choice.
Since my daughter was four years old when I applied for welfare I was automatically enrolled in BEGIN, a program designed to give recipients the means by which to eventually stand on their own two feet. Adriana and I receive about $600 a month in cash and food stamps and that barely covers our most basic needs.
I was told if I wanted to qualify for additional money I either had to enroll in a vocational training program or go for a two-year associate’s degree. I didn’t want to settle for less than the best when I had worked so hard to get into NYU. So I decided to forego that part and continue working toward my bachelor’s degree.
Despite the fact that money is tight, I have been working hard and have been a successful student and mother. Last year I completed my sophomore year at NYU as an Economics major with a 3.3 GPA. Adriana is a happy child who loves to draw. We read together and she’s supposed to start kindergarten this fall.
They Changed the Rules on Me
But now a dark cloud has descended over our future. On July 16, I was informed that a new city law required me to enter the Work Experience Program and work in a welfare office, government agency, or public park for 90 days with neither pay nor job placement afterwards. If I didn’t agree to this, I was told I would lose my benefits.
The fact that I am a full-time student does not exempt me from the new requirements. Recipients have to work from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. at an office of the Department of Social Services’ choosing-no matter how far away it is from your campus or home-and we are not allowed to attend night school.
So, if I comply with what they are asking, I will be forced to quit school and throw away years of hard work. I won’t have the education or experience to ever be able to earn enough money to pay back my student loans.
I Can’t Do Everything at Once
If I don’t comply, my benefits will be cut off. To keep my scholarship, I would have to continue going to school full-time and work enough hours to pay our living expenses and afford a baby-sitter. Adriana needs and deserves all the love and attention I can give. I do not know how I could spend any time with her and still work, go to school, sleep, write papers, and study. It seems like a physical impossibility.
The reformers claim that forcing everyone to work is the way to make welfare recipients self-sufficient and give us a sense of self-worth. But their willingness to penalize those of us who are trying to educate ourselves and improve the likelihood that we will be able to get and keep a job suggests that all their talk of bettering people’s lives is little more than empty rhetoric.
Welfare was meant to temporarily help people get back on their feet. What better way to do this than to let recipients complete their educations?
Teach a Man to Fish. . .
You know the old saying that if you give a man a fish he will have dinner for one night but teach him to fish and he will never go hungry? I am trying to escape my dependency on welfare. I want to be able to rely on myself.
All this kind of welfare reform does is push people like me into an already crowded workforce without the proper skills or education. It doesn’t do me, Adriana or society any good whatsoever. It prevents us from becoming self-sufficient by making sure that we will always be one short step away from poverty.
I want to take charge of my own future and that begins with graduating from college. In two years I can get a respectable job and am willing to pay back the government for the assistance. If I could borrow the money somewhere else I would.
But the welfare system is not set up for success stories. At its best, it creates a secondary class of citizens with less training and fewer chances of earning a humane paycheck than everyone else. It relegates people to the ranks of the impoverished and maintains a constant source of cheap labor.
Punished For Not Having More Babies
One example of the mixed-up logic by which the system currently operates is that if I had been more irresponsible and continued having children I wouldn’t be in this dilemma. But because my only child is over the age of four and in school now, I am considered eligible for the Work Experience Program.
My choices, therefore, are either to quit school, work at the welfare office and continue to live in poverty; have another baby and stay at home; or try to finish school and have my benefits cut off altogether.
If I could work and go to school and afford good quality day care I would. If I could get health coverage for my daughter without welfare I would. Welfare was my last resort. I do not buy shrimp and lobster with my food stamps and I have not had a new piece of clothing in years. I don’t have a savings or checking account-my assets are zero.
I Won’t Fulfill Their Stereotype
Don’t get me wrong. I’m grateful for the support that I have been given so far. But I am also angry. Angry that the government is encouraging me to quit school rather than beat the odds, angry that I am being punished for having only one child, for striving to get an education and for daring to dream.
I refuse to become a walking stereotype. I want to be able to say that I did my all to get an education and that I never settled for second best. I want to work and I want to take care of my daughter. Most of all I want to save Adriana from falling into the welfare cycle, from becoming another statistic. She deserves a chance.
Give Me the Chance to Contribute
And so do I. All I am asking for is the chance to finish what I started, the chance to complete my education so that I can put back into society more than what I got from it.
With an Economics degree from NYU instead of just my high school diploma, I will not only be able to keep my daughter and myself off welfare, I’ll be able to pay more taxes and contribute to the hope of the future. Whatever I do to benefit my life will also benefit my daughter’s. And our lives will touch others and those lives will touch still others.
There is a proverb that says, “Whoever saves one life, saves the world entire.” I am just trying to protect the life that I brought into this world.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.