How can you cope with a mentally ill sibling? We talked to Russell Saunders, a therapist who has worked with children and families for more than 15 years.
YCteen: How might it affect you to have a mentally ill sibling? Is it common to feel resentful?
Russell Saunders: When there’s a child in the family who is having mental health issues, a lot of time and resources are being allotted to the kid who’s having the problems. Often, the other child might feel they are not getting attention. I would think that resentment would be a pretty normal reaction.
Another thing that happens a lot is that the healthier sibling becomes “parentified”-that means a kid has basically had to take on some of the role of an adult, either by helping take care of the mentally ill sibling or by helping raise other siblings in the house or take on other responsibilities. You’re pressed into service early.
Sometimes there might be some kind of nonverbal pressure from the parent or the family-you’ve got to be good, you can’t cause problems in school, etc. That’s unfortunate. It’s a burden on the child to have to be the “normal” one. Nobody’s perfect. If the burden’s on you to always be the smiling, optimistic one, that’s not realistic. It can be an emotional strain.
YCteen: How can you deal with those issues?
Saunders: You need to feel like your life is not taken over by your sibling’s mental illness. Channel your experiences in a positive way-through writing or keeping a diary, making art, or by joining some kind of proactive organization. Maybe learning meditation. Anything that can foster your own growth. And some of that might be just finding ways to relax, like sports or spending time with friends, maybe joining a support group.
Look for outside support: Not necessarily a therapist, maybe a guidance counselor, another relative, a coach-someone you can talk to and who can be an ally for you.
YCteen: What can you do if you have a family member who’s mentally ill and your parents want to keep it a secret?
Saunders: I think secrets are corrosive, and it’s especially hard if you don’t agree that it should be a secret. But an adolescent still has to kind of follow the rules of the parent-so that puts them in kind of a catch-22.
I’ve had adult patients who had mentally ill parents and it was supposed to be a secret when they were growing up. Looking back they realized there were all these weird things going on in their homes and they weren’t allowed to tell their friends. As an adolescent, your friends are your support network. To not be able to talk with your friends about what’s going on in your life-that makes you isolated. That’s an additional stress.
I don’t know if there’s a great answer for this except that I think that you have to take care of yourself. That might mean confiding in a good friend, or a relative you trust who won’t go back and tell your parents-talking to someone so you don’t feel so isolated.
YCteen: How can you talk to your parents about how your sibling is affecting you?
Saunders: Ask to speak to your parent privately. Tell them, “This is a problem for me and I need some help here, I’m not sure what to do.” If you feel like your parent might not respond well, or the issue feels too combustible, enlist a trusted adult to help you. Another relative, a guidance counselor at school, a favorite teacher, a family friendâthey might be able to be a go-between, or someone who can help you figure out how to talk to your parent.
If there’s a therapy team working with the mentally ill person, that might be helpful here. You or an adult you’ve asked for help can advocate for the team to work with the whole family.
Addressing your needs with your parents is an ongoing process; it’s not going to be solved in one conversation.
YCteen: How can you balance wanting to help your sibling and your family with protecting yourself?
Saunders: Negotiate boundaries based on how physically and emotionally safe you feel with that particular sibling. For a sibling who sucks all the air out of the room because they’re so emotionally needy, you can decide, I’ll spend this amount of time with you but then I need to go play soccer or go see my friends. If personal safety is an issue you might need to spend less time with that sibling than you might want to. You need to monitor your own feelings about whether you feel safe.
It can be confusing. I think the more other people in the family are aware of the situation and that it’s difficult for kids to figure out, the better. Look around in your life and find your allies.
Trust in your feelings. Ask yourself, “Is this too much for me?” Feelings exist to provide us with some signposts. If yours are telling you something’s wrong, that can spur you to take care of yourself in this situation.
Getting Help
National Alliance on Mental Illness
www.nami.org
The website for the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) offers a wealth of information about living with mental illness. Click on “Find your local NAMI” to find the chapter nearest you and search for support groups and other resources.
Mental Health America
nmha.org/go/information/get-info/mi-and-the-family
This page includes information for families about how to recognize and cope with mental illness in a family member.
This story is part of the health literacy series, which is generously supported by the Cigna Foundation.
Coping With a Mentally Ill Sibling
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.