Black male students are in trouble. Over half of them drop out of New York City public schools. And they are much less likely to go to college than Black girls. Black boys face tremendous pressure to underachieve. One of them is the fear of “acting White.”
If a Black male has a 95 average and he is editor of the school newspaper, is he “acting White?” Does “acting Black” mean failure or mediocrity? Some people seem to think so.
According to Jeffery Flours, 15, of Edward R. Murrow HS, the term “acting Black” brings to mind several negative images, including “cursing, selling drugs, drinking, smoking weed, hanging out, and going with the girls.”
Kenneth Bell, 21, added that many young people think “robbin’ and stealin’ is ‘acting Black,’ also making fast money.”
Robert Smith, 15, of Midwood HS, disagreed: “There’s no such thing as ‘acting Black.’ You should just act yourself.”
But for many Black males, there is such a thing as “acting Black” and “acting White” and most of the descriptions of “acting Black” are not favorable. Many Black male youths do not excel because they are more concerned with being accepted by their peers, which can involve rejecting the demands of both teachers and employers. They fear that if they go to class, study, get good grades, and speak standard English, or put in a hard day’s work, their friends will think they’re “acting White.”
“It’s true,” said Jeffery ” ’cause now if Black boys go to class and do their work and pass their classes, his friends make fun of him and tell him he’s a nerd or he’s ‘acting White’…If you wanna be something in life, you a nerd.”
How About ‘Acting Asian’
Why don’t they say going the library is acting Chinese [or Asian]?…It’s stereotypes,” said Randy Smith, 18, of Midwood HS.
Randy doesn’t think fear of success stems from fear of acting White. He thinks it comes from having a short-term perspective.
“They [Black males] just don’t think they have to work as hard. They want to be popular now and be successful later. …It hasn’t been instilled in them that they have to work hard in the beginning to be successful through the rest of their life.”
Peer pressure is a powerful influence for Black males, and the pressure not to act white is particularly strong. For many guys, ‘acting White’ means doing well in school, so many Black males cut classes, don’t study, and some even drop out.
Omar Jerome, 18, of Edward R. Murrow HS explained: “When you see your friends having fun and you have to go to class, you think ‘Why should I go to class [when] I could be having fun?’ ” He admitted that he sometimes yields to the pressure: “When I’m thinking they’re having more fun than me, I’ll leave the class and don’t go to school for the day.”
Wanting To Fit In
Andre Beckford, 20, who attends Borough of Manhattan Community College, also admitted that his friends have a strong influence on his academic performance: “Most definitely they influenced me. You want to fit in…They influenced me a lot.”
But Kenneth said he is able to resist negative peer pressure. “If they want to stop me from doing something constructive, then [I don’t allow them to] influence me,” he said.
Some Black males try to develop strategies for both doing well and avoiding the name-calling and negative peer pressure. Randy said one of the high-achieving Black students in his high school was also involved in the African-American Council and other extra-curricular activities. Yet he was never perceived as ‘acting White.’
Anthropologists Signithia Fordham and John Ogbu found that some bright students become good athletes, or class clowns to disguise their academic achievements.
Educator Dr. Jawanza Kunjufu, in a book entitled “To Be Popular or Smart: The Black Peer Group,” said that in school he was a good dancer and roller skater. This helped deflect criticism of his excellent academic performance and his participation on the college debate team.
Nerd, Brainiac, ‘Acting White’
And anthropologists Fordham and Ogbu, report that name-calling is a common form of peer pressure against academic striving. In an article entitled “Black Students’ School Success: Coping with the Burden of Acting White,” they say that a student who studies hard is often called a nerd or a brainiac. This causes many students to resist striving academically because they don’t want to be rejected by their peers.
Dr. Kunjufu argues that the media play a part in Black males’ attitude toward academic effort and success. Television glorifies Blacks in professional sports and music, but not in other fields.
