For three years I was living with an abuser who hit me and made me feel that I had no one to turn to.
I was 18 when I met him at a party. He was good looking, and the beginning of the relationship was great. He would pamper me and kiss me and act like he loved me.
But after a year, things started to change. He started to yell at me. Then the hitting began. He would kick me, punch me, smack me in the face. Once he pulled a gun and threatened to kill me. He told me that if I tried to leave him he would hurt my family and that he would hunt me down and kill me.
Repeating My Mother’s Life
I couldn’t believe what was happening. I never thought my life was going to be a repeat of my mother’s. When I was young, my father was loving to me and a good husband to my mom. But after my father was murdered, my life was hell. My mother married an abusive man. My mom would also hit me almost every day and blame me for how messed up her life was.
As a teen, I just wanted to be loved and for someone to care about me and my son. I really didn’t care who it was. When I saw the signs that my boyfriend was abusive, I didn’t want to believe it. It was so hard to look into my life and see my mother in the mirror.
Over time, my boyfriend’s violence grew worse, and eventually that made me stop loving him. I suffered through about a year of abuse before I tried to leave the first time. I tried to leave many times over the next two years, but I never succeeded.
The first time I called the cops I was scared of what could happen to my son and me if my boyfriend found out I was calling, but I never doubted that once the cops arrived I’d be safe.
The Cops Didn’t Help Me
But they treated it just like a dispute over the apartment, and they said that since my boyfriend had been living with me for more than six months, they could not do anything. After they drove away, I felt like there was no way out. I called the cops seven times in all while I was with my boyfriend, but each time the same two cops showed up. They never helped me.
After that, I went to a domestic violence unit, which is a place where women who are being abused can go for help. The first time I went I had to sneak out of my house. When I arrived the worker told me I would have to come back in a few weeks to see if they had found an apartment for me. I was incredibly disappointed. I was scared, too, because I knew that when I got home all hell would break loose.
Kicked All Over the House
When I got home my boyfriend asked where I’d been. He didn’t believe it when I said I’d been to my mother’s, so he hit me and kicked me all over the house. I went again anyway, but they still didn’t help. After that, I never went back. I felt like I had no one to turn to. Even my mother said she didn’t want anything to do with my problems. I felt like I was stuck with this man. I didn’t want to risk my life anymore with fruitless attempts trying to get away from him. I had a son to think of and he needed me.
Then in July 1993, about two years after I met him, my boyfriend hurt my son. I never imagined he would do anything to my son, but he broke my son’s leg. I don’t know why or how. I was at school, and when I came home my neighbor told me that the ambulance had taken my son to the hospital. After that, ACS took him.
Losing my son was the hardest thing I have ever gone through. I felt so alone with no one to care for and with no hope whatsoever.
Scared to Leave
I had accepted that I might be stuck with my boyfriend for life, but when he hurt my son I began to think I was crazy for being with him.
Still I stayed because. I thought he would kill me if I left. After all, when I’d tell him that I wanted to go to my mom’s house, he would hit me and say, “Can you go to her house looking like this? Huh? Now what are you going to do, b-tch?”
Then, a couple of months after ACS took my son, my boyfriend was arrested on drug charges and sentenced to five to seven years in jail. He spent a year and a half locked up.
Having that man out of my life was what I had wanted for a long, long time. But the pain of missing my son sometimes made me wish I had him around because I was so lonely. I hated that feeling and I fought with myself trying to understand why I had been with a man who had hurt my son.
Fighting for My Son
After my son was taken, I also had the foster care system to fight with. My first worker didn’t explain what I was supposed to learn from parenting classes or why I needed to go. My ACS worker didn’t ask what I needed. I felt lost each time I went to court. I did not know what to do or say. I felt like I couldn’t trust anyone.
I tried to comply with the requirements, but beyond that, for more than a year, all I did was cry and wish my son would come back. I cried for my son, who was only 3 and didn’t understand why he was taken. I cried for myself, too. For two years I just tried to understand why these things had happened in my life.
