Fighting Words

Before I was born, or even thought of for that matter, there lived a bachelor named Thomas Lemmo.
Now I’ve heard stories of his escapades-whether it be dealing-with-angry-cab-driver stories or about how he was just another stupid kid-but nothing compares to this story my father tells about being a bouncer, and how he relives it as he tells it.
His eyes look as though they are going to bulge out of his head. With his deep voice and his Queens-Italian accent, he takes his time, making the minutes tick by ever so slowly.
He’s told me this story many times, and every time he reenacts it with a smirk on his face, as though a conquest was successful, and a war won.
We often spend time lounging in our kitchen, talking over cups of coffee; since my parents are divorced, I see my dad once every two weeks. I enjoy the time I spend with him-it’s good to be filled in on his life because I can get a better understanding of him as a person, not just as a father.
So here we sit at the table, sipping cups of Pepsi and coffee. Him at age 61, his coffee mug wrapped by his long, thick fingers covered with blisters from his last carpenter’s job; me at age 17, with a pen between my fingers, chewing on the pen’s cap.
Boyfriends Tremble
My father is anything but a petite guy. Standing at a bone-crushing 6’2″, 220 lbs., he doesn’t get much flak from anybody; either they know better or they’ll have to face his wrath.
Boyfriends tremble at the sight of him, ex-boyfriends run from him and everyone else stays out of his way. I appreciate that; I like knowing that he supports me, physically and emotionally-in whatever I say or do.
My dad’s been a carpenter for 32 years. Back in the 1970s, though, he was a bouncer at a huge club in an abandoned airplane base in Queens. It was a popular disco joint, holding up to 1,000 or so people at a time, and the owners had no tolerance for drunks or fights. To keep the club safe, they paid 20 or so bouncers to keep order. And keep order they did.
On one particular night, several bouncers, including my father, kicked out one especially drunk 21-year-old, who then vowed revenge on him and his colleagues. “I’ll come back with three cars full of people with bats, knives and everything. You watch-all of you will be sorry.”
A Bouncer’s Utopia
Writing it off as another threat-I guess in that business you expect to get many threats-they continued maintaining the peace and thought nothing of it.
Several days passed with no sign of three cars filled with people. No sign of bats, knives or any other kind of trouble. A bouncer’s utopia.
As my dad says, “I remember it being quite peaceful, at least for a while.
“But later,” my father tells me, “I distinctly remember standing in front, taking care of another quarrel, when another bouncer comes running up to me, informing me there’s a severe problem outside.” He is no longer looking at me.
Three Cars Full of Pissed-Off Guys
“I rushed outside, probably knocking all sorts of people out of my way. When I reached the doors, there sure as sh-t were three cars full of guys blocking the entrance to the club, complaining loudly about how ‘I told you I’d be back!’
“My buddies and I didn’t know what to do. They completely outnumbered us.”
By this time my dad’s eyes are completely glazed over; he seems to be truly reliving this event in his mind. I ask him, “Well, what happened next?”
I sit there waiting for the real juicy part, and I’m glad when my father delivers. “Well, it just happens,” he rambles on, “my little Irish bouncer friend Eddie rushes through the crowd to find what you would call the leader of the group, and confronts him and threatens him, using what I still find handy to this day!
“‘If a fight breaks out,’ Eddie says, ‘I will personally see to it that I make my way all the way to you, getting past all your buddies. I guarantee I will find you, and when I’m done with you, your own mother won’t recognize you!'”
Short Bouncer with a Mouth
My dad pauses for a second, waiting for me to gasp or hold my breath. But then he remembers I’ve heard this story before and suspense isn’t exactly killing me, so he picks up where he left off.
“At the moment when Eddie finished speaking, I was watching this guy’s face as he thought it over and the smirk once on his face completely faded, and he went from stern to horrified.
“Quickly he retreated, yelling to his friends, ‘Guys get back in the cars, we’re done here!'”
I don’t know if it all got solved that fast, but that’s the way my dad tells it: “Eddie was in fact pretty small, but he was a tough fighter, and those words made him seem twice his height. I guess that’s why the guy backed down. Words can have a pretty profound effect on people.”
He sighs, and his eyes focus back on me. He’s finished the triumphant retelling of a story that he claims changed all his old fighting methods.
Since then, instead of just jumping into a fight, my dad tries to make things a bit more verbal, whether by working the problem out or threatening the hell out of someone.
Like Father, Like Daughter
He uses his words as his weapons, and he extends what Eddie did to situations where he wants to defend something he believes in-not just in possibly violent situations, either. He got himself promoted at work by saying something he’d thought would get him fired.
My dad often tells me to speak up for what I believe in and how he’ll back me 110%.
So I try to open my mouth whenever I do believe in something or someone.
I have one of those voices that, with the same Queens-Italian accent my dad has, doesn’t seem like it’s coming out of a 5’5″ girl. I guess I’m Eddie in that respect; I’m small but I use my mouth.
My group of friends thinks I’m a hard-ass. When I don’t want to do something they want to do, I say so. They’re perhaps a bit intimated by it, considering that a lot of people don’t voice their opinions when they disagree with their friends.
My Dad, My Hero
I’ve always enjoyed this particular story because I remember first hearing it and thinking, “My father the hero-what a tough guy he is.”
It’s also nice to know how different he is with me compared to the rest of the world. He can be an absolute sweetheart when he’s getting all mushy about his daughter. But if anyone pisses him off, he’s ready to do battle.
Even so, after telling his story, he’s got to throw in a typical father remark: “Don’t let me catch you fighting, Caitlin!”

View the lessons based on this story

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.