“What they see on television and in the newspapers has a big influence on them…All they see is the Black football player, basketball player, the rapper, and the boxer… That’s what they wanna be more like,” said Andre. He added that we seldom see educated, hard-working Black men featured on the news.
Low Teacher Expectations
Low expectations from teachers are another factor which can discourage Black males.
“I feel that when we go to class [the teachers] feel that Black males don’t work as hard. [When] they see you’re trying to make an effort to learn, they get surprised,” said Omar.
Randy disagreed, saying that how a student is treated by a teacher largely depends on his attitude in class: “Once you get into class and participate, you don’t have a problem with teachers.”
While Andre admitted that he never experienced a teacher expecting less from him because he’s Black, he noted that White students often get higher grades for doing the same level of work as Black students. “I get along well with most of my teachers but I prefer Black teachers.”
Barry Oscar, a teacher at Edward R. Murrow HS didn’t think low expectations or low self-esteem caused students to do poorly in school. “I don’t really see the low self-esteem. I see more of wanting to hang out in the halls. It’s almost like an addiction.”
Asked if he had low expectations of Black males he responded: “I expect everybody to do their best.”
“I try to expect the same from every student. Every student is different, every student learns at a different pace,” explained Susan Schylander, another teacher at Murrow.
The Role of Parents
Parents also play a vital role in their child’s academic performance. Without parental support, it is extremely difficult to excel in school.
“[My mother] over my shoulder-she pushes me. I don’t think I would take school seriously if it wasn’t for her,” acknowledged Robert.
Oscar noted that in his experience as a teacher, the foundation for higher achievement comes from the home. “I think it has to come from the home. The home is the strongest. The school is not the cure for the problems. I think if a kid comes from a well structured home and there are certain expectations that the home has for him then you have a kid achieving.”
Schylander agreed: “A lot of times students come from parents that don’t encourage reading or cultural activity. Therefore, they become less prepared for school. You have to have a backup at home to become a good student. You have to have discipline at home to achieve.”
Dr. Kunjufu stresses communication between home and school in his books on education. The schools need to make clear exactly what they want parents to do. And parents need to spend time with their children, talk to them and encourage them to strive academically.
Some Have Low Expectations of Themselves
And some Black students may have low expectations for themselves. For most of American history, Blacks have been prevented from rising to positions which reflect their skills and experience. They see the effects of the “job ceiling” in their community: talented people who were only allowed to rise to a certain level, and then were prevented from going any higher. Black youths recognize this and many question why they should study hard when their path to success may be blocked by forces they can’t control. This attitude, even if it is unconscious, can make it hard to do well in school.
Unfortunately, too many factors which contribute to poor academic performance in school-negative peer pressure, fear of ‘acting White,’ low teacher expectations, and lack of parental involvement-are a fact of life for many Black males.
SIDEBAR: Black Females
Do Black females feel as much pressure to underachieve as Black males? And how are Black girls affected by peer pressure, fear of ‘acting White,’ low teacher expectations, and lack of parental involvement? For one thing, Black girls’ self-esteem is more centered on family, and less centered on being accepted by their peer group. “The guys have more [negative] peer pressure than the girls,” claimed Robert Smith, 15, a freshman at Midwood HS. Teachers Expect More From Black Girls “I think [teachers] expect more from [Black] females. Most [girls] have longer attention spans. They’re more geared to studying,” observed Andre Beckford, 20, who attends Borough of Manhattan Community College. “The girls in my classes did well. The guys did all right, but we could have done better.” “[Teachers] feel girls are the only ones who are going to do their homework and guys are going to hang out,” added Kenneth Bell, 21. Dr. Kunjufu argues that some Black mothers “raise their daughters and love their sons.” In short, there’s a double standard-they discipline their daughters and expect more from them than they do from their sons. Omar Jerome, a senior at Edward R. Murrow HS, made a prediction: “I feel there’s going to be a Black president and it’s going to be a woman.”
