Breaking the Blue Wall

Before interviewing some of New York’s finest, I really did not like cops. I thought they were all crooked. I thought that partly because of all the negative headlines I see about the cops: Cops Shoot African Immigrant or Cops Sodomize Innocent Man. As an African-American, you sort of drift away from the people who are supposed to protect you.
When I first heard about the Abner Louima case, I thought, “What are these cops doing?” And after the Amadou Diallo shooting, I thought, “Not again.” I was so shocked and disappointed by the police department, the mayor and the police commissioner.
It seemed like these men’s lives were not important to them. Mayor Giuliani said a few words on the subject and that was it. I think he spent more time talking about the Yankees.
What I saw in the media about the Louima and Diallo cases definitely shaped how I see the police. I wondered, “Is it a coincidence that the victims are Black and the cops are White?” I think not.
It seems like police brutality always happens to African-Americans. (Although, recently, cops shot and killed a White man armed only with a hammer. So maybe it’s not just about race.)
Their Side of the Story
Most people I know hate the cops, and I did, too, even though I’d never even spoken to a cop, or seen a police officer do anything wrong. So I decided to get their side of the story.
I talked with three members of the force: Officer Thompson, a Black officer in the 23rd precinct, Officer Enresman, a White officer in the 107th precinct, and Officer Hurd, a Black, female officer in the 6th precinct.
All three are youth officers, meaning they deal mostly with the young people who live in their precinct, and said they joined the force partly because they want to improve conditions for youth.
“Growing up in Harlem, you endure so many negative things-drug dealers and users, robbery,” said Officer Hurd. “I just felt in my heart I needed to do something about that.”
I felt happy when she said that because few people have role models in the ghetto.
Playing the Tough Guy
And I was glad to hear that citizens join the force because they are trying to better their community or someone else’s, not just for a job. I think being a police officer is one of the most important jobs.
Officer Thompson said the work is hard. When you’re a citizen, if you see someone getting beat up in the street, you don’t have to stop and help, but as a police officer, you do.
I think that could cause a lot of stress, and make the world seem dangerous. It can also change your perceptions of whether other cops are fair, Officer Thompson said.
Before he became a cop, if he was on the train or bus, he would see some things that cops were doing and maybe wonder if it was justified, Officer Thompson said. “But then when I became a cop, you see differently.”
The cops I met seemed like reasonable people, and I could understand the danger they probably feel out on the street. But some cops go too far playing the tough guy and hurt people because they’re in power.
Media Gives Cops No Credit
That’s why I think the media coverage of police brutality has been fair. But the officers said they feel like the media portrays them as public enemies.
“You never hear the media say Officer Hurd saved 13 children from a burning building or you never hear, ‘Officer So-and-So did a good job by cracking this drug thing,’ ” Officer Hurd said.
“The media doesn’t give the police department the credit it deserves,” Officer Thompson said.
Besides brutality, race was the other big concern on my mind.
I noticed that when I asked Officer Thompson about race relations in the precinct or his feeling about the Diallo tragedy, he would whisper. It seemed like he didn’t want the White officers to hear what he might say about racial issues.
He also avoided my questions. Instead of answering straight, Officer Thompson would say, “Oh, you know how it is,” when I asked what it’s like to be a Black officer on the force. I could tell that he was uncomfortable talking about it.
I think it must be difficult to be a Black cop, especially when the police department is being called racist by the public.
We Need More Black Cops
People have called Officer Enresman a racist, he said, but he thinks that when they see him with his daughter, they are sorry because his daughter is half Black.
“I know my intentions, and race has never been a factor to me. Never!” Officer Enresman said.
Still, all the officers agreed that the city should make a major effort to hire more minorities. “We should have more ’cause minorities are the majority here in the city,” Officer Hurd said.
I think it’s great that the NYPD is trying to get more minorities to join the police force. Maybe more diversity in the police department could help the police create better relationships with communities where they work.
Probably there wouldn’t be so many people saying things like, “I was treated unfairly because of my race.” I know I feel safer when I see a Black cop, because it’s the White cops who’ve been getting in the news for police brutality.
All cops would benefit if citizens trusted them more.
Before I spoke with the officers, I assumed they would be rude or act like they rule the world. But they seemed friendly. By talking to them I learned that they all aren’t as tough as they appear to be.
‘I’ve Never Had to Use My Gun’
Cops put out this image of themselves as being self-assured and macho. If they’re scared, they hide it. When they’re out on the street, they act that way so people will follow the rules. If they walked around looking careless and unaware, people would walk all over them.
In person, they didn’t seem so tough-guy-ish, though. At the precinct, the cops were relaxed, talking and eating. Seeing the cops acting like normal people made me feel better about them
I guess I had believed all cops are pretty violent, because when I asked them about carrying a gun, I was shocked that none of the officers had used her gun, and that they all said they hope they never have to.
“I’ve never been involved in a shooting,” Officer Thompson said, sounding relieved. “I wouldn’t know how to act.”
“I’ve never had to use my gun, nightstick or mace,” Officer Hurd said. “I use the tactics [for settling conflicts] that I was taught at home, and that’s the best weapon that I carry out with me while I’m on patrol.”
That really surprised me. Of course I didn’t think that cops really want to shoot at anyone, but I did wonder, “If they had to shoot at someone, what did they feel?”
On TV shows they show how cops are upset by shooting someone and need counseling. But in real life, I wondered if they would really care. These cops seemed like they would.
Interviewing cops made it easier for me to think of cops as individuals instead of as one large enemy. I also believe that many of them are not racist, although I still believe that some are. Now, if people around me are badmouthing the cops, I might not join in.
Of course, not everyone can interview the cops, so I think the cops need to reach out to teenagers so that young people’s attitudes can change.
Getting Cops and Teens to Talk
If teenagers could see that cops care about them, by having programs where cops talk to teens about problems, they might see that some cops are good people.
The cops told me about the Explore Program, which was designed to bring cops and young people together. They have meetings where teens can talk about whatever is on their minds, and the cops and teens go on field trips together.
I think the police department needs to create more programs to get kids and cops talking.
If teens saw cops listening to them or protecting them, maybe their opinions would be based less on a single incident they’ve heard about or the shocking brutality cases on the TV news. And if officers could not only enforce the laws, but also be a counselor and a friend to these kids, then juvenile crimes might go down.
Officer Enresman agreed with me. “The improvement between teens and officers comes from more dialogue,” he said. “It comes from keeping the communication open.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.