Does Cheating Run in the Family?

Back in Jamaica in 2007, before I moved to New York, my mom and I were chilling in the kitchen when she asked, “Who are you going out with?” I was shocked. I didn’t realize that my mother knew that I had a boyfriend.
“Alex, why?” I responded. She gave me a nasty look.
“Why are you with him?”
“I like him. He’s very nice and he is very cute,” I told her.
“You should not be with him. You need to leave that guy,” she said.
“Why?”
“Because of his father’s background. Like father, like son,” she said.
I had no idea what she meant, but she wouldn’t say anything else. I thought Alex’s father was cool. He seemed kind and helpful, and he was always smiling.
Later that week, Alex picked me up from school. I wanted to ask him about his dad so badly, but I didn’t know how he would react. Finally, when we came to a stop near my house, I told Alex what my mom had said and asked what she could mean.
He looked uneasy, but he started talking. He told me that his father regularly cheated on his mother, and that he, Alex, even had other outside siblings as a result. Apparently, it was common knowledge, but I was shocked.
Uneasy
I was surprised because his mother and father were always together and they seemed like the two coolest people on earth. I was also scared of getting hurt. Maybe my mom was right and Alex would be like his father and cheat on me.
When I asked him why he didn’t mention any of it earlier, he said, “I knew you would react this way, that you would get scared and probably want to leave me.” I felt bad. I liked him, but he was right. Now I was thinking of leaving him. We sat in silence staring at each other for a minute.
“I can’t assure you that I won’t cheat because no one is perfect,” Alex finally said. “But I will try to do my best. I really like you, and I don’t want to hurt you.” He said that he was nothing like his father, but I was still confused and uneasy. I didn’t know what to believe.
Like Father, Like Son?
After thinking things through, I decided to stay with Alex. I had already fallen for him and I didn’t want to see him hurt. Plus, I didn’t want to judge him for his father’s actions.
But afterward, my mom and I started having arguments about whether or not I should break up with Alex. Although I didn’t want to break it off with him, I did really care about my mom’s take on the matter. After all, if she hadn’t mentioned his father’s background, I wouldn’t have known.
I also knew that, even though it’s unfair to judge someone by another person’s actions, children do tend to follow the patterns of their parents.
My own brother and my father are similar in a lot of ways, and I am a lot like my mother-which was another thing that worried me. I didn’t want to follow in my own mother’s footsteps when it came to relationships.
My parents live in separate houses and are never seen together. My mother practically raised my siblings and me by herself. Although my father was around, he was never there for us financially. When we asked for things, his typical response was, “You’re not doing anything for me, so why should I give you my money?” I think he is selfish. I wouldn’t want a husband like that.
Part of the reason my mother didn’t want me to be with Alex is because she worries that I will end up like her and fall for someone who doesn’t treat me well. And I understood what she was saying: Children can re-live their parents’ mistakes when it comes to relationships.
For example, I know that if you grow up in a house where your parents fight constantly-even if they tell you not to follow their example-you may still go out there and find someone you clash with.
Similarly, it sometimes feels like I am destined to end up with a bad husband like my mother because I copy her a lot.
A New Path
In the end, it wasn’t cheating that broke us up. Alex and I were together for three years before I moved from Jamaica to New York. Shortly after that, I told him I didn’t think it was going to work out because long distance was too hard.
We still talk almost every day, and I still have feelings for him. He was the only guy that I ever liked so much.
Although it ended, I learned some things from being with Alex. I learned not to cheat. It might sound strange, but every time I was tempted, it felt like acting on that impulse would be repeating what his father did to his mother. Alex always said he wouldn’t want to be like his father because he knows how much cheating hurts a family, and that stuck with me.
Also, I’ve found out that we can learn from our parents’ mistakes so we don’t go through the same struggles. Although it gets irritating when my mother tells me what to do, especially when it comes to choosing someone, I will follow her advice in future relationships. She says to choose someone who “doesn’t just love you because you are cute but because you are who you are.”
And that’s what I am doing. I will try to have a friendly relationship with a boy first and then see how it works out, instead of jumping into anything. I am trying my best not to follow my parents’ path.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.