Eventually I started to learn who I was and what I wanted from my life. Therapy helped. I kept a journal of everything that we discussed, and in those logs I dealt with the pain from my past. Coming to terms with my past meant I learned not to blame myself for everything that had gone wrong and to accept myself and what had happened to me. I cried a lot of tears, but I also started to see my life as a lesson that I could learn from.
I attended groups with other mothers with kids in foster care. That helped too. Most of the women in the groups were much older than I was, and when I heard their stories I said to myself, “Damn, that could be you in a few years if you don’t do something. You have to fight. You cannot let this happen to your son.”
The System Worked Against Me
But even after I began to grow stronger, it seemed like my caseworkers were still working against me. I had 10 different caseworkers in a span of six years. That made it nearly impossible to develop a trusting relationship with any of them. I believe that, until the end, I didn’t have one worker who was committed to helping me get my son back. They told me that since my son had attention deficit disorder he was too much for me to handle. They said I had inadequate housing. They found all sorts of reasons why my son couldn’t come back to me.
After about a year and a half of my son being in care, one of my workers told me that if I married it would be easier to get my son back. I met a man soon after and I married him almost immediately. But that didn’t get my son back.
Meanwhile, my ex-boyfriend was released from jail. I was determined not to let him back into my life, but he wouldn’t let me be. He came after me every day, waiting for me in the streets, hitting me and threatening my life. He forced his way into my apartment. I was so afraid of what he’d do to my husband, that for a while I told him he had to leave. Then I ran away, too.
The Pain Only Grew
Eventually, I succeeded in finding cops who would help me, and I had him arrested for being in my house without permission. I pressed charges against him, and because he had other charges against him, he got locked up for almost two years.
But the years were passing. My son had been in foster care over three years. The more time that passed, the bigger the pain grew, because we were not together. It was painful, too, because I could see that my son was being hurt in his foster homes and hurt in his group home, too. He was even sexually abused.
That is what I cannot understand about the system. Why didn’t they help us by keeping us together and getting us the help we needed? I think I felt more pain than even if my son had died, because at least then I’d know that no one else could hurt him.
So I started to read books on how to fight back. I read Law books, books on child welfare, domestic violence, social work, poverty and oppression. Reading all those books gave me the strength to see that I was part of a bigger problem, and I began to say, “The system cannot screw me.”
Mine wasn’t a quick learning curve, but I learned a lot. Four years after my son had gone into foster care I began putting my demands on the table. I was no longer the scared young girl I had been, and you could see in my caseworkers’ faces when I spoke that they were thinking, “Oh sh-t, she’s got knowledge.”
‘She’s Got Knowledge’
I met the executive director of my agency, New York Foundling, and she saw my potential and hired me to be a parent leader in their new “Parents as Partners” program. But while my agency was holding me up as a parent leader, my caseworker was still saying that my son was not ready to come home.
After my son was in care for almost five years, I was given my 10th caseworker. I talked to her on the phone and soon I had a court date. I thought they were going to tell me that they were going to extend my son’s placement for another year. But when I arrived in court, the agency had its own plan and that plan was to terminate my parental rights.
An Angel On My Case
I was shocked. But just as the lawyer from the agency was talking to the judge about terminating my rights, an angel came into the courtroom and saved me. The angel was my new caseworker. She had gotten to court late, but I am so glad that she made it there. She knew that terminating my rights was not the right thing to do.
Donna told the judge what I had accomplished in the past five years, and how much my son was hurting without me. So the judge extended his placement one year, to be returned to me after that year. It took me six years to get my son back. It was worth the fight because in 1999 he came home to me.
The first few years that my son was home were hard. He was very angry and I could see the pain in his eyes. Sometimes he had flashbacks to abuse he had experienced while he was in the system. He had many nightmares, too. One minute he’d be fine and the next he’d be out of control. Sometimes he would yell at me and call me a b-tch. He would challenge me, “Ain’t you gonna punish me? Ain’t you gonna punish me?” He started fights in school and cursed teachers out. Sometimes he’d yell, “F-ck everybody, you can send me back!”
