As a lifelong Brooklyn resident, I was curious to see how a Black family living there in the 1970s would be portrayed on the screen…especially by Spike Lee, since he’s one of the few successful Black filmmakers out there.
While I was sure that he wouldn’t show Brooklyn as a modern-day Wild Wild West, I didn’t want to see the Huxtables either. In Crooklyn, we’re not given either extreme.
Instead, we’re shown a family where one of the parents is unemployed and the other is a school teacher struggling to make ends meet. The title gave me the idea that the movie was going to be about a bunch of thieves from Brooklyn, but the worst crime is when 10-year-old Troy steals her brother’s coin collection to buy some ice cream. And the worst fighting is with hands, not weapons.
Crooklyn takes you back to a time when children really were innocent. In the very first scene, you see the kids playing games like Steal the Bacon, Red Light, Green Light, and Hopscotch. Memories of my childhood in Bed-Stuy flashed through my mind when I saw that.
It’s Ok To Be Flatchested
Troy (Zelda Harris), who is the main character, reminded me of myself in a lot of ways. When the girls in Troy’s neighborhood begin to experience puberty, she feels out of place because she’s flatchested. She tries to solve the problem by stuffing her training bra with bathroom tissue, until she realizes that this isn’t getting her anywhere and that it’s OK to be flatchested. She grows to accept this as a part of her identity.
I can understand why she does what she does because I’m a flatchested girl myself (although I never stuffed my bra-I didn’t see the point in setting myself up for ridicule). Most young girls feel self-conscious about their breasts, especially when they see their friends developing way ahead of them. I thought that Spike handled the issue in a funny yet sensitive manner, which I appreciated.
Like most parents, Carolyn (Alfre Woodard) and Woody (Delroy Lindo) can’t seem to agree on how to discipline their kids, and this causes a certain amount of domestic strife. Carolyn and her son Clinton argue because he wants to watch a Knick game on a school night. When he defies her by turning the TV back on after she’s cut it off, she comes close to hitting him, but her husband, Woody intervenes and pulls her out of the room. I could identify with these family fights too.
A lot of people may be under the impression that Crooklyn is a comedy but it’s really a drama. At one point Carolyn throws Woody out of the house in anger. And the most emotional scene comes when Woody has to tell the kids that Carolyn is very sick and won’t be leaving the hospital as soon as they’d hoped.
Serious Fun
But there are some funny scenes in the movie. When the family is sitting at the dinner table and Woody suddenly burps real loud, for example, that really made me laugh. Another funny scene is when Troy is visiting her Aunt Song in Virginia and Aunt Song loses her dog. The dog pops up where you’d least expect it and the look on her aunt’s face is hilarious.
Like most movies, Crooklyn also has its share of silliness and a few boring moments. Although I liked it OK, it’s not a movie that’s going to appeal to everyone. If you want to see a comedy, try You So Crazy starring Martin Lawrence. If you want to see action and adventure, check out The Crow with Brandon Lee. But if you want to see a serious, realistic drama, then Crooklyn is the movie for you.
“Crooklyn”: It’s a Family Affair
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.