In late January, PBS will be airing two documentaries that deal with Black struggle. The first, on the life of Bayard Rustin, showcases how African-Americans had to fight for our civil rights, while the second documentary, which delves into the modern day lynching of James Byrd Jr., shows a complete violation of them.
Brother Outsider: The Life of Bayard Rustin is about a powerful civil-rights leader who put his life on the line for racial justice. Rustin organized the first Freedom Ride through the South, organized the March on Washington and served time in jail for refusing to be drafted in World War II, in accordance with his philosophy of “peace is the way.” Despite his accomplishments, Rustin is often overlooked as a historical figure because he was gay.
Also overlooked was the racial ignorance held in the hearts of many citizens of Jasper, Texas. Two Towns of Jasper
documents the murder of James Byrd Jr., who was chained to a pickup truck and dragged to his death by White supremacists. The documentary follows the trial of the murderers and explores residents’ feelings about Byrd’s death.
Keshia: I liked the documentaries. They gave me insight on events that I probably wouldn’t have looked into. Back in elementary school, the only people we learned about during Black History Month were Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King Jr.
I was shocked to find out that King, the man behind the “I have a dream” speech, didn’t actually organize the March on Washington. It was Bayard Rustin. I’d never heard of Rustin and he’s had a huge impact on my life.
Reg: I know what you mean. I’d never heard or learned about him in school or on TV, either. This guy was the reason why the March on Washington was a huge success. But I think that he’s not as well known as other civil-rights heroes because he was gay and a member of the Communist Party in college. And he went to jail for refusing to sign up for the draft and for engaging in homosexual acts.
Keshia: He was arrested for being a “suspected sexual pervert.” He was in a car with two men! What kind of definition of pervert is that? I think the cops arrested him because he was a gay Black man with power. And it was used against him for the rest of his life. He was forced to back out of demonstrations because of threats that the charges would surface.
After watching the film, I gained more respect for Rustin than for any other Black civil-rights leader. He was held back from doing a lot of things because of his sexuality.
He was even threatened by Congressman Adam Clayton Powell Jr. Powell said that if Rustin didn’t pull out of the March on Conventions Project, which Rustin was organizing with Dr. King, he would tell the press that Rustin and King had sexual relations.
Powell thought that Rustin was an “immoral element” in the civil rights movement. But Rustin still got involved with other projects and despite Powell’s threats, King eventually put Rustin back on his advisory team.
Reg: What Powell threatened to do to Rustin and King was foul. Imagine what it would be like if people thought King were gay.
Keshia: It shows how damaging people’s prejudices can be. The fact that Rustin was gay didn’t change what he was trying to accomplish. And his sexuality wasn’t wrong. The only thing wrong was that he was shunned because of it. He was still an oppressed Black man, and the fact that he was gay made his struggle even worse.
Reg: Rustin fought hard to end discrimination, but sadly, the murder of James Byrd, discussed in Two Towns of Jasper, proves that racism still exists.
Keshia: For real. I can’t believe that in 1998 there could still be people in America who’d actually chain a man to a truck and drag him for nearly three miles-just because he’s Black. That’s insane.
Two of the three murderers belonged to a White supremacist group. They had racist tattoos and pictures of Black men hanging from trees.
I can’t comprehend how people can still be so ignorant.
Reg: That whole incident got me heated. Watching a couple of White folks in Jasper treat it like it was no big deal made me realize how low and heartless people can be. One White woman, talking about Byrd’s character, said, he’s not “the pillar of the community that they made him out to be.” This guy got dragged almost three miles and they’re talking about what he did when he was alive.
Keshia: It shouldn’t matter what he did while he was living. He could’ve been selling drugs and pimping ho’s-that doesn’t justify his death. What would she do if someone killed her child and then talked about what a terrible kid he or she was?
Reg: At least all three men were convicted. John King and Lawrence Brewer Jr. were convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death. Shawn Berry was also convicted of capital murder, but was sentenced to life in prison.
Keshia: It was historic. According to the film, it was the first time a Ku Klux Klan member got the death penalty for killing a Black man.
Reg: I felt justice was served. They deserved what they got.
Keshia: But I don’t think the death penalty was justified because no one has the right to decide if someone else should die. I don’t believe in hell, so I don’t think they’re suffering in death. The only people who’re suffering are the people who cared about them, and they aren’t the ones who committed the crime.
Another thing that bothered me is that the Jasper schools were behind schedule and so decided to turn days that are usually holidays or vacation days into school days.
One day that survived the cuts was Rodeo Day. The Rodeo Day parade started at 5 p.m. and the actual rodeo started at 7 p.m. The kids could’ve gone to school, done their homework and still would’ve had time for the parade.
Guess what day got cut? Martin Luther King Day! That’s a slap in the face. After how hard we struggled to get the day nationalized, they take it back. At a time like that. If I were in that town, I’d act like it was the 1950s and boycott school.
Reg: I know what you mean. I was happy when one of the community leaders told the head of schools there that he would let them take King’s birthday off the school calendar.
Keshia: Did you find any segments of the Bayard Rustin piece interesting?
Reg: Oh yeah! I found the Black Panthers vs. Rustin segment real interesting. They each had valid points about how to achieve equal rights. The Panthers wanted to achieve equality by any means necessary, including violence, and Rustin wanted to do it peacefully.
Keshia: I agree with some of the things that the Panthers were for, like equality for Black people. But some things I just couldn’t agree with, like their pro-segregation stance. How can people be separate and equal? You just can’t disengage relations with a whole race if you want to build tolerance.
So I’m curious, Reg, about what you thought of the documentaries overall. What’s the most valuable thing you’ve learned?
Reg: I learned that racism still exists. No matter how hard you try, people are still going to discriminate against others because of age, color, sex and culture.
Keshia: I thought that the Two Towns of Jasper had more of a personal edge because it was videotaped. The Rustin documentary seemed like an educational dictation you’d watch in school. It was still interesting, but won’t bring viewers into it as much as Two Towns of Jasper will.
Reg: Yeah. Still, I’d recommend both documentaries to my friends because they both have good information about African-American history.
Brother Outsider: The Life of Bayard Rustin premieres Monday, Jan. 20 at 10 p.m. on Channel 13-WNET.
Two Towns of Jasper airs on Wednesday, Jan. 22 at 9 p.m. on WNET.
Civil Rights, Then and Now
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.