don’t Be Too Casual

Practicing for the Interview

I’m interested in getting a custodial job, but interviews make me feel like I’m at the principal’s office. I don’t like sitting there being judged by someone who’s asking me why I left a job or what my weaknesses are. So to deal with the anxiety, I usually think of the interviewer as just a new person I’m meeting.
When I talk to someone I don’t know, I want them to recognize my sense of humor, my sincerity, and my honesty. I don’t want to be boring. I imagine that taking this approach during a job interview will show the interviewer how interesting I am, and see that hiring me will make their company more interesting.
However, doing a mock job interview with career counselor Katherine Jo made me realize that potential employers aren’t asking themselves, “Which of these candidates is most fun and interesting?” They’re asking: “Does she have the skills to do the job? Will she have the motivation to do the job? And will she fit into the workplace?”
Many of my answers may show that I have a good personality, but I need to work on showing my skills and drive to do the job. Here’s what I learned when Katherine asked me these questions:
“Hello, how are you?”

My answer: Good, how you doin’?

Better answer: Good and how are you?

Katherine said, “How you doin’?” was too casual. She said that I have to be more formal. I can introduce myself, saying “Hi, I’m Chimore Mack, nice to meet you,” or I can say, “Fine, and how are you?” which shows mutual respect.
“What is your biggest weakness?”

My answer: To be honest, my weakness is time management. I’ll probably be late to work.

Better answer: I get along with everyone and I sometimes find myself being social while working, but I get the job done.

Katherine explained that saying you’ll be late to work shows that you’re unreliable and would result in the employer not even considering you for the job. It’s important to be honest, but you shouldn’t talk about a weakness that would prompt an employer to think, “I can’t hire you!”
My improved answer, explaining that I’m social, is a real weakness. But hidden in that answer is a strength, too: I get along with everyone. That’s something an employer would be happy about.
No matter what weakness you talk about, it’s good to explain how you’re working on it. For example, if you do blurt out that time management is your weakness, give examples of what you’re doing to correct it, like using a planner.

“What do you like about custodial work?”

My answer: I love cleaning, but I also like that the boss doesn’t bother me. I can just do my job and leave.

Better answer: I like cleaning everything up, making everything smell nice, and feeling like I’ve accomplished something.
I actually said everything in both the first and second answers. Katherine explained that what I said about loving the job was good, but the “boss not bothering me” comment showed that I don’t like authority. When she said that, I laughed because I knew I shouldn’t have said it as soon as it left my mouth. I have to watch what I say because that answer would prompt an employer to immediately think, “She’s not a good candidate.”

“What makes a team player?”

My answer: A team player is someone who listens. I have been trying to work on not cutting people off when they’re talking.
Better answer: A team player is someone who listens, provides ideas about how to achieve the team’s goal, and performs the job.
Katherine explained that, while it’s good that I’m working on my bad habit of interrupting people, it’s not a great idea to share a weakness when that’s not what the question is about.
After talking to Katherine, I see how I can be more strategic with my answers.

Tips For Your Job Interview
¥ Remember that every question an employer asks in an interview is trying to find out one of these three things: Can you do the job? (Do you have the skills and education necessary?); Will you do the job? (Are you motivated?); Will you fit into the workplace? All your answers should, in some form, say “Yes” to these questions.
¥ Practice! Ask someone to do a mock interview with you so you can practice answering standard interview questions with ease. This can help calm your nerves, and if you record the interview, you can watch and critique your answers. Did you stay on topic? Did your responses show that you can do the job, that you’re motivated, and that you’re easy to work with? If not, keep practicing.
¥ Before you get to the interview, do some research. Find out everything you can about a company, so you have a better idea of what the job is and how to fit in at the company. Go to their website and read the “about” section. If you’re applying at a store, visit the store and see what they sell and the responsibilities of people in the job you want.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.