At first I didn’t feel strong enough to handle it. I felt like I had screwed up as a mother, and I couldn’t separate out him and me enough to help him. But I tried to remember everything I had learned in therapy. I went back to my logs and read them again. I would lie in bed at night and cry. I tried to stop feeling guilty just enough to help him. Then I would calculate my next move. I knew that if I reacted with anger it would make things worse.
For the most part, I just let him yell and scream and tried to have faith that he would come around and be himself again. Then when he calmed down we’d talk it through. I went up and down with his moods like a roller coaster. But once I realized he was testing me to see if I was going to get rid of him just like all his foster homes, it was easier.
Building Trust
My son is now 13 years old. Everything has changed for the better. My son and I have built trust in the past four years. He’s doing better in school, and at home we talk and laugh and are close. I thank God for giving me my son back. It’s been a long road to a better life, but I enjoy every hour, every minute and every second with him.
As for my ex-boyfriend, when he was locked up the second time, I thought I was finally free from him and all the pain. I thought it was over but I was wrong. After he came out he started stalking me wherever I went. He would pop up and hit me whenever he could. Finally I decided there was just no way I was going to take it anymore. Without going into details, I’ll simply say that I scared him so badly that he hasn’t bothered me in a long time.
Looking Ahead in Life
There are many things that could have been done differently for me and for my son. The cops could have helped me. The child welfare system could have helped me while I had my son with me. I’ve learned over the years that when the system isn’t working right you can and should fight the system. I’ve also learned to work within it-I continue to work as a parent leader at Foundling.
But now that I have my son with me, I don’t want to look back at the lost six years as a tragedy. I cry much less than I used to because I see how much my son and I have been able to overcome. Instead I think the lessons I’ve learned from all the negatives of the past nine years are invaluable. Life is a lesson learned, and if you have not learned, you have not lived life.
SIDEBAR: Should Children of Abused Mothers Stay at Home? By Antwuan Garcia
One afternoon, Sharwline Nicholson’s ex-boyfriend stopped by her apartment and started to hit her because of rumors that she was with another man. He fractured her ribs, injured her head and broke her arm. Nicholson ended up in the hospital, and her kids ended up in foster care. In many states, parents who do not protect their children from witnessing violence are considered neglectful. That’s why Nicholson’s kids were taken. But Nicholson believed it was wrong for her to lose her kids just because a man entered her home and hurt her. So she sued the system. In a landmark decision last year, a federal judge ruled that New York City’s foster care system cannot remove children from a home only because of a violent incident between parents. Carolyn Kubitscheck, a lawyer on the Nicholson case, said most batterers are not a threat to the children. “Most batterers are very much in control. For example, they never hit their bosses,” she told the Gotham Gazette. On the other hand, it’s not healthy for children to witness violence at home. Domestic violence between parents makes kids feel scared, nervous, depressed and angry. And 60 percent of kids living in homes with domestic violence are themselves abused. That’s why the judge ruled that kids in New York City can’t be taken away because of a single violent incident, but parents can be considered neglectful if their kids are exposed to ongoing violence in the home. There are no easy answers in domestic violence cases. Violence does hurt kids, but so does being separated from their parents. Alisa Del Tufo, who runs the Urban Justice Center’s Anti-Violence Project in New York City, says there’s one option that might help: “Give kids more responsibility to decide when to say, ‘I know how to handle this,’ and when to say, ‘I want to get out.'” FCYU-2003-05-13b If you think your friend is abusing his partner:
o Confront your friend and point out his abusive attitudes and behaviors when you see them.
o Talk about the consequences of violence. Abusive behaviors build fear, not love, and physical and sexual assault are against the law.
o Encourage him to get help. Let him know that it will probably happen again and may be worse the next time.
o Phone a crisis help line to find out about resources in your community (see page 5).
o If he is willing to accept responsibility for his actions and get help, stand by him as a friend. -from Safe Horizon’s Quest for Peace
