Ever since my brother and I reunited with our mom after foster care, when I was 8, she’s been overprotective. And as I get older, it’s bothering me more and more. My mother barely lets me do anything without her. She’s always trying to shield me from everything, but I feel she’s really just blocking my way.
I’m almost 18. That’s the age when you’re supposed to get freedom, but I’m not close to that yet. As my birthday comes closer, I realize all the ways my mother’s kept me from being ready to live on my own. I’ve been held back as a teenager so I wouldn’t get hurt.
But I would rather make mistakes and get hurt than watch everyone else live life. When I finally do get my freedom, I’ll still be afraid of all the people and things that are unfamiliar.
I read Lily Mai’s stories in YCteen, the sister magazine of Represent, written by New York City teenagers. I decided to interview her because her stories were about living with overprotective parents and being shy and insecure. But now she’s going to college and has her freedom.
Somehow Lily’s mother got the message that I want my mother to get: You can be my mother and still let me live my life.
Shut Off From Life
I was nervous before the interview. I don’t really have friends because I’m afraid of someone not liking me. My mom has something to say about everything I do or say. I hear her criticism in my head when I’m around new people and it shuts me up.
Lily has overcome some of my same insecurities and feelings of isolation. Her parents are from China, but she was born here in New York. She’s 20, a junior in college and still lives with her parents in Brooklyn.
“My parents grew up in a different culture,” Lily told me. “They didn’t grow up with computers or cell phones or nightclubs or bars or parties. They basically just ran after a rooster and killed dogs and cleaned and cooked.”
When Lily’s parents moved from China to New York, they had to work long hours. Lily’s an only child and they just put her in front of the TV. “Why go outside?” they said to Lily. “Just stay inside and do your homework.”
In high school, Lily’s parents still tried to keep her home. “I didn’t do anything that people my age were doing,” she said. “I had friends, but they were like me, quiet and shy. I’d never been to a party; I’d never been kissed. I was always in my room.”
Our situations are a little different: I don’t even get a chance to go to school (I’ve been home-schooled since 4th grade). Lily at least had some connection to the outside world, while I have to be by my mother’s side all the time.
Age of Independence
When Lily went to college, she kept living at home. Then she turned 18 and said to herself, “I can buy cigarettes now, I can vote, I can buy a plane ticket. That’s independence. If I can do those things, my mom should give me space.”
Lily began to drink and party and then one night, she didn’t come home at all and didn’t answer her Mom’s cell phone calls. Soon after that, her mother sat her down and said, “You’re 18, you’re educated, and you make your own choices now. You should know the consequences; I’m not always going to be there to tell you what’s good and what’s bad.”
Lily was glad to have her freedom, and she went a little wild. One time she drank so much she threw up in a Dunkin Donuts, then got on the subway alone and blacked out. When she came to, a man on the train was grabbing her thigh. She was so weak that she could only brush his hand away and say, “Stop.” He followed her off the train at her stop. Fortunately a woman near the subway stop saw the man and offered to walk Lily home.
Lily thinks there is a connection between her strict parents and her risky behavior. “When you’ve been sheltered and you finally get exposed to something you never thought you’d get your hands on, you sort of use it as an act of rebellion. I was too much in that feeling to worry about my safety. I just thought,’This is all new, I want to try this and this.'”
Bring on the Life Lessons
Lily said she’s also learned some hard lessons about boys. “I thought this guy at college really liked me, but he just wanted me for sex. I didn’t know there were guys who just want to hook up, and I let it depress me more than it should. Now I know what guys like that want and I know to tell them,’I don’t want that.'”
I think there’s a chance that I will go overboard with partying and boys in college, but I honestly don’t know if that’s my fear or my mother’s. I haven’t had the chance to experience parties, dating, or any social life really, so I don’t know how I’ll handle that. I think it’s good that Lily caught the situation before it got out of hand and that she learned from it.
Lily feels like she’s still trying to catch up with kids who started rebelling earlier. “The earlier you get experience, the easier it is to think quicker. I have a coworker who’s 25 and she’s done a lot and she’s read a lot. And she’s so much wiser, she thinks quicker, and if she’s being disrespected, she talks back. I’m not as strong as she is.”
I think when I’m older I’m going to wish I did a lot of things earlier because I know I’ll have to catch up during my adult years. I’m trying to learn what to do and what’s wrong and right. I’m trying to learn how to be OK with myself and not care so much about what others think of me. I have to do my practicing with my mom, though, because I don’t have many dealings with other people.
In order to get her mother to give her freedom, Lily stayed out all night and her mother finally got the point. I want my mother to get that point that she can’t control me forever, but it’s not in me to go over to someone’s house and stay without contact with my mother.
With a Little Help
I’m not sure yet how I’ll do it, but I will get free of my mother some day. And then I’ll have to deal with my insecurities. I’ve never rebelled, because I’m terrified of people. My mother’s judged me from head to toe. Lily also had to go through that judgment from her mother, and has had to learn how to get confidence.
Lily said that she used to feel insecure all the time. “When I was 15, 16 and writing here, I started to hate Manhattan. I was just watching TV and coming here, and everyone seemed to have better lives. I’d look in the bars and think I’d never fit in.”
Lily had a counselor her first two years of college, and having someone to talk to helped her break out of her shell. Making friends also raised Lily’s self-esteem. “There were two writers here who I started to hang out with a lot. Once we went to this wine bar in the Upper East Side, a really nice, dimly lit place with couches and people on laptops. And I thought’What am I doing here with these beautiful people?’ but it didn’t matter that I didn’t fit in because I had my friends with me.”
I wondered how Lily had gone from being alone in her parents’ house to making friends, and I asked her how she picks friends.
“People who show an interest in me, who ask me questions about my life,” she answered. “They need to handle my rambling and going off-topic, they need to handle that I ask a lot of questions. I like that back-and-forth.”
I think having friends as a teen helps you become who you are. You learn about life in some ways with your friends or from your friends. When I am out of the house now, I try to be myself without thinking so much.
Talking to Lily helped me realize that I will have to confront my mother before I can be free. I need her to realize that we are separate people even though I’m her child. Sometimes it feels like I’m the Terminator and my mom’s the chip that controls me.
Let Me Go
My mother wants me to stay with her and live her dreams, and one way she does that is to put her fears into me. Until recently, that worked. She always tells me that I must avoid boys because I could just get swept out of control and find myself pregnant. I know I have more control than that. She tells me I need her to protect me from a world that’s out to hurt me, but I’m realizing that everyone’s not out to get me. She tells me I’m rude and disrespectful whenever I express what I want or I feel. That’s kept me quiet around people, but now I’m starting to speak up.
Lily told her mother that at 18, she deserved her freedom, and it worked. Lily isn’t fat at all, but she said her mother picked on her for her weight her whole life.
“My Mom’s a size zero and she thinks I should be where she is. A more positive way of rebelling for me was to finally tell her to stop it. I said,’Mom, I’m happy with who I am and I’m in this body, not you, so as long as I like this body, you don’t have any right to say anything to me.’ And she hasn’t said anything since.”
I imagine the speech I would give my mother. I’d tell her that she can’t tell me what to do for the rest of my life. She has to let me live my own life or I’m going to just one day end up hating her for not letting me be me and for making me miss out on life.
Most important, she can’t just look at me from every angle and judge me. She shouldn’t break me down every chance she gets, to make me afraid to be on my own. That’s not what a parent is supposed to do.
I imagine giving this speech on the day I leave home, but maybe I need to give it sooner.
Breaking Free
A college girl who defied her strict parents inspires me
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.