Dancing Around the Issues

The dance concert has been an annual event at my school for several years. It was designed to show off the work students were doing in their dance classes. For the most part, that meant modern dance. No one ever had a problem with this until the ethnic make-up of the school started to change.
Like most private schools, the students used to be mostly wealthy and White. But when I came three years ago, there was a pretty even balance between white and “minority” students. Now the student body is mostly Black and Latino. Everyone seems to be from the Caribbean (Jamaica, St. Lucia, Cuba, Puerto Rico, St. Croix) or the Caribbean Basin (Guyana, Colombia, Costa Rica, Honduras, Ecuador).
The changing student population and the clash between different cultures and generations has been the source of a lot of controversy and debate at my school over the last couple of years. The dance concert is really just one manifestation.
A Hip-Hop Festival?
Many of the newer students can already dance, but it’s not modern dance and they didn’t learn to do it in school. They dance hip-hop, club music. They bring with them a style of dance quite different from what’s being taught. These dances, even though they aren’t being taught in class, have become a small but lively part of the dance concert.
Recently, the dance teacher expressed concern that the concert was becoming a “Hip-Hop Festival.” She said she didn’t consider Hip-Hop to be dancing of great difficulty on a “conceptual” level, the way modern dance was. For her, Hip-Hop had no meaning.
But did the modern dances have meaning? It’s true some were really good. One girl choreographed a dance about her father’s death. I don’t think anyone in the audience knew what it was about, but whether you knew it or not, it was still very moving.
Another year, a girl made up this very jazzy and sensual dance to an Eric Clapton song. A row of girls danced across the back of the stage, running around the backdrop and getting back on line, creating the illusion that the line was continuous and neverending. Meanwhile, the lead dancer (and choreographer) danced around this boy in a way that was very seductive, but tasteful.
Showing Off For the Boys
Not all the modern dances were like that, however. We used to call some of them “CFM [Come F-k Me] dances.” They were done by girls in tight clothing, who seemed to be showing off their bodies more than their technique. We thought they were up there just to look good for the boys in the audience.
The main problem we had with the modern dances, however, was that there were always too many. One year in particular, there were at least eight which featured the same girls doing basically the same moves, only in a different order, different costumes, and to different music.
On the other side of the controversy, a lot of the complaints about the way our new dances were ruining the tradition came down to the response they were getting from the audience. Our theater is small and dark, and when house music blasts from speakers at the sides and the audience interacts with the dancers on stage it becomes almost like a club scene (but better organized).
There was one hip-hop dance a few years ago in which some of the boys jumped off the stage and started dancing with some of the girls in the front row. Members of the audience, especially Blacks and Latinos, like to participate and encourage the dancers by cheering them on, shouting their names, singing, clapping to the beat and dancing in our seats.
A Culture Gap
Others, particularly White parents and teachers, seem to take objection to this. During a powerful step dance to the song, “Sweat,” about the freeing of South Africa, many of us were compelled to react, again, vocally. The dance teacher wasn’t accustomed to this. She thought it was being disrespectful to the dancers and the other members of the audience. In fact, it was just the opposite: In joining them we were paying them the biggest compliment we knew how, demonstrating that we enjoyed it so much we wanted to be a part of it.
There were also complaints about the dances themselves. One parent wrote the school to say that the dance concert was not a club and ought to be taken more seriously, that dances like ours would never be permitted at a reputable school. On that occasion, the dance teacher recognized an attempt to limit our right to self-expression for what it was and backed us up.
But she too had reservations about some of the hip-hop dances-one in particular. It was done to a club song called “Stomp.” Near the end of the dance, three Latino students lay face down on the stage, a boy in the middle with a girl on either side, and they all did a move similar to a push-up. The rest of the dancers (all Black) stood behind them and cheered them on, waving their hands in the air and making barking sounds along with the music.
A Savage Act?
The dance teacher insisted that this part be cut out because she said it looked too much like the gang rape scene in “The Accused.” This reference to a savage act was bizarre to us. The dance had absolutely nothing to do with rape or anything of the sort. The dancers on the floor weren’t even touching each other. There was no plot. It was simply a dance.
It was a rather good dance as well. We had had dances before that weren’t well planned and came off a little crude-this wasn’t one of those. There were four boys standing across the back of the stage, silhouetted in red. Seven girls were spread out further upstage and did a clean, energetic series of moves, both in unison and playing off one another.
About halfway through, the girls started dancing in a circle and the boys joined in. The best part came near the end with a substitute for the move that had been censored.
Three of the boys stood in their earlier positions with the background this time flashing red and blue. They waved their arms in the air and barked along with the others who were moving out to the edge of the stage. At that point many of us in the audience got caught up in the energy of the dance and joined in, waving our hands in the air and dancing in our seats.
The kids at my school who dance hip hop and have also taken modern dance classes have adapted to that style rather nicely. It even influences their own style. Unfortunately, many of those who have spent years learning modern dance, haven’t had such an easy time picking up the hip hop dancing that a growing number of their peers are doing.
I recently spoke to our dance teacher about some of these issues and while she said she has nothing against hip-hop, there isn’t anything about it that particularly interests her either. She said it was very “stylized” and the tendency among students who do it is merely to copy. “Dance in a school should challenge people’s minds,” she added. “Copying moves isn’t that.” Her technique, she maintains, demands more of the dancer in the way of originality. I don’t think she really understands.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.