Dear Mom: Take It Down a Notch

Names have been changed.
“Where do you plan on going to college?” I asked my friend Jane one day during English class.
“I don’t really want to go to college,” she replied.
“Yeah, me neither,” I said, “but since you really can’t do anything with your life without it, I guess I have no choice. And besides, I think it’ll be a fun experience.” I was expecting her to agree with me, but what I got was a little different.
“Well, I already know that I’m going to make it as a singer, so I don’t need to go to college,” Jane said.
I didn’t know how to respond. I’ve heard the girl sing and she’s pretty good, but “I don’t need college”? She isn’t that great. Plus, I didn’t realize she took her music so seriously since she doesn’t do anything to promote it, like posting videos on YouTube or Facebook.
Finally, I said, “don’t you think that you should go to college anyway, just in case that doesn’t work out?” She is, after all, a good student. But she insisted that she doesn’t need it.
I can’t help wondering what Jane will do with herself after high school. Does she plan on just sitting around, waiting to be discovered?
I also can’t help wondering where her confidence-I should say over-confidence-came from. Maybe her parents pumped her up by telling her she could achieve anything she wanted.
My Mom the Cheerleader
For as long as I can remember, my mom has told me, “You can be anything you want to be.” Thankfully, I’ve never been the type to have unrealistic dreams. From the age of about 6, I wanted to be a veterinarian. Then, in 7th grade, I changed my mind and decided I wanted to be a psychologist.
My mom’s response was, “You can do both!” Realistically, I can’t. That would mean two advanced degrees in two different areas, which I’m definitely not up for. But my mom still tells me this. In her mind, she’s doing something good.
Loving parents encourage their kids to pursue their dreams and because of that, many children grow up truly believing that they can do or be anything they want. In some ways, that’s great. Boosting a child’s confidence is an important part of being a parent, teacher, or even friend.
My Voice of Reason
The problem comes when kids focus on unrealistic dreams-like becoming stars-and start to believe that they will reach their goals just because they want it so much. By telling them they can accomplish literally anything, some parents may be setting their kids up to become over-confident. And over-confidence is a weakness, not a strength.
The thing is: Not everyone will make it as a famous singer, or actor, or sports star. Because so many people want to be famous, attempting to get there is like trying out for a competitive team. If 25 kids are trying out for 10 spots, you have to know that you’re not all going to get the spot.
Yeah, those 10 kids who make it are thrilled, but what happens to the other 15? If you don’t at least acknowledge the possibility of not getting it and explore alternative ideas, you’re setting yourself up for disappointment. That’s what the voice of reason in my head has always told me.
It’s important for parents to be realistic-in a nice way, of course. I’m not suggesting telling your children that they can’t do something; I’m just saying you should let them know that their plans might not work out. Perhaps you can offer other options to explore as backup plans. (Just like I suggested to my friend that she go to college.)
When I have kids, that’s what I’ll do-because encouragement is important, but so is honesty